Significance: Qualcomm is the only chip major which has put resources into optimizing its architecture for Windows Phone, and is rewarded with a monopoly of an admittedly niche market ‘ but also a deep alliance with Microsoft which should stand it in good stead for the larger Windows 8 sector. By contrast Intel, while having Android and W8 roadmaps as ambitious as Qualcomm’s, has ignored Windows Phone. This will not be important in unit terms yet, though the mobile OS is likely to gain ground in 2013 on the back of higher OEM and carrier support. However, it leaves Intel stuck at the high end of the device continuum when Windows 8 appears, and it will find it hard to drive the platform down the chain without a fully mobile platform. That runs the risk that it will have to rely entirely on Android for smartphones, depriving itself of the top-to-bottom user experiences that most vendors are chasing.
Intel is having a month in the mobile sunshine at last, with the launch of the first Atom-based smartphone, the Motorola RAZR i, really to stand out in a crowd. That came hard on the heels of the annual IDF developer forum, where the silicon giant set out its stall for Windows 8, as well as looking far into the ‘everything connected’ future. But while the firm is finally gaining credibility in the Android space, courtesy of a long process of wooing Google and a major engineering investment, and remains in pole position for W8, the old Wintel alliance is heavily cracked, as seen in Intel’s indifference to Windows Phone. Where once it would have placed its weight behind the Microsoft platform, as it did for the terrible Windows Mobile, now it has ceded the space to Qualcomm. Favoring Android over Windows Phone is a no-brainer given their relative share, but a company of Intel’s scale could certainly support both ‘ and with carriers and OEMs starting to push WP8 up their priority list, Intel may have made a miscalculation which will lose it market share in future, but more importantly, further alienate Microsoft.
There is no question that the software company would support an x86 version, as it did in WinMo, should Intel show interest. And there are many signs that Windows Phone and Windows 8 RT (the ARM version) will converge over time as the lines between small-screen and large-screen mobile gadgets blur. The danger for Intel is that, at that stage, it will be confined to the x86 strand of W8, and to larger devices, with a far tougher task to drive that OS right down the wireless device chain if it lacks any experience in the fully mobile Windows iterations.
Of course, chip support for Windows Phone has been limited ‘ indeed, Qualcomm retains a de facto exclusive, having taken a longer view on the OS. The San Diego firm is as keen to expand in Intel’s natural turf as Intel is to go truly mobile, so usurping its rival’s place as Microsoft’s court favorite would have been an obvious ploy, and well worth the expense of optimizing Snapdragon for a OS that was likely to remain niche for some years. Unlike Intel, Qualcomm seems to have seen the side benefits of supporting Windows Phone. One was to get far closer to Microsoft via their collaborations on creating a strong Snapdragon/WP7 platform, and that has surely borne fruit with the position of Qualcomm in the inmost circle for Windows RT, an OS with the potential to accelerate Qualcomm’s move into tablets, hybrids and other non-phone form factors. It also gained Qualcomm a new customer, Nokia, and new ties with existing ones like HTC. Competitors, notably Nokia favorite ST-Ericsson, promise WP8 silicon, but are now well behind Qualcomm in the market and lack the wherewithal to throw quite as many resources at Microsoft.
However, while Intel may have done better to take Windows Phone more seriously, it has been carrying out a similar charm offensive to Qualcomm’s at Microsoft, but targeted at Google and Android. Intel has, according to Google insiders, invested more time and resource in collaborative development on Android than any ARM-based rival, in its quest to gain mobile credibility and harness the search giant’s influence over the handset ecosystem. The rewards were glimpsed at the launch of the RAZR i by Google’s Motorola Mobility subsidiary, which ‘ unlike previously launched Atom-based models ‘ threw down the gauntlet to ARM-based superphones in performance and battery life rather than hovering around the midmarket.
It also showed the way that Intel has worked closely with Google to optimize its Atom Medfield smartphone processor for Android, not just in performance terms, but in terms of the key elements of strong user experience, such as battery life. In that sense, the Motorola device reflects a more politically significant relationship than Atom phones from other early adopters, such as Lava and Lenovo, which are geared to achieving some springboard volume for the chip by targeting the midmarket, China and operator branded smartphones. But the RAZR i is part of the intensifying and strategic alliance with Google. Erik Reid, general manager of the Mobile & Communications group at Intel, said: ‘We have spent literally years and had hundreds and hundreds of engineers working to optimize Android for the Intel architecture’. (However, he did not address reports that some Android apps may not run on Atom.)
The RAZR i runs on a 2GHz (though single-core) Medfield SoC. Reid claimed the device was ‘the first smartphone that can achieve speeds of 2GHz, and that’s a really big deal’. It achieves this by harnessing the chip supplier’s Hyper-Threading Technology, which allows a single-core processor to ‘do two things at once’, improving battery life compared to ramping up to dual cores, said Reid at a London event.
The most striking claim for the handset is a long battery life of 20 hours of ‘mixed use’ (Motorola’s measurement of an average person’s normal handset usage). This is an improvement on the high end ARM-based model in the family, RAZR M, which uses Qualcomm Snapdragon. The difference is unlikely to be huge, but it indicates that Intel is finally winning its battle to match ARM-based chips for low power consumption, an important barrier to smartphone contracts. This milestone also reflects close collaboration with Google/Motorola, harnessing some of the latter’s recent work on battery life.
From next month, the new handset will go on sale in the UK, France and Germany, as Motorola tries to win back share in the European market, which it sidelined during its recent troubles; and also in the Latin American region, where it has been aggressive (the launch markets will be Argentina, Brazil and Mexico). It is bringing Motorola’s most famous recent brand (confined in the US to Verizon) to a more global audience, perhaps thanks to Google’s weight, and other markets will follow. However, Motorola has yet to announce a US carrier deal. Its main RAZR partner in the US is Verizon, but this is, at least for now, a GSM/HSPA-only device, so would need to attract AT&T or T-Mobile USA.
The RAZR i will be followed by other Atom-based devices as the platform finally starts to appear in the mainstream. Last month, ZTE launched its own Intel-powered device, the Grand XIN, targeted at Europe. Like the Motorola offering, that runs Android Ice Cream Sandwich and both OEMs have promised updates to the latest OS release, JellyBean, soon. Intel said at IDF that it had ported JellyBean to Atom.
With all this focus on Android, it then came as a surprise when reports circulated that Intel’s forthcoming Clover Trail, the most advanced Atom to date, would not support Linux-based operating systems such as Android, but would target Windows 8 only. This led to speculation that the Linux kernel did not conform to the new chip’s most compelling feature, its power management technologies.
However, Intel said there would be support for Linux at a later stage. Intel said in a statement that it had ‘plans for another version of this platform directed at Linux/Android; however we are not commenting on the platform specifics or market segments at this time. Stay tuned.’
It is hardly surprising that Intel should prioritize on W8 for this year. Despite the fracturing of the Wintel alliance, it will still have home advantage when it comes to the new OS, at least on large tablets, PCs and ultrabooks. In particular, the x86 version of W8 will have backwards compatibility with Windows 7, and Intel retains close ties with, and influence over, the PC ecosystem ‘ many members of which will be eager to support W8 as a way to break into the mobile device space at last, even if only on larger gadgets like slates. Intel has said that about 20 W8 tablets are being designed using Clover Trail, and has demonstrated one, the Asus Tablet 810.
Intel seems to believe that, for now, it offers enough to Android OEMs in the shape of Medfield with JellyBean ‘ it has a dual-core Medfield chip coming out later this year and next year promises a system-on-chip made using its new 22nm process, to improve power efficiency even further. By 2014, Intel will release chips made using the 14nm process. Some OEMs may not agree though. If Intel wants to lure mobile players away from ARM, it will need to keep up with rivals like Qualcomm and Nvidia in the Android tablet processor space, since many of these vendors will not want to move to W8 for these devices ‘ or will prefer the RT release.
The technical reason for staggered releases of Clover Trail for the two main platforms is that it has two cores. While Nvidia and others are pushing quad-core ARM processors into Android tablets and even smartphones, Intel has been openly concerned about Android’s power requirements for multicore platforms (hence the single-core Medfield). However, Clover Trail is designed to improve battery life significantly compared to its predecessors, using a new power state called S0ix or ‘active idle’. This will supposedly use 20 times less power while in active idle state, compared to the state of being on but idle. Intel is working on Linux support for active S0ix, but that project is not complete yet.
The two-pronged focus on Android and Windows 8 does enable Atom (and Core) to span the whole range of devices from PCs to cellphones via the important in-between categories where the unit growth is expected to lie. But there is a disconnect between the two platforms, and in the Microsoft world, Intel’s reach stops short at the large tablet. There’s nothing the firm can do about Windows RT, which is likely to thrive in low power categories where no compatibility with installed apps is required ‘ except to make its own low power, fully mobile OS even better. That will be hard without including the handset OS, WP8, in the strategy.
But there is no indication that either Medfield or Clover Trail will support Windows Phone. Hermann Eul, president of Intel’s Mobile Communications Group, said at IDF: “We would be interested when we see that this market has a good chance to return the money that we have invested into this. Our roadmap has devices that can support Windows also on phones. So we can do that. The hooks for doing that are there.” But he added: “The current trend of statistics is pretty clear, Android is gaining the largest share of the market so that is where the money is.’
Impossible to argue with that logic, except that the advantage of being a giant like Intel is resources can be invested to gain longer term rewards or even intangible benefits ‘ as Qualcomm has done with its own Microsoft initiatives. The Windows Phone segment is small, but it has growth potential, and very few competitors, so Intel would have a chance to lead. And while it will never catch Android, Windows Phone does have the chance to be the second mobile OS by mid-decade, according to many forecasts, partly because it is heavily supported by many carriers as a counterweight to Android and iOS. And it is being given greater prominence in the roadmaps of several big names, such as Samsung and HTC, which want to hedge their bets on Android (see separate item), as well as being the make-or-break weapon for Nokia, the only WP-only major. Vendors like Samsung will not forsake Android, but amid lawsuits and Google’s Motorola purchase, they want insurance policies. Nearly all the big names have shown revived interest in WP8 in their fall collections, partly for political reasons and also because of the improvements made to the new release, and its degree of harmonization with W8 and the PC ecosystem.
This was seen clearly when Samsung unveiled the first WP8 smartphone from a major OEM, and this week saw HTC’s affair with Windows rekindled. HTC was always the biggest player in the Windows Mobile niche until its crown was stolen by Nokia last year, courtesy of the Finnish vendor’s close new alliance with Microsoft. However, having also lost its early Android lead the Taiwanese firm is struggling to reverse declines in market share in the face of Samsung’s dominance. This has refocused its attentions on its first OS love, and it has unveiled two WP8 devices which will go head-to-head with Nokia’s new Lumia models.
As in Android, HTC runs the risk of launching bighitting products in functionality terms, but failing to make much noise above the storms surrounding iPhone and Galaxy launches. It seems to be enlisting Microsoft’s help here. Its new offerings include ‘Windows Phone’ in their names (Windows Phone 8X and 8S by HTC). Hardly as snappy as ‘Galaxy’, but the decision shows HTC reasserting its old special relationship with Microsoft and buying into that firm’s investment in its own brand. Indeed, the move drew approval from Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer, who said in a statement: “Pairing HTC’s beautiful new Windows Phone 8X and 8S with our brand is a big milestone for both companies. I’m thrilled to take our longstanding partnership to the next level.”
Such comments suggest that Microsoft, too, is hedging its bets, and trying to reassure key partners that they will gain the same level of support as Nokia. However, the new smartphones appear to have taken some tips from the Finnish giant too, adopting bright colors and a similar specifications list (and Microsoft’s tight control over the WP8 user experience means differentiation is difficult on the software side).
HTC CEO Peter Chou was also making the point that his company is not sidelining Windows because of Android’s success. “Windows Phone has clearly emerged as one of the top mobile ecosystems and is competitive against any other smartphone platform in the world,” he said.
The 8X and 8S will ship in November via 150 carriers in 50 countries, says HTC, and it has secured slots with AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile in the US; Vodafone, Orange, Telefonica, 3UK, and MTS in Europe; and SingTel, Telstra, and Chunghwa Telecom in Asia-Pacific. That indicates the global reach which HTC can still command, which is notably better than that of Motorola Mobility, for instance.
However, it needs to turn that, and any support it can get from Microsoft, into actual sales ‘ in 2010 it scored considerable success with its new branding campaign but last year saw this eclipsed by Samsung’s massive Galaxy marketing. In the second quarter, HTC sold 9.3m devices, giving it only eighth place in the handset market and representing not much more than 10% of Samsung’s sales (90.4m handsets).
The 8X runs on Qualcomm’s dual-core Snapdragon S4 processor at 1.5GHz ‘ Qualcomm, the only provider of Windows Phone processors, will certainly gain from the rejuvenated interest of top OEMs in their second string OS. The 8X also has 1Gbyte of RAM and NFC, with a 4.3-inch display, but lacks the expanded battery and wireless charging of the Lumia 920.
Success is not assured, for HTC and certainly not for Windows Phone. Sony Mobile and (of course) Motorola will not support the OS, and even Ballmer admitted in an interview last week that the firm has a “big challenge” ahead of it in smartphones. ‘We’re a very small player, but we have a different point of view in terms of user experience. We’ve got great cloud integration with the rest of the Microsoft world, which a lot of people participate in,” he said. “So I think our point of view on user interface, the great work that our hardware vendors are doing and the integration with Windows should help ratchet us up.”
The point about integration with the other Windows platforms is the critical one. In the past, mobile Windows has been the worst of both worlds ‘ on one hand, cramming many of the unloved features of the OS onto an unsuitable device; on the other, being sufficiently separate to deprive developers and users of many benefits of a single OS. Of course, nowadays the idea of one user experience from PC to phone to tablet, and possibly to TVs and cars, is considered essential to a serious mobile play, and increasingly, as Ballmer indicated, integration with the cloud is also key. This is why it seems perverse for Intel not to be supporting Windows, which it knows so well, as a top-to-bottom platform, in addition to its Android efforts. The decision may cost it market opportunities, and if the new enthusiasm for Windows Phone does propel it up the league tables, that could cost Intel smartphone units too.
Apple gains processor self-reliance with A6:
Apple is becoming increasingly self-sufficient in key mobile components, commissioning its own unique displays and designing its own processor. The newest processor for the iPhone, the A6, is the most extreme yet in terms of Apple’s architecture control. In successive handset iterations, it has shifted through various stages. First it used a Samsung chip, in the first iPhone. Then it adopted a unit codeveloped with, and made by, the Korean firm, but including technology from Apple’s own PA Semi acquisition. Then the A5 was almost entirely an Apple creation, using a standard ARM core. But the new A6 does not even use that, according to review site Anandtech, but instead Apple is leveraging its possession of an ARM architectural licence to develop its own core. The only common thread is that Apple’s arch-rival Samsung still manufactures the chips, though even that may change, with the iOS giant trying to introduce TSMC as a second foundry.
The A6 sees Apple emulating Qualcomm in incorporating inhouse knowhow into its processors in order to differentiate them and tailor them to particular requirements. Qualcomm also has an architectural licence, which enables it to modify the ARM designs. Initially it was thought that the iPhone 5’s processor used the Cortex A15 core, the latest high performance platform from ARM, but Anandtech reveals that Apple is harnessing its acquisitions of PA Semi and Intrinsity to go its own way. Its lead analyst Anand Shimpi wrote in a post: “Based on a lot of digging over the past couple of days, and conversations with the right people, I’ve confirmed that Apple’s A6 is based on Apple’s own ARM-based CPU core and not the Cortex A15.’ It will be interesting to see whether, in future, Apple also looks to create its own processors for the Macbook range, which currently uses Intel silicon.
According to Linley Gwennap of chip consultancy Linley Group, the microarchitecture for the A6 was completed in early 2010 and, embarking on the physical design phase, Apple acquired chip design firm Intrinsity, which had recently been involved in boosting the speed of the Samsung Hummingbird processor, the basis of the Apple A4. Gwennap thinks Apple is now committed to doing a new CPU design every two years, and the next iteration is likely to implement the 64-bit ARMv8 instruction set in 2014, while in 2013 Apple will use the same CPU design, but possibly with quad-core variants and an upgraded GPU.
McAfee will be mobile differentiator says Intel:
One of Intel’s motives for acquiring McAfee last year was to differentiate its mobile chips with superior silicon level security, fending off ARM initiatives in this area. This strategy is starting to bear fruit, according to software chief Renee James.
James ‘ SVP and general manager of the software and services group – told TechWorld that the security threats to mobile devices are escalating, and chip capabilities which help the gadgets to block malware are becoming important differentiators for Intel. “It will become if not the most important, a significant differentiator for our silicon. It will be very obvious in phones,” he said.
Intel is working to embed McAfee’s security knowhow in silicon, and has outlined a technology called Deep Safe, which creates hooks in chips, which then help the anti-malware software to identify and block threats more efficiently. DeepSafe is initially coming to PC and server processors but similar technologies are being created for mobile products.
“We can hardcode the service directly to our silicon,” James said. “When it’s an Intel processor we can actually do specific middleware extensions that connect to their service that just activate the hardware.”
Intel’s big challenge in trying to lead in mobile security is the ecosystem that surrounds ARM. The processor IP giant is also enhancing chip level security capabilities within its well established TrustZone platform and has several multivendor initiatives in this area.