Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 March 2008

Inmarsat in talks with three national carriers about hybrid satellite services

We have looked in detail at how the mobile satellite (MSS) operators in North America could partner with terrestrial wireless providers in order to enhance their business models and maximize their returns on investment in the emerging ATC technology, which supports hybrid terrestrial/satellite networks and therefore more attractive economics for MSS (see Wireless Watch February 19 2008). Now UK-based international operator Inmarsat is upping the ante, and says it is in talks with Verizon Wireless, AT&T and T-Mobile USA about partnering on a new nationwide service. This would make heavy use of the 2GHz spectrum held by MSV, with which Inmarsat formed an alliance and spectrum sharing deal in January, and which was allocated by the FCC specifically to support hybrid services using ATC, in which MSV holds the leading patent position.

Inmarsat said no agreement is ‘imminent’ but the idea is to lease capacity on its network to one or more cellcos. This would potentially enable them to address the problems of rural data services that continue to plague US cellcos, using satellite coverage rather than having to build uneconomic cell networks for sparsely populated areas. It might also enable the cellcos to participate in the most lucrative market for mobile satellite, emergency response/public safety, where a gap has been left by the failure of the FCC’s plan to auction a swathe of 700MHz spectrum with a public safety mandate attached. Although this idea, which was thought to be the best way for the FCC to fulfil its obligation to support a nationwide, interoperable mobile network for first responders, could return to the table if the 700MHz block is reauctioned with new terms or reserve price, some operators are casting around for alternatives in which they might gain some of the revenue with less of the build-out risk. Sprint Nextel has been rumored to be considering selling its iDEN network to the government under a public/private deal geared to first response, but with the MSS players already strong in the emergency sector, a deal with one of them could bring Verizon or AT&T into the game far more cheaply than by acquiring a national license.

Inmarsat CEO Andy Sukawaty told the Reuters news agency last week that he had held discussions with Verizon Wireless, AT&T and T-Mobile and believed his firm could derive $115m a year in revenue from leasing ATC capacity to them. “We are talking to potential strategic partners to launch a hybrid of terrestrial and satellite mobile services,” he said in the interview. ‘We would be the [satellite] supplier to the new licence, and would be paid leasing of $115m a year.”

Inmarsat is moving into the mobile satellite voice market for the first time from 2009 and its ATC partnership with MSV is important to this, since the hybrid technologies improve on the economics of satellite voice by allowing the terrestrial network to be used where possible and by supporting standards and smaller devices. Three operators ‘ MSV, ICO and Terrestar ‘ gained specific 2GHz MSS/ATC spectrum in 2006 at very low rates, and Globalstar has also been allowed to set aside frequencies for ATC, leaving Inmarsat with the more difficult task of supporting hybrid services in its existing L-band spectrum, hence its tie-up with MSV. Inmarsat has long stayed away from the commercial minefield of satellite phone services, but now believes that combining these with terrestrial wireless networks will finally deliver the business model that has eluded other ventures. By combining its new generation BGAN broadband satellites with one or more telecoms partnerships, Inmarsat says it will get ATC services to market more quickly than its competitors and with shared costs and risks, also using the new satellites to steal a march on the main international satellite phone operators, Iridium and Globalstar of the US and Saudi Arabia’s Thuraya, which have not yet upgraded their fleets. It is likely to be looking for telco partners outside the US too.

Inmarsat is targeting 10% of the $350m mobile satellite telephony market by 2010, an aim Sukawaty describes as “extremely unrisky”. The operator reported a 15.3% jump in annual revenues to $576.5m last Thursday, while EBITDA was up 17%, an improvement largely credited to the well respected CEO, who recently extended his commitment to Inmarsat by another three years.

Although public safety and very remote access will remain the heartland applications for MSS operators, they and their potential telco partners are looking for other services that might be made viable by ATC. Partnerships are the order of the day, to spread risk, pool business models and increase overall capacity. For instance, satellite TV operator Echostar injected funding into Terrestar earlier this year, a deal that also added L-band spectrum to the MSS specialist’s 2GHz S-band holdings. Inmarsat and MSV have also pooled S-band and L-band assets, in their case contiguous. And the third 2GHz ATC player, ICO, is controlled by Craig McCaw and could look to a partnership with McCaw stablemate Clearwire with its 2.5GHz terrestrial network (or even Xohm, the Sprint 2.5GHz vehicle, should Clearwire end up investing in that, as widely expected).

Handset-sized devices will still find it hard to reach directly to the satellite, especially with obstructions such as buildings, so the overall effect of these alliances is likely to be a two-spectrum network where the terrestrial portions carry most traffic, but where some special devices can reach the satellite as well as commandeer emergency communication services ‘ rather than a system based on dual-mode devices. But just as easily, these MSS services might deploy other protocols, aiming to pick up the 30% or so of land area in the US where fixed broadband is currently not being delivered. Currently proprietary satellite operations like WildBlue support expensive low end DSL-class services for most of the major carriers. AT&T, DirecTV and EchoStar all resell the WildBlue services. These new MSS satellites might take much of this business and it could become a handheld or laptop experience and far cheaper. This means that the major telcos could contract with the MSS carriers for rural broadband and even for rural cellular voice, using GSM and CDMA protocols, and save themselves any rural investment at all, and yet fulfill all FCC obligations in that area. Of course this might form the basis of a partnership with hundreds of rural incumbents also. It seems that Inmarsat may be setting the pace in attracting the most attractive partners in the US for such a plan.

Satellite-WiMAX interference?

The battle between satellite and WiMAX interests in the US continues. The Satellite Users Interference Reduction Group (SUIRG) claims it has carried out field tests that prove that WiMAX poses a “significant interference threat” to fixed satellite services (FSS) operating in the C-band spectrum.

SUIRG, a non-profit association comprised of private and public sector satellite operators, said the primary objective of the tests was to measure interference levels generated by fixed WiMAX transmissions into an FSS satellite receiving station. Testing showed that WiMAX transmissions could cause interference to a satellite digital signal as far away as 12 kilometers, the group claimed. That led SUIRG to conclude that FSS antennas could not coexist with WiMAX systems, which with suitable terrain and power levels could achieve ranges of 50 kilometers or more.

“The C-band is in many ways the lifeline of the satellite industry, and protecting that spectrum from the threat of interference posed by sharing it with broadband wireless access services is of paramount importance,” said SUIRG president Robert Ames.

The tests were carried out in part to support a general ruling made at last fall’s World Radio Conference, which sets guidelines for global spectrum and radio policies. The decisions announced in Geneva last October were broadly favorable to the satellite industry, as regards wireless operations in the C-band, which spans 3.4GHz-4.2GHz (a typical C-band satellite uses 3.7GHz’4.2GHz for downlink, and 5.925GHz’6.425GHz for uplink, though there are variations in various parts of the world, and the ‘super-extended band’ reaches down to 3.4GHz). The WRC guaranteed uninterrupted use of the band to the satellite operators and gave assurances that any future IMT networks would provide them with full protection from interference, restricting the chances for 3.5GHz WiMAX in some key areas of the world, notably Asia.

Despite pressure to open up the C-band for a wider variety of users, the WRC decided against doing this on a global basis ‘ which would have provided a huge opportunity for radio technologies like WiMAX – pointing to a major geographical split in how mobile broadband will be deployed, which means that satellite providers will require more spectrum and greater protection in some markets. Instead, the status quo was maintained, although a limited number of countries in favor of change will be ‘identified’ in an opt-in footnote. As well as stepping back from global harmonization, the WRC also further cramped radio’s freedom of action by insisting on stringent requirements for anti-interference, including cross-border protection.

In Region 2 (the Americas and the Caribbean), 14 countries have their mobile service allocation in 3.4GHz-3.5 GHz upgraded to allow IMT operations, under the anti-interference conditions. In Region 3, (most of Asia), only eight countries inserted their name to the footnote identifying IMT. In Region 1, which covers Africa and Europe, there was broad support for inclusion in the footnote identifying IMT for national usage in the 3.5GHz band.

Kizuna shows future of satellite broadband

Japan is demonstrating how satellite can be used to support a high speed broadband model, as an alternative to mesh Wi-Fi or WiMAX/LTE. The country’s newly launched and experimental Kizuna (meaning ‘ties between people’) satellite promises to provide broadband to homes, mainly in rural areas, with download speeds of up to 155Mbps and upload speeds of up to 6Mbps. It can also be brought into service following disasters when landline broadband is unusable.

Users will need a relatively small and inexpensive 45-centimeter dish, about the size of the devices that satellite TV services use. The initiative – also called WINDS (Wideband Internet working engineering test and Demonstration Satellite) – is part of the government sponsored e-Japan project, whose goal is to create the world’s most advanced information and telecoms network. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) and Mitsubishi Heavy Industries jointly developed the satellite, which was launched last Saturday.

Rural satellite in many countries delivers slow broadband rates at high prices, but Kizuna sets new expectations. For comparison purposes, Verizon currently offers 25Mbps up and down in selected areas where it has deployed its FiOS fiber optic network, although it says FiOS could ultimately offer speeds up to 100Mbps. US cablecos, led by Comcast, promise speeds upwards of 100Mbps, perhaps even up to 160Mbps, beginning later this year. Last week Motorola announced CPE and network gear for the cablecos’ next generation DOCSIS technology, which will make those speeds possible.

The Kizuna satellite program is at the beginning of an initial four-month test. More advanced tests will start in October. The service is expected to be available to every home within five years and bring ‘real’ broadband even to remote locations on islands and in mountainous areas.

“I hope that satellite technology will be well incorporated into our lives,” wrote Yasuo Nakamura, WINDS project manager, on the JAXA web site. “I’d like to see a society where everyone benefits from space technology without being aware of it. I hope the day soon comes when all satellite technologies are naturally embedded in our everyday life, and people don’t take space to be a special world. I’d like space to be part of our lives, and hopefully, WINDS will be a catalyst for this.”

The launch is the first step in the Japanese government’s demonstration of technologies that could revolutionize internet-based communications. Who needs DSL or cable modems or fiber if the speeds and geographical coverage promised by the Kizuna satellite prove to be real?

JAXA is putting up most of the money for the project, which has a five-year budget of $484m. The National Institute of Information and Communications Technology is anteing up $56 m. Not to put a political twist on things, but the $484m is less than what the US and its allies are spending every two days in Iraq.

Japan is a step ahead of the US and Europe when it comes to broadband speeds and ubiquity. DSL is considered slow and archaic there, much as dial-up is in North America and Europe. Fiber optic networks already cover much of the more densely populated areas in Japan and provide speeds upwards of 100Mbps to consumers at monthly rates of about $40 a month. Only rural areas are limited to slow DSL broadband speeds.
In North America and Europe consumers can get broadband speeds in the 1Mbps to 6Mbps range for about $40 or so a month. Consumers in rural areas have to settle for dial-up (remember that hiss, crackle and pop era?) and pay $15 to $25 a month.

A major advantage of satellite-based broadband is, in addition to its near-100% coverage, it is available when a natural disaster occurs such as a tsunami, earthquake, typhoon or volcano. (Japan has about 60 active volcanoes.) “Even if communication networks are disrupted and electricity lines are down, an internet connection can be easily set up anywhere,” Nakamura said. Kizuna will be used to link to small mobile stations to replace a disabled internet backbone line.

There are also international possibilities, since while one of the two antennas on the satellite is aimed at the Japanese archipelago, the other is aimed at the entire Asia-Pacific region. In a joint announcement, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency and the National Institute of Information and Communications Technology said the satellite’s other antenna would provide the Asia-Pacific region with high speed internet connections between Japan and other nations. That will cover about one-third of the planet – an area stretching from the central Pacific to India. Download speeds of about 1.2Gbps will be offered to businesses via five-meter antennas.