Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2012

Is NSN’s optical sale a cut too deep?

Nokia Siemens’ restructuring continues apace, and this week it has offloaded two more business units ‘ optical networks and BSS (business support systems), and is reported to be closing a German services unit. The aim is to reduce costs by €1bn by the end of next year, and to achieve sustainable profitability, by replacing a diverse business covering many aspects of the carrier network, with a laser focus on mobile broadband. That effort centers on the ‘Liquid Net’ family of products, which promise flexible, intelligent platforms for the RAN, core and backhaul, plus services. However, it can be questioned whether NSN is starting to cut so close to the bone that it will reduce its mobile broadband assets. With the loss of the optical division, it turns its back on the idea of the end-to-end network and reduces the ‘Liquid Transport’ element of its platform; while in selling BSS it is countering the trend for vendors to add value by controlling the back end systems, as seen in NEC’s purchase of NetCracker and several moves by Ericsson.

NSN has sold its optical unit to private equity firm Marlin Equity Partners of Los Angeles. The division will be spun off as a separate company which, according to NSN’s statement, will be ‘an industry leader in the fragmented optical networking sector’. Since kicking off its streamlining exercise last year, NSN has offloaded its microwave transport business to DragonWave ‘ the final element of that much-amended agreement was concluded last week with the sale of the Chinese unit. The vendor has also sold its broadband access operation to Adtran; the WiMAX assets of its Motorola Networks acquisition to NewNet Communication; and its IPTV business to Accenture. In addition, in May it set up a spin-off fund, called Verso, to support early-stage projects which are no longer at the heart of the company’s own strategy.

The latest deal will see up to 1,900 employees, mainly in Germany, Portugal and China, transferring to the new company, with the transaction due to be completed in the first quarter of next year. The unit will be headquartered in Munich, Germany and be led by its existing management team, under CEO Herbert Merz.

‘During 2012 Nokia Siemens Networks has made tremendous progress in the transformation of our company to being the world’s mobile broadband specialist. Our strategic focus on our core markets has enabled us to concentrate our energy and investment in areas such as LTE where we have strengthened our global leadership position,’ said CEO Rajeev Suri in a statement.

The plan sees NSN cutting one of its last ties to the wireline business at a time when rivals like Ericsson and Huawei are expanding their activities there and Alcatel-Lucent is talking up the benefits of having a common IP platform underpinning all kinds of network gear. However, a surprisingly strong set of third quarter results at NSN gave early justification for its strategy.

Analysts welcomed the sale to Marlin, pointing out that NSN had mainly held onto the optical unit as a complement to its mobile broadband activities, not as a strong player in its own right. Indeed, it holds only tenth position in the $15bn sector, with just under $500m annual sales, and that share is sliding against firms which have invested more heavily in new platforms ‘ Ciena, Cisco, Huawei and Alcatel-Lucent for instance. Some expect Marlin to sell the unit onto one of these larger contenders in time. The NSN unit’s main product is the hiT 7300 100Gbps platform and hiT 7100 packet switch, and it claims about 200 customers. The company is seeking a separate deal for its Carrier Ethernet products.

Just a day after it announced the Marlin deal, NSN said it was also offloading its BSS (business support systems) division to Redknee, and will close its German services unit to save costs. According to sources who spoke to Reuters, NSN will close the latter by the end of next year, putting about 1,000 jobs at risk. The reason is that a lifeline contract, worth €300m, with Deutsche Telekom will not be renewed. That deal was signed five years ago, when the telco sold its services unit to NSN. Once the contract expires, NSN plans to use the savings to help reach its target of reducing costs by €1bn by the end of 2013.

The vendor has also announced an agreement to sell its BSS unit to Redknee, a specialist in billing and charging solutions. About 1,200 employees will transfer to the purchasing firm, expanding its
global footprint. Redknee’s CEO Lucas Skoczkowski said in a statement: ‘This planned acquisition marks a significant milestone in Redknee’s long term growth strategy. It would add strong long standing relationships with new Tier one operators and expand Redknee’s market share and presence in high growth markets. Our expanded team would drive the continued success of our customers, as we strive to be the provider of choice for real time converged billing, customer care, policy, and payment solutions in the communications industry.’

While the BSS sale does go against the trend for hardware vendors to boost their margins and influence via key IT systems, the real question marks hang over the optical decision. That sale does weaken the Liquid proposition by removing the transport element (along with the DragonWave deal) and it is notable that NSN did not originally identify optical as one of the ‘non-core’ units it wanted to sell, when it outlined its reorganization plan. However, this is part of NSN’s decision to pursue only profitable markets where it can shine, rather than seeking to deliver the entire network like Ericsson. It said recently it would focus its efforts on geographies like the US, where it could see major growth potential, and not on margin-squeezed territories like India.

So since the original restructuring was announced, NSN has actually narrowed its ‘mobile broadband’ definition considerably, both in geographical and technology terms. It insists it will still offer customers elements like transport and BSS, via best of breed partners, while its value will come from its core platforms- RAN, mobile core and customer experience management ‘ and from the intelligent software to manage the whole network, including partner products, in a holistic and highly flexible way. The logical extension of this thinking will be that NSN eventually becomes a software house, divesting all the hardware products to partners as seen in its small cell strategy. There is logic in such a transition, but also a huge shift in revenue and profit structures. The risk is that, in pursuing profits and a big vision, NSN will cut off one too many businesses.