Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

Is an open multivendor 5G network still just a pipe dream?

One of the most fascinating questions in the 5G networks market in 2020 is how far operators’ dreams of a more open, multivendor supply chain will come true.

A sceptical view says we have heard all this before, especially when the WiMAX and 3GPP communities were fighting to set the 4G agenda – one of the appeals of the former was the promise of a more WiFi-like ecosystem with lower barriers to entry, pooled patents and communal support for expensive processes like interoperability testing and certification.

In that case, and in other attempts to break open the market – in small cells, in unlicensed LTE and so on – there has been limited impact. Operators have been too nervous, in the end, to trust newly emerging specifications, untried solutions and small vendors. And as they are finding out at the start of the telco cloud era, deploying open, multivendor solutions is expensive. The products may be lower cost, but until the dream of fully cloud-native, plug-and-play  networks comes true (a decade away at least), there is a lot of integration, quality testing, stress testing and interoperability assurance to be done, which comes at a high cost in terms of inhouse or integrator support.

So there are obvious risks of taking on untested vendors and additional cost and complexity (in the short to medium term at least – eventually automation and cloud technologies should transform the cost base). But this time, we think the prospects are brighter for greater diversity of suppliers as networks shift to being software-based and cloud-native.

Many operators are under unprecedented pressure on the cost:revenue ratio, and many are being forced by commercial or government forces to deploy 5G earlier than they would ideally have chosen. To make matters worse, some are seeing new competition from agile new entrants, and those entrants will certainly seize the advantage of their greenfield status and the chance to deploy cloud-based networks from scratch. Meanwhile, many emerging business models centered on industrial or private networks lend themselves to a new supply chain, from vendors of small cells and edge compute nodes, suited for localized roll-outs, to vertically specialized integrators.

And there is more intense activity and broader participation in core specifications that will enable open, multivendor networks. Despite this period of over-hype, organizations like the Open Networking Foundation (ONF), Telecom Infra Project (TIP) and the ORAN Alliance are making real progress in defining quasi-standards with open processes – greater alignment with one another, and with 3GPP, ETSI and IEEE, would turn these into a genuine 5G-class platform.

That alignment is not impossible – all these groups are working together at least on some projects, and share many of the same members. However, this remains the big risk – fragmentation between two many overlapping or even conflicting efforts. Our heart sank a little when the 5G Future Forum was announced last week – yet another operator group, this time led by Verizon, focused on open platforms and particularly the important but over-diverse area of mobile edge.

But operators are making commercial moves too, not just setting up talking shops, though some of their deployment announcements may be designed mainly to put pressure on their existing vendors to lower their prices. The past week brought news of another operator deploying open RAN equipment (O2 UK) and a win for the ONF (T-Mobile Poland); while SK Telecom continues its push towards a more diverse set of vendors in South Korea, with a multivendor 5G demonstration.

Importantly, some of the big vendors – which will be essential to drive any new platform to scale and to gain operator trust – are biting the bullet and lending support. Nokia is putting  a brave face on this, seeking to use open platforms to take market share from its rivals without the huge cost of a vendor-funded rip-and-replace exercise.

So open systems will not only be about new suppliers, whether start-ups or entrants from other sectors – the major impact on the supply chain may well be to provide some high value exits for some of those small firms, while driving some shifts in the market share between the existing network OEMs. ZTE and Samsung, which lag behind the big three in share, are understandably embracing new platforms that could give them an edge if operators do break the shackles of their incumbent suppliers and branch out into the open. Samsung is ramping up its activities in the USA with this in mind, while ZTE is harnessing advanced positions in network functions virtualization (NFV) and cloud core to expand its share.

One of the big risk factors is China. The trade, patent and cybersecurity wars between the USA and China have become conflated in a damaging way for a telecoms industry that will always benefit from being fully global. Huawei and ZTE are increasingly working with open source groups, but are on the defensive, and pushing back to their home base. They dominate new patent filings for 5G-related technologies, but file many of these only in China, in support of their government’s goal to become more technologically self-sufficient, which has, of course, been intensified by US aggression.

There is a real risk of the industry splitting into two regional blocs with increasingly non-aligned standards, patents and open systems, which will reduce scale and increase cost just at a time when there is real progress towards a more diverse ecosystem and global open specs. US hawks argue that the absence of the Chinese giants will provide more room for western start-ups to thrive; the counter-argument is that the global ecosystem will lose China’s rich base of start-ups and innovation, and that many Asian markets, in particular, will become difficult for western firms to penetrate.

The conflation of ‘openness’ and ‘multivendor’ with anti-Chinese feeling is deeply unhelpful to operators which are looking for more choices, not fewer, but it is to be hoped that the push towards broader, global ecosystems will rise above geopolitics and create a truly open platform for all.

February 2020:

 

There were still months to go before the UK government finalized its policy towards Huawei equipment in 5G – this preliminary policy was later toughened up, with even more challenging consequences for three of the four MNOs. However, this piece, though UK-focused, sums up the uncertainties that affected many European operators during this year, as they weighed up their options ahead of clarity about government rules. Some played safe and backed away from Huawei equipment proactively, others continue to lobby their regulators to allow them a free choice of supplier, even with stronger security precautions (since the official reason for sanctions against Chinese vendors relates to alleged hacking via cellular networks, rather than trade wars or geopolitics),