Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2012

LatAm growth saves Telefonica’s quarter

Telefonica’s third quarter results followed the pattern familiar in recent times, with its Latin American units, as well as mobile data growth, providing most of its upside. The Spanish giant has been progressively distancing its home division, which is suffering from the economic crisis in the country, from other activities, and may pursue an IPO for some larger Latin American units, as it is for its O2 Germany subsidiary.

Such actions could see European and LatAm businesses separated, in order to cushion the effects on the group of any further worsening of Spain’s economic troubles. IPOs would unlock value and raise funds to cut its deficit and accelerate mobile broadband expansion. Telefonica has also been transferring some growth businesses, notably the Digital unit, to the UK to insulate them and ‘decouple’ itself from the Spanish problems. This could give it easier access to financing as the situation at home is making it hard for the operator to carry its habitual level of debt.

CFO Angel Vila recently told The Wall Street Journal: ‘There are ways without changing the domicile to structurally move the group in such a way that you can minimize the issue of where we are domiciled.’ The Q3 results will only intensify his interest in such solutions, highlighting the contrast between European and emerging market activities.

Executive chairman Cesar Alierta, however, did see overall reasons for optimism, saying in his statement that there had been ‘a consolidation of the recovery trend initiated in the second quarter’. He said results were starting to be seen from ‘transformational initiatives and cost reduction measures undertaken in all countries’.

Indeed, the group did report third quarter profit of €1.38bn, reversing a year-ago loss of €429m, though revenue was down 1.6% year-on-year to €15.54bn. For the nine months, it announced a net profit of €3.46bn, up 26.4% on the year-ago period, on revenue down 0.3% to €46.52bn. Telefonica also said it had narrowed its debt by €2.3bn during the quarter, to stand at €56bn, and since the end of Q3 had ‘executed an efficient asset portfolio management and a successful divestment program’, which should result in an additional €3.2bn reduction in debt.

Rather bravely, Telefonica has avoided the common panic reaction of carriers in reduced circumstances ‘ the dash for market share ‘ and is seeking to increase margins and improve another key cellco metric, churn. This means attention to quality of service, and a move to reduce handset subsidies, which aid customer acquisition, but eat into profits. The firm has removed many subsidies for new customers in Spain and is gradually reducing them in the UK. In the latter market, rival Everything Everywhere has used its early LTE launch to make the break with 100% subsidies and unlimited data plans, and Telefonica’s O2 UK unit is likely to follow suit next year when it rolls out 4G.

Alierta said Telefonica was stepping up ‘the focus on quality as a key lever to reduce churn’ in its mobile operations, as well as cutting costs through measures like network sharing in Mexico.

The contrast between businesses on either side of the Atlantic was clear though. Quarterly revenue in Latin America ‘ up 3.8% year-on-year to €7.62bn ‘ now exceeds that from Europe, which fell 6.8% to €7.45bn. Spain weighed heavily on the latter figure, with revenue down 15.3% to €3.64bn. The wireless unit was particularly hard hit, seeing a revenue decline of 19.8% to €1.57bn.

As of September 30, the whole group had a mobile subscriber base of 245.64m, up 5.9% on the year-ago figure, and the prepaid base had increased by 5.5% to stand at 165.77m or 67.5% of the total. However, growth was higher in the more valued contract segment, where subscriber numbers were up 6.8% to 79.87m.

Again, the geographical divide was clear. The Latin America mobile base increased by 10% year-on-year to 175m, despite some restrictive factors – disconnection of inactive prepaid customers in Brazil, for instance, and tighter rules on reporting net additions in several markets. Meanwhile, the European mobile base shrank by 2% to stand at 70.4m at the end of the quarter. However, the move to favour quality over quantity was starting to show through, with postpaid users accounting for a higher percentage of the total at 59%.

On a group level, the company said that mobile broadband penetration was 19% of its customer base, up from 15% a year earlier, and smartphone penetration was 17%, up from 11%.