Smartphones and internet tablets, or UltraMobile PCs? The future is about mobile devices – the question is whether the market for those devices will be dominated by the current cellphone community and architectures, or those from the PC heritage. The battle is already being fought at the high end, with Intel, Nokia, Sony, Qualcomm and others staking their claims to drive the evolution of multimedia and enterprise products for power mobile internet users. But even bigger prizes may await in the emerging economies, where rapidly growing mobile penetration and low uptake of laptops have created very different starting points for the gradual evolution of the mobile internet.
The venerable Wintel alliance has already been hard at work to target the huge potential volumes of poor but rapidly growing economies in Asia and Africa, and PC-oriented projects have included the One Laptop per Child scheme. The cellphone giants are planning handsets and other new-look devices that not only deliver voice for under $50 but look forward to providing an internet experience too. But such products will require a whole new ecosystem, and India, in particular, is not content to let the western and Japanese majors make all the rules themselves.
India, which already has influential R&D projects for future mobile devices – such as the collaboration with Alcatel on ultra-small WiMAX CPE – is also examining the low cost laptop. It has rejected the much touted project to create a $100 Laptop, spearheaded by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and its luminary Nicholas Negroponte under the auspices of his One Laptop per Child (OLPC) organization. Last year, this created a prototype of a simplified laptop that delivers networked applications but cuts costs by avoiding hard drives and other elements, and can be crank-powered in areas where there is no electricity.
Indian authorities protest that the model was immature and even the $100 price tag is too expensive to support mass roll-out in poor areas, and they are targeting a $10 device (although other countries have signed up to the Negroponte scheme, including Argentina, Brazil, Namibia and Nigeria). India’s Ministry of Human Resource Development is spearheading the $10 project, with help from Semiconductor Complex, a state-sponsored designer and manufacturer of integrated circuits. Officials from these bodies are currently assessing designs submitted by an engineering student from India’s Vellore Institute of Technology and a researcher from the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore. These first-look proposals would support a laptop cost of $47, though $10 remains the goal.
The Indian approach cannot be ignored by the PC or phone industry, since the country represents massive buying power and high growth, as well as boasting a developed hi-tech skills base and an increasingly powerful electronics ecosystem, which will be valuable, with its low cost base, in supporting the manufacture of low cost devices. However, it is hard to see how even the most efficient supply chain and ecosystem can generate commercial profit for major vendors on the back of a $10 laptop or even cellphone, at least with current technologies, and so the notebook vendors will face the same dilemma as the phonemakers – leap in early, with a disastrous effect on margins but a chance to corner a healthy stake of a huge market and cash in as costs come down; or stick to profitable products and risk exclusion from India.
Not only that, but the PC community will also see the challenge from the cellphone makers, which believe their architectures can be shrunk down – in cost, power and size terms – to suit a low cost economy more easily than the PC architecture. Therefore the handset makers will be seeking to provide an alternative to the notebook and so keep the PC industry out of the mass markets of emerging economies forever. The GSM Association and other cellular bodies have been quick to press forward the advantage of the phone as the device of choice for low cost internet access in the future. Last year, for instance, GSMA chairman Craig Ehrlich slammed the MIT program, pointing out that $100 would be too expensive for many applications and user bases and pointing out that GSM handsets are being driven down to sub-$20 price tags, and data-capable 3G phones will soon be around $40 thanks to initiatives like the GSMA’s 3G For All (in which LG is creating the prototype).
“The eye-catching price tag of $100 is going to be too expensive for the 2.5bn people worldwide living on less than $2 a day,” said Ehrlich. “Thankfully, there is another hi-tech tool, which is already low cost, robust and frugal with electricity – the mobile phone.” The London Business School has estimated that a 10% increase in mobile penetration in a developing country can boost that country’s economic growth rate by about 0.6 percentage points a year, which can make a major impact in a slow growing economy.
Another challenge facing the quest to bring affordable internet access to poor communities is – assuming wireless is usually the most appropriate network – finding the spectrum to do this, and supporting an affordable system of licensing and charging. Experiments with bridging the digital divide in the developed economies using unlicensed bands – whether run by public bodies or commercial entities – have encountered huge problems in generating a profit model and/or justifying tax dollars for a subsidized offering. Although emerging economies may have access to more grants and other funding, this issue will only become more complex and urgent as wireless usage spreads, especially if the burden of expansion is put on carriers with commercial concerns and licensed spectrum.
Indeed, an official from the One Laptop per Child project criticized the WiMAX community at last week’s WiMAX Asia event in Singapore for its focus on licensed bands, and virtual killing of interest in the license-exempt 5.8GHz version of the standard.
“Try to find something in the 5.8GHz band. Forget it. It’s mostly just written about in the papers,” said Michail Bletsas, chief connectivity officer at OLPC, although vendors pointed out that 5.8GHz spectrum requires larger numbers of base stations and does not easily support mobile or non-line of sight operations, driving capex up.
The weight of these respective arguments will depend largely on the policies of the regulators in countries like India, which have been far from clear, and often downright counter-productive to the wireless internet cause. But at the device end, the debate between the laptop and the cellphone model will continue to rage as the vendors on each side stake their claims to these huge potential customer bases. Few companies stand to gain or lose more than Intel, whose latest chip roadmaps, including its Silverthorne architecture and other designs geared to low power and low cost, are clearly looking to strengthen the case for extending its systems to the embedded and low cost worlds. To achieve this, it will need to make greater common cause with India, which is determined to seize the steering wheel in defining the type of technology that will underpin the move to the dream of universal internet access.