‘ABQ’, or ‘anything but Qualcomm’, was an acronym which helped shape the more recent 3GPP standards processes, as companies sought to reduce the dominance of the chip designer’s vast array of CDMA-based patents. Now, a similar mentality seems to be behind the latest initiative aiming to steer standards for the internet of things (IoT).
Intel, Samsung, Broadcom, Atmel and Intel’s subsidiary Wind River are the founder members of the Open Interconnect Consortium (OIC), the latest in a long line of efforts to standardize the way devices discover one another, and communicate, in the world of connected gadgets. Not only does the new consortium include several of Qualcomm’s most important competitors, but it is likely to step on some of the territory of the AllSeen Alliance, which supports the AllJoyn discovery technology, devised by the San Diego chip giant.
The OIC is short on details of its approach so far, but its announcements suggest it will be a rival to AllJoyn in using the weight of its big-name backers to establish a de facto standard. It says it will devise, and contribute to open source, a peer-to-peer protocol which handles device discovery and authentication. However, Intel says the key difference from AllJoyn is that the OIC code will be created collaboratively, rather than forming a supporters’ club around an existing technology from a single firm.
This highlights how industry groups of this kind tend to establish themselves with high-sounding promises to end fragmentation, while often making things worse. While Intel claimed the high ground on collaboration, Qualcomm execs hit back, claiming the new initiative was adding to fragmentation and confusion.
The spec will support authentication and be independent of any specific processor, network protocol or operating system. Intel will contribute its XMPP-based Common Connectivity Framework, which enables device-to-device links over WiFi or Bluetooth.
Broadcom and Samsung also will contribute existing code.
The OIC will initially release open source code this autumn, targeting home and office devices, followed by a more generic specification in early 2015. It will then create variants of its platform for vertical markets such as automotive, healthcare and industrial, and will create APIs and compliance tests for those who want to develop their own code around the spec.
The focus on verticals is important, and an area where the OIC may leap ahead of AllSeen, which seems largely consumer focused at present. It may also run up against work being done by GE’s Industrial Internet consortium ‘ or be adopted by that group, which already includes Intel among its core members, and which aims to set de facto standards for the heavy industry market. Either way, the real growth and profit opportunities for IoT systems will lie in enterprise and vertical markets, rather than the high profile consumer and wearables applications where decent revenues will be hard to drive.
The other important IoT trend reflected in the formation of the OIC is the focus on peer-to-peer communications. While there has been so much effort put into leading standards for internet connected gadgets, in reality, many of the billions of tiny devices will not link to the internet themselves, but to one another, using short range, ultra-low power, self-discovering protocols. This is at the heart of AllSeen and of many efforts in the Bluetooth LE and ZigBee communities.
“The developer community needs a consistent and secure way to develop apps that incorporate peer-to-peer communications,” said Gary Martz, a product line manager in Intel’s wireless group, who is heading up OIC. “Device-to-device methods are cropping up in an ad hoc manner, especially in places like China.
This will certainly not be the last body formed to help the big chip vendors ‘ all of them in urgent need of a leadership role in at least some aspects of IoT standards ‘ to position themselves as standards setters. As seen in other technology markets, the array of would-be standards will gradually consolidate as the real market makers ‘ such as the large-scale consumer and industrial devices vendors ‘ make their choices.
In this way, the OIC has scored one big point, by netting Samsung, although the Korean firm’s semiconductor division does not necessarily influence the alliances made by its consumer products activities. It will be positive to see some of those market makers taking some decisions, or risk the chip giants tearing IoT platforms into fragments with their politicking, before the segment has even gained scale.