WiFi security needs to be toughened up to bring the standard in line with its dramatically expanded remit, according to recommendations from an IEEE study group.
The IEEE – the organization which defines the 802.11 standards on which WiFi is based – now favors the use of randomly generated addresses to improve security and privacy. Currently, each WiFi device gets its own unique MAC (media access control) address, which is not encrypted, making it easy for the identifier to be traced to its user, and the user tracked.
Juan Carlos Zuniga, principal engineer at InterDigital and chair of the IEEE 802 privacy executive committee study group, explained that the shortcomings date back to WiFi’s original role – as a local area connection for stationary devices. However, over the years its functionality has been stretched to near-cellular levels of coverage and mobility, but security mechanisms have not kept pace. Whenever a user connects to a public WiFi network, the device’s identifier can be accessed, and its owner’s location detected.
“You can identify the walking path, where they work, where their live, what their likely income is, what their age range is, in a scarily easy way,” Zuniga said in an interview with CSO magazine. “Anywhere you have these WiFi identifiers today, anyone with simple PC tools can open them up and start sniffing the air.”
His group’s recommendations could be incorporated into the next major standard, 802.11ax, but that is not due to be commercialized for several years. However, as in many aspects of WiFi, the industry is likely to add its own remedies and let the standards catch up later. In the past, that has happened in various areas such as security and QoS, where de facto extensions (WEP and WPA for security, WEM for QoS) were even certified by the WiFi Alliance, before eventually being incorporated into the next 802.11 standards.
For this latest issue, vendors could generate random identifiers for their devices with a firmware update to the operating system (though older products might require hardware level changes). “Our study showed that this can be done, and the benefits are huge, and the problems that can be caused are very, very minimal,” Zuniga added. “You can easily go around them or fix them.” Problems might include a hotel charging a second time for a 24-hour WiFi access, because it detected a new identifier; or enterprise networks refusing to recognize and authenticate legitimate devices.