Judge Lucy Koh, who has been presiding over the central Apple-Samsung battle in Silicon Valley, has slashed the damages awarded against the Korean vendor last summer almost in half.
Samsung was ordered to pay $1.05bn in damages to its rival after the most prominent of its many patent trials against Apple. Koh has reduced that sum by $450.5m after ruling that the jurors in the original trial did not follow her instructions when calculating the award. Koh ordered a new trial to review the damages bill again, but this will focus only on recalculating the sum, and will not revisit the issue of patent infringement.
‘This is an extremely careful and thorough opinion on a very difficult and interrelated set of issues,’ Stanford Law School professor Mark Lemley told Bloomberg. ‘Samsung will get some reduction in the award, but almost certainly less than $450m. We’ll need a new trial to figure that out.’
Apple’s and Samsung both have various appeals ongoing, which could affect the final total too, and decide on other consequences such as potential product injunctions. Both firms have also added newer devices to their suits and countersuits, although Samsung is still seeking to have the original verdict in San Jose overturned completely and the case dismissed. Apple has repeatedly failed to get an injunction against Samsung despite the verdict against its rival.
In separate Apple legal news, another thorn in its side – activist investor David Einhorn of hedge fund Greenlight Capital – has withdrawn his firm’s lawsuit. This had aimed to block a shareholder vote on a proposal to have investors decide on his plan to have Apple share more of its cash with shareholders. This plan, called iPrefs, would involve Apple issuing its existing investors with ‘permanent preferred’ stock, which would pay an annual dividend in perpetuity. Greenlight said it cancelled the lawsuit after Apple withdrew the bundled proposal it was objecting to.