China’s breakneck 5G roll-out seems to be concentrating minds in neighboring India which relies on advanced wireless communications just as much for its competitive base, as well as societal aspirations. But the country will inevitably fall further behind China before it closes the gap, at least over 5G. This is not least because it has still not completed its 4G national roll out, with a 4G auction coming in 2021.
This has come to a head with a spat between two of the country’s leading entrepreneurs in the communications arena, Mukesh Ambani – who controls the country’s largest telco Reliance Jio – and Sunil Mittal, chair of number two Bharti Airtel. Ambani argues his company is ready to start offering 5G service in the second half of 2021 and is calling on the Indian government to clear the way for national roll-out to proceed then.
But Mittal argues that the domestic infrastructure is not yet ready to backhaul 5G effectively and that it would take two to three years to rectify this, during which 5G would be unable to deliver the promised performance or capacity. Ambani in turn differed by suggesting that Jio’s own 4G infrastructure could easily be upgraded for 5G because it is based on converged mobile/fixed infrastructure.
It seems like both may be right. Jio has invested heavily deploying fiber in major centers such as Mumbai and Delhi as a foundation for mobile as well as fixed services, and will be well placed to deploy 5G there. But nationally more work will have to be done even to bring many users up to 4G, and on that point Mittal and Ambani appear to agree.
Ambani himself pointed out that 300m Indian subscribers are still trapped in the 2G era and in July 2020 called for urgent policy measures to migrate them straight forward to 4G. He has repeatedly reiterated his argument that 5G rollout needs to be accelerated just to maintain the country’s status as a leading digitally connected nation.