Ericsson is clearly weighing its response to the proposed merger of its two major European rivals, Nokia and Alcatel-Lucent. After it emerged that CEO Hans Vestberg is to hold a senior management meeting to discuss Ericsson’s own potential M&A options, speculation went into overdrive, with Juniper Networks appearing to be the pundits’ favorite choice.
According to Ericsson sources who spoke to Bloomberg, a large acquisition may be considered as one solution to maintaining market leadership in network infrastructure despite the Nokia/ALU combination. However, the Swedish firm has limited choices at this scale, having passed on its own possible bid for ALU last year.
Apparently, it was concerned that the disruption of the merger would not be justified by sufficient scale of cost reductions, a conclusion which may well come back to haunt Nokia when it tries to execute on its ALU deal.
Ericsson has generally steered clear of major acquisitions and has benefited from its ability to keep on with business as usual while its competitors have been going through traumatic mergers – particularly in the later years of the last decade, when Alcatel and Lucent, and Nokia and Siemens, were painfully working out their marriages. Ericsson’s most significant acquisitions – such as Telcordia, Redback, Marconi Networks, BelAir Networks and Microsoft Mediaroom – have not been on the same scale, and have tended to add new revenue streams to the business, rather than being motivated purely by consolidation.
Juniper, or another popular candidate, Ciena, would both accelerate Ericsson’s moves to strengthen its wireline and all-IP businesses, and expand beyond its heavily mobile roots to target quad play carriers, and those in adjacent markets such as pay-TV, cloud services or the internet of things. There will be pressure to improve its wireline credentials once Nokia has control of ALU’s crown jewel, its routers and IP infrastructure division.
Analysts at Credit Suisse wrote in a recent research note that Juniper, Ciena and Samsung’s infrastructure business are the only viable choices left in the network infrastructure space. Of the three, the analysts believe Juniper Networks would add the most value to Ericsson, particularly in service provider routers, where Juniper has a 17% share compared to Ericsson’s 2%, and where it has a good position with the major US carriers, which are also major Ericsson customers on the mobile side.
The Swedish firm would welcome the chance to seize a larger share of the total pie at Verizon and AT&T, since its north American results have slumped recently as its major customers come to the end of their first wave of LTE roll-out. Sales in the region were down 8% year-on-year in the firm’s first quarter. However, Juniper’s own router sales have been sliding recently, and its moves into new growth areas such as SDN have not yet made a significant impact on its results, or its ability to compete with the market leader, Cisco.
Ericsson also has closer existing ties to Juniper than the other two candidates, although in recent years the smaller company has worked more closely with Nokia – though a partnership for routers and backhaul is likely to fall victim to the ALU acquisition, if that ends up being approved by shareholders and regulators. Ericsson had a previous investment in Juniper which resulted in a large amount of mutual IPR.
The Credit Suisse analysts calculated that Ericsson could boost its earnings per share by 15% in 2016 if it funded a Juniper deal, valued at about $10.4bn, solely with debt.
Ciena is also seen as a good potential target for Ericsson in some quarters as the two have been working together on SDN, and it is strong in the fiber transport segment, which is highly complementary to Ericsson’s mobile access business. These activities will be important to counteract ALU, even without the additional power it could gain from Nokia’s resources. For instance, the French firm recent debuted the first commercial system bringing together Ethernet, IP and optical transport under a single SDN platform, highlighting the need for vendor to seek optical expertise.
The optical/IP convergence trend has already prompted Ericsson to intensify its partnership with Ciena, so a merger could make sense even without the ALU/Nokia factor – as it needs to be able to provide the entire hardware line to underpin a software defined, multilayer network. That alliance will integrate Ericsson’s IP play, the SSR (Smart Services Router), with Ciena’s WaveLogic packet optical platform, which has a stronger market position than the Swedish giant’s own offering. Ciena says it has started to develop an SDN controller based on sourcecode from the open source OpenDaylight project, in which Ericsson, among other telco equipment providers, has taken a prominent role. Other optical transport specialists which might come into M&A play include ADVA and Infinera, which could be targets for Ericsson or the router giants Cisco and Juniper.