Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 August 2008

Intel remains ambivalent on Symbian despite need to woo Nokia

Intel has set out its mobile internet device stall aggressively in the past year, with platforms for ultra-mobile PCs and other portable devices, and with plans to re-enter the fully mobile market with a future iteration of its Atom low power microprocessor. In this respect, it is taking on Qualcomm and Texas Instruments on two fronts ‘ one, seeking to ensure that the advanced mobile user of the next decade is most likely to be carrying a product with its roots in the PC/IP/open world, with Wi-Fi, WiMAX and Linux the key technologies; two, if the market remains dominated by smartphones and their heirs, trying to take on the cellphone chipmakers head-to-head with Atom. In either of these quests, it will need the support of Nokia to gain credible market share, but Intel remains ambivalent about the technology closest to the mighty Finn’s heart, the soon-to-be open sourced Symbian/Series 60 software platform.

In an interview with Forbes magazine last week, Christian Morales, head of Intel Europe ‘ who needs, more than any other executive, to understand Nokia in its heartland ‘ was keeping the focus firmly on the preferred Intel foundations for the mobile internet, notably Linux (of course Windows also remains important, but Intel seems to have accepted, as perhaps even Microsoft has now, that Windows will have a declining role in the mobile world after 2011 or so). Asked whether Intel would join the Symbian Foundation, he said: ‘We are neutral to it. We think it’s a good foundation, and Symbian has been very important for cellular phones up to a certain level, but we think that Linux is going to have a major role. There, you have compatibility across the board.’

Of course, Linux is far from offering compatibility across the board right now, and Intel is playing its part in stirring up the politics that surround the battle between Android, LiMo and the other players. It created the Moblin initiative a year ago, its attempt to set de facto standards for mobile and MID Linux, with key partners Ubuntu and Red Flag. Moblin will be tightly integrated with Atom.

With Qualcomm hinting that it will work with Symbian in the near future, after its truce with Nokia over licensing, the lukewarm comments of Morales will not be music to Nokia’s ears, and may reduce the chances of a Nokia-Intel axis to dominate mobile web devices in the next generation ‘ especially as the Finnish giant now has the prospect of a chip partner with genuinely advanced technology in this area, in the shape of Qualcomm and its hardware and software platforms for mobile broadband smartphones, embedded 4G for notebooks, and ‘pocketable computers’ (what Qualcomm calls MIDs, or the category between handsets and PCs).

Yet Intel and Nokia would be a powerful combination in defining and accelerating mobile internet standards, and without Nokia, unless the Finn missteps badly in next generation devices, Intel will be as handicapped in its quest to be a major chip supplier for 4G, as Qualcomm has been in 3G, until last month, by being blacklisted by the handset market leader. The world’s largest chipmaker is still confident it can sell silicon to Nokia on its own merits though, aside from the politics. When asked ‘Why should a device manufacturer like Nokia pick Intel to supply its chips?’, Morales responded that the new versions of Atom would offer ‘huge compatibility and will basically bring you the internet in your pocket. They are very high performance and very energy efficient’. The main chips will be Menlow, the first mobile Atom, and then a smaller, even lower power version codenamed Moorestown, targeted at smartphones and scheduled for next year.

All this is part of the quest of Intel, Nokia and the other devices giants to get the next 2-3bn people connected to the internet. In this context, Morales thinks the often promised $100 laptop is coming close. Morales said: ‘We have just announced an initiative with the government of Portugal to offer notebooks for €50. There will be a subsidy from the government, so the cost is actually €299. But you can find it this year in the US at $299, and in a year or two maybe much less.’

Whatever Intel’s challenges in the smartphone sector, in its more familiar territory Atom has made a strong start. For ultramobile PCs, mobile internet devices and some consumer electronics gadgets, Atom is beating the company’s targets and looks set to contribute to balancing the slowdown in the traditional PC sector.

According to CFO Stacy Smith in an interview this week, ‘Atom is off to a very, very rapid start, far exceeding our expectations when we started the year. It’s the perfect recession product to have in the marketplace.’ Smith believes small, relatively low cost internet-enabled gizmos appeal to customers as they tighten their belts, more than fully fledged laptops or even (unsubsidized) super-handsets. He also said there is strong interest in using Atom in embedded devices. The chip carries lower margins than Xeon or other larger processors, but better than the low cost Celeron processor, so Smith is unworried if it starts to eat into the sales of Celeron.

However, all Atom’s segments are just emerging and the ultimate size of the portable web device sector is uncertain, though Smith believes Intel will have a fairly clear picture within six months, and says the firm is hopeful that Atom devices are growing the total market rather than just cannibalizing PC sales.

He stuck to his forecast for third quarter revenue of $10bn-$10.6bn. Last quarter the giant defied the western world’s economic slowdown and reported a 25% leap in profits, and also issued a higher than expected revenue guidance, which Smith is still confident of achieving.