India represents the best and the worst of the wireless opportunity for infrastructure vendors ‘ the best prospect, given China’s unpredictability, for a super-high growth market with rising income in the years ahead; but coupled with the worst prospect, in any large market, of making a serious profit on that growth. Both sides of that coin are currently highlighted by the activities of Indian incumbent BSNL, which is poised to award a $2bn GSM expansion contract and issue RFPs for its huge planned WiMAX build-out in 3.5GHz, on the eve of 2.5GHz spectrum also being freed up for mobile broadband in India. But amid all this opportunity, Nokia Siemens faces the risk of losing out in the GSM award, because it will not price down to the cut throat level set by Ericsson, possibly the only vendor ‘ because of its scale and ability to bundle in everything from backhaul to managed services ‘ that can make a commercial profit based on the sort of pricing levels Indian operators are demanding (and which will set benchmarks for other major developing economies and neighboring territories like Pakistan).
BSNL had originally split the huge GSM deal between NSN and Ericsson (about 40:60) but now is reported to be pressurizing the former to price match with the market leader or forfeit the deal. Ericsson has, during the wave of supplier consolidation in this sector, been the target of very public attacks from the chairmen of Alcatel-Lucent and NSN for making it, as Alcatel put it once, ‘impossible to compete’ with its aggressive pricing and bundling. For Ericsson, pricing low in a market like India is not just a question of its economies of scale but sometimes a calculated loss leader, that should directly result in more high margin deals in areas like managed services ‘ one of the key focuses for the Swedish giant in its quest to sustain margin ‘ and in future could lead to further, more valuable business as GSM operators start to introduce data services and mobile multimedia. In countries where GSM, rather than wireline voice or terrestrial television, are the main communications media, there is high expectation that, as incomes rise, all future media and internet applications, including TV, will be delivered from day one to mobile or portable devices, creating a potential future goldmine for an incumbent infrastructure supplier.
NSN and Alcatel-Lucent, still suffering the financial pain and turmoil of their respective mergers, have less leeway to take such risks than Ericsson, despite the leader’s recent shock results warning. Last week, NSN rejected an order from BSNL for 9m GSM lines because the price was only $80-$90 per line, compared to the $170-$177 specified in the original deal awarded to NSN and Ericsson. Ericsson confirmed that it had accepted the new rate, and then received an offer from BSNL to step into the void, although sources told the Hindustan Times that the vendor might not be able to take up the additional order because of the volume of work involved and the short timescales. “The current order (of 14m lines) itself is very large. And to add up on the existing order by almost 70% cent would not be easy. The order can be taken, but whether it will be delivered on time, will have to be seen,” the source said.
BSNL managing director Kuldeep Goyal told journalists that he has yet to decide whether to award the whole deal to Ericsson, float a new tender to existing GSM suppliers, or even renegotiate with NSN. If a new tender is held for the NSN portion, the other GSM suppliers to BSNL are Motorola, Nortel and Alcatel-Lucent. Motorola has probably blotted its copybook by engaging BSNL in legal action, while Alcatel-Lucent, which is laying 2m lines for BSNL in a separate rural-focused deal, could also have capacity issues. Since the French giant is also currently engaged in rolling out a $400m GSM/CDMA system for Reliance in India, sources hinted that it, too, might have problems meeting BSNL’s aggressive timescales.
BSNL had originally announced a tender for 45.5 million GSM lines in March 2006. The process for announcing the contract was delayed due to a court battle involving BSNL and Motorola, which had participated in the bid but was ousted on technical grounds.
The price pressure on GSM is clear from recent statistics from researchers at dell’Oro Group, which found that GSM revenues in the third quarter rose by just 7% on a 40% increase in base station shipments, a trend that the report largely attributed to Ericsson’s aggressive policies in a market which, contrary to many forecasts a few years ago, is far from dying or becoming a legacy, but is providing the basis of massive new build-outs for operators in many countries.
However, even Ericsson’s scale and range of offerings cannot entirely protect it from the financial impact of such dramatic price reductions, and its pursuit of GSM market share at the expense of margin, while it may make sense to its long term ambition of dominating next generation systems in growth economies, is having a devastating short term effect on its results.
Ericsson warned that fourth quarter results would be ‘in the lower end of the range’ the company had expected, news that sent its stock down 11% to $23 per share. The company now expects its fourth quarter sales to be between $8.42bn and $9.53bn, compared to $8.53bn in the 2006 fourth quarter.
Much of the market nervousness was because of downbeat forecasts for 2008, with Ericsson saying: ‘Early expectation for 2008 is that the current market conditions will prevail,’
Specifically, Ericsson blamed its pessimism on a financial tightening among carrier customers in the US and Europe. In the former, which only generates 10% of Ericsson sales, capacity upgrades have been less than expected. In emerging markets’where Ericsson derives 55% of sales’the company said political unrest in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Thailand and elsewhere was affecting its financial prospects.
CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg said the first quarter, which is typically weak, could be the low point of 2008, but that the longer term market outlook remains unchanged, and it hopes to grow faster than the market.
Late last month, Ericsson issued a profit warning, bursting the illusion that, unlike its rivals, it was riding the storm of slack wireless carrier demand. The company’s shares dropped nearly 30% then, and Ericsson blamed a shift in balance towards less profitable businesses such as base stations, and a drop in higher margin software. A week after that warning, Ericsson reported a sharp fall in its third quarter net profit, and appointed a new chief financial officer.
BSNL also plans to spend $750m on WiMAX networks to cover one-sixth of India’s population, and has just issued the first tender. Price pressure is in evidence even in this new technology market, with some analysts estimating that the usual budget required for what BSNL is planning would be closer to $1bn. However, some vendors expect the resulting revenues, in reality, to be half what BSNL is indicating it will spend as further price squeezing sets in.
The operator will issue two WiMAX tenders. The first one, published last week, focuses on covering small towns and rural areas and centers on about 1,000 802.16e base stations and 100,000 CPE units. Much of the funding will come from the government’s universal service obligation (USO) fund for broadband access. The second tender will cover certain large cities, and will be issued in the next 2-3 months. On the rural side, BSNL plans to cover 25,000 villages, provide broadband access to 40,000 primary and secondary schools, and set up 50,000 WiMAX kiosks. The operator has made some early, small scale deployments already, using Aperto kit.
Other operators already building out WiMAX are Reliance and VSNL, both supplied by Telsima.
Despite its grand plans, BSNL still needs to secure the 2.5GHz spectrum to run its rural systems (some of its roll-outs will also be in 3.5GHz). The government is not expected to finalize its spectrum rules for the band, or its broadband wireless access policy, until at least year end. BSNL says it has been assured of getting at least 20MHz of 2.5GHz spectrum and expects the licenses to be issued in the next 2-3 months.
Indian 3G auctions:
In a highly significant move for India’s ambition to leapfrog the world in 4G-style services, the government has made a U-turn in its approach to 3G licensing, and now plans to open the2008 licensing process for 3G to all-comers. Previously the country’s Communications Ministry had indicated that it would only consider granting 3G rights to existing 2G licence holders. The new policy could also open the door to international bidders, with Vodafone ‘ already majority owner of Essar ‘ and SKT possible candidates.
Also significant is the decision to run the 3G auction and the sale of 2.5GHz spectrum ‘ technology neutral but earmarked for mobile broadband, and so a hot target for WiMAX ‘ in parallel, with the latter’s base price being set at just 25% of the 3G floor. This shows how keen the Indian administration is to promote competition and create an environment that enables operators to leap immediately to 4G services in some areas, stealing a march on some more developed economies and accelerating the much needed boost to Indian infrastructure and broadband availability.
The Ministry, which has yet to fix a date for the sale, said that the auction will be carried out via a controlled, simultaneous ascending online auction process. It plans to rope in a specialized agency to handle the sale.