In the overcrowded world of wireless charging standards, Qi is the incumbent, but it needs to evolve its platform significantly or be overtaken by its two rivals – newly merged and enjoying a major push by Intel.
Three organizations have been vying to provide the universal standard for wire-free charging of smartphones and other mobile devices (there are yet more would-be standards for charging other items, such as electric cars, not to mention new technologies emerging from start-ups in this immature and fluid segment).
The Alliance for Wireless Power (A4WP) and the Power Matters Alliance (PMA) announced in January that they would merge, and this was formalized this week. They represent the two main technological approaches to wireless charging – the more traditional inductive technology, which requires the device to be placed on a specific mat, and is supported by the PMA’s Power 2.0; and the newer magnetic resonance approach, which allows multiple gadgets to be powered from a foot away from the charging coil, and is the basis of the A4WP’s Rezence platform.
By uniting the two efforts and promising a coordinated roadmap, the two groups – which will announce a new name later this year – are mounting a strong challenge to the third alliance, the Wireless Power Consortium (WPC), whose Qi standard is the most widely deployed of the three. In addition, the WPC already has a technology and roadmap which combines elements of inductive and magnetic resonance charging, so it is important that the new organization can now match that.
The A4WP and PMA said they had “retained key leaders and contributors within all working groups including technical, testing and certification, regulatory and marketing” during an integration process for which they have been preparing since January. The PMA’s president, Ron Resnick, said the combined body would be the one that “takes it global and the biggest companies in the world have bet on it. We plan to really be aggressive about building out and seeing infrastructures go everywhere for our wireless charging.”
The PMA risked being sidelined by its lack of expertise in magnetic resonance, whose greater flexibility has positioned it as the charging approach of the future, even though it currently has limited real world deployment, and it has downsides – for instance, its larger charging field means multiple devices can be powered, but this may increase average charging time.
However, the PMA will be a valuable member of the new alliance as it brings powerful supporters such as Duracell, Powermat (the originator of its technology), AT&T and Starbucks (which has been deploying PMA chargers in some coffee shops in the US). It also has the backing of Qualcomm, which has been an important influence in uniting wireless charging efforts, lending support to all three specifications and arguably being the most active in pushing forward wireless charging in commercial products from handsets to cars.
The major chipmakers have been particularly interested in Rezence, which has Broadcom, Intel, Qualcomm and Samsung among its senior members. At the Computex trade show in Taiwan this week, Intel upped the ante for Rezence, partnering with several companies to accelerate the technology’s progress towards the commercial mainstream. It presents Rezence as just one element of a broader concept of a completely wireless PC, with no cables or ports required. It announced that it is working with accessory vendor Targus on Rezence products, and with Chinese consumer electronics giant Haier to introduce the technology to hotels, restaurants and airports across China from later this year.
Intel will also work with fellow A4WP members Foxconn and Basecom and manufacturers BYD, Primax and Kokuyo to drive the creation of new products during the rest of 2015. It also said that the Hilton and Marriott hotel groups would introduce the technology, as would carmaker Jaguar Land Rover as Rezence looks beyond the handset.
In his keynote address, Kirk Skaugen, general manager of Intel’s Client Computing Group, demonstrated a self-installed Rezence charging plate from Kokuyo than can be placed under any desk, and described a power brick integrated into a laptop bag.
Meanwhile, the WPC – whose technology is included in smartphones from Samsung, LG, HTC, Sony, Microsoft and others – remains independent. John Perzow, VP of market development, presents the merger of the other two bodies as a defensive move to try to narrow the gap with Qi. He told FierceWireless: “There is synergy and an attempt to catch up with WPC and recognize the need for both technologies. As you know, the Qi standard addresses both inductive and resonant approaches, which has been WPC’s position from the start. The two groups are filling gaps with technology the other organization didn’t have.”
The WPC has over 200 members and claims 750 Qi-certified products, including over 80 smartphones and tablets, in the market.
Of course, the device industry will be encouraging further unity. A single standard breeds superior economics, especially in low cost items emerging for the internet of things. Only high value devices can afford to implement multiple standards for charging, as the Galaxy S6 does, though some vendors are bridging the divide, including Freescale with its multi-standard charging chip for Power 2.0 and Qi.
Resnick said in an interview: “I’d love to see a unification of the whole ecosystem. I would absolutely encourage the WPC to approach us and figure out how we can get their inductive technology.” In January, when the merger was first announced, Perzow told The Wall Street Journal that his group would be “willing and able” to have discussions with the others about combining efforts.
Aside from these main groups, there are many other developments in the wireless charging field, some focused on other sectors, such as cars, some on further pushing the technology boundaries. There are several start-ups in both cases, such as Ossia and Energous, and of course, always the lurking possibility that Apple, which has not supported the technology in the iDevices yet, will use its own system rather than any of those on the open market.
In April, the iPhone maker advertised for a senior engineer in wireless charging, and it has also filed various patents in this area, prompting speculation that, as in the mobile payments field, it will move late, with a view to improving on current efforts and giving consumers yet another reason to stick with, or convert to, the iDevices.