Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 February 2013

LG shows signs of turnaround but HTC still battling

LG said its handset unit staged a strong comeback in the fourth quarter, with a 25% increase in operating profit ‘ though it still made a net loss because of a price fixing fine. The company said increased sales and better cost structure boosted mobile performance, despite higher marketing and R&D expenses.

The handset unit reported Q412 operating profit of KRW55bn ($50.66m), compared with a year-ago loss of KRW3bn, on revenue of KRW2.78 trillion, up 3.1% year-on-year. For the full year, the division saw an operating profit of KRW51bn, compared with a loss of KRW280bn a year earlier, on revenue down 13.1% to KRW9.9 trillion.

The full year profit was largely down to a strong Q4, with key LG smartphones performing well in the holiday season. Across 2012 as a whole, it had two quarters in operating profit and two in loss, better than 2011, which was entirely lossmaking.

In the quarter, handset shipments increased by 7% compared to Q312, to 15.4m units, with 56% of those being smartphones, compared to 50% in the previous quarter. The Optimus G and Vu2 LTE smartphones were particularly singled out for credit, along with ‘robust’ sales of the L-series 3G devices, and the launch of the Nexus 4, co-branded with Google ‘ although that has suffered from supply constraints.

Looking ahead, it hopes to ride the growing LTE wave with its high end models, increase its cost efficiencies and launch successors to the Optimus G and L-Series devices. It is also planning ‘mass LTE smartphones’ in the F-series line.

On a group level, the company reported a net loss of KRW468bn in the quarter, compared with a Q411 net loss of KRW112bn, on revenue of KRW13.5 trillion, down slightly year-on-year. It said that the loss ‘reflects a fine related to alleged cathode-ray tube pricing issues imposed by the European Commission in December’.

Research firm Gartner estimates LG ranked fifth last year among cellphone vendors, with a 3.4% market share, behind compatriot Samsung in the lead on almost 22%.

“Following restructuring efforts and the launch of the Optimus G smartphone model last year, LG was able to narrow the big gap it had with the leading companies in terms of technology and phone design, performance and convenience,” said Yoon Bu-hyun, VP for LG’s mobile unit, admitting the division had struggled for three years.

Sony is also seeing some recovery in handsets since taking full control of its former joint venture with Ericsson. The Japanese firm said its mobile division achieved 94% year-on-year increase in sales in its fiscal third quarter (to December), reaching ‘318.8bn ($3.4bn), though on a pro forma basis, the increase was 10%.

The unit enjoyed higher volumes and selling prices for smartphones, though offset by weaker sales of its Vaio PC range. The group sold a total of 8.7m smartphones, down slightly from 8.8m in fiscal Q2, and is targeting a total of 34m for the full year. The division’s operating loss narrowed to ‘21.3bn from ‘48.4 billion, after a tax charge in the year-earlier period.

By contrast, despite high anticipation of HTC’s upcoming new flagship smartphone, the M7, to be launched on February 19, the firm is still warning of continuing sales declines.

The Taiwanese firm has spent the past year turning out high-class devices, rationalizing its product range and refocusing its marketing efforts, after largely taking its eye off that ball in 2011. However, it remains tightly squeezed by the rising domination of the Apple/Samsung duo, and by the competition from Huawei and ZTE in key Asian markets, notably China. It dropped out of the global smartphone top five in the fourth quarter of 2012, while the two Chinese giants entered that league.

HTC has now forecast its sixth consecutive fall in quarterly sales and says revenue in the current first quarter will be NT$50bn ($1.7bn) to NT$60bn ‘ below the NT$64.8bn of the consensus analyst outlook. One of its problems is that it did not have a major launch for the holiday quarter, saving the M7 to be unveiled just before Mobile World Congress, shipping from late February onwards. It does not provide earnings guidance but analysts expect its net income to be NT2.56bn.

The M7 could enter mass production in late February, with shipments ramping up from 1m 1Q13 to 2.5m in 2Q13,’ Birdy Lu of Daiwa Securities told Bloomberg. He thinks HTC could see a sales leap in the second quarter, on the back of M7 and some other upcoming new handsets like the recently outed M4. This could be as much as 20% from Q113 to Q213.

HTC reported a month ago that its fourth quarter net income had dropped by 91% to NT$1bn, its lowest level in eight years, on revenue of NT$60bn and operating profit of NT$600m.

Analysts at IDC say it suffered a 25% drop in smartphone shipments in 2012 and this amounted to less than 4.3% share, while Samsung, Huawei, Sony and ZTE all gained share.

However, CEO Peter Chou remains upbeat about a medium term turnaround amid the bleak forecasts. ‘We’re most confident now because last year we achieved a lot, and we changed a lot,’ he told staff on Friday at the firm’s year-end party, where he showed off the M7.

Of course, all these mid-tier players’ results are overshadowed by the big two, Apple and Samsung. The latter reported a stellar quarter, as expected, but was downbeat in its outlook, warning of increased challenges ahead and implying its record $6.6bn profit for Q412 could be close to the peak of its performance.

The company reported a 76% year-on-year rise in Q412 net profit to KRW7.04 trillion ($6.6bn), with its mobile devices the main contributor. Key devices like Galaxy S3 and Note 2 were major drivers, but Samsung warned that higher costs and a stronger Korean won would make life difficult in 2013.

For the quarter, revenue rose 18.5% to KRW56.06 trillion ($52.4bn). Consolidated operating profit also hit an all-time high at KRW8.84 trillion ($8.3bn).

Full year 2012 operating profit was KRW29.05 trillion ($27.2bn) on revenue of KRW201.10 trillion ($188.1bn), according to Samsung’s report.

The mobile business turned in quarterly revenue of KRW27.23 trillion ($25.4bn), up 4% sequentially, a rise driven mainly by strong sales of the key Galaxy family members, which Samsung said “beat the popularity of their predecessors with record sales in record time’.

Robert Yi, SVP and head of investor relations, said in a statement: “Despite uncertainties in Europe and concerns over the US fiscal cliff creating a difficult business environment, we did our best this quarter to achieve strong earnings based on a strategic focus on differentiated and high value added products, as well as our technological competitiveness.’

However, he echoed the caution of other executives about the climate in 2013, adding: “Heading into this year, we are expecting a slow recovery in the component business due to reduced capital expenditures, while competition in the set business will intensify further as demand slows and the mid to low end market expands.’ He also warned of increased price competition in the mobile market, which could slow Samsung’s growth in smartphone units and market share.

The company predicted that, in the current calendar first quarter, smartphone demand in developed countries would already be slowing down although rising sales of entry level smartphones and tablets in emerging economies would be the “silver lining”.