Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2008

Linux bodies merge in bid to forestall Symbian and Android

There is nothing like a strong new threat to force bickering allies to form a united front. Nokia’s market-changing purchase of Symbian, turning it into an open source handset software platform supported by the top five phonemakers, has put the Linux-based challengers to provide the dominant standard for smartphones on the defensive. The likely impact on Google’s Android is clear, and may push the search giant back towards majoring on its services across all platforms, rather than on underlying architectures. Now the other main Linux-based contenders, the LiMO Foundation and the Linux Phone Standards (LiPS) Forum, have decided to combine their efforts and form the Mobile Linux Forum.

With Android delayed and under threat, this is the moment for the other prominent Linux organizations to act (even though their memberships often overlap with those of Android and Symbian). Despite the likely dominance of Symbian in the smartphone and webphone sectors, there will always be a place for Linux, because of demand for unified PC-phone platforms, as pushed by Adobe, and because of popularity in China (Motorola, for instance, has dropped nearly all its Linux activities for Symbian, but retains the open source OS for China. In a joint statement, the newly unified bodies said that their pooling of efforts and resources reflects the trend towards unification of Linux-based mobile platforms and should ‘ accelerate the emergence of common mobile Linux specifications and implementations’.

Before Google assembled its Open Handset Alliance around Android last fall, LiMO was emerging as the most significant effort to create a unified mobile Linux platform, and a string of LiPS members had already taken up membership in LiMO too, including Access (owner of the former Palm software, which it is adapting for Linux), ARM, France Telecom, Huawei, MontaVista (owner of the most commonly used mobile Linux distribution), NXP and Texas Instruments. In effect then, LiPS is being subsumed into its more impactful rival. The two initiatives did have different focuses and so, beneath their politics, they will also bring complementary developments and experience. Founded in 2005, LiPS has concentrated on standardizing Linux-based services and application programming interfaces, while LiMo has been more focused on a market-ready top-to-bottom platform, more comparable to the agendas of Android, Symbian, Apple and Adobe. The LiMo Foundation was set up in 2007 to create broad standards from operating system to higher software layers and user interface. Its main founding backers were Motorola, NTT DoCoMo, Samsung and Vodafone, all also key initial drivers of the Symbian Foundation. In February it unveiled its first wave of LiMo handsets, with 18 models from seven vendors, and so far has a clear time to market advantage over Android, which should be helped by the merger with LiPS.

Despite the furore around unified smartphone platforms, developers remain focused on the technologies they know best, and software that spans multiple mobile and PC operating systems and frameworks ‘ notably Java, with Ajax coming up behind ‘ remains more important to attracting programmers than individual systems. So, in a new survey by Evans Data, it emerged that more developers are targeting their applications at Java Mobile Edition and also at Microsoft’s .Net Compact Framework than at individual mobile OSs such as Linux or Windows Mobile 6.0. This is clearly because these platforms allow one application to be ported relatively easily across server, PC and mobile devices, rather than being confined to a mobile internet market that, at this stage, remains small and fragmented compared to the PC web.

Among 384 professional mobile developers worldwide polled by Evans Data, 42% said they were creating applications for Java ME and 41% for .Net CF, with Linux and Windows Mobile 6 coming next in line. Only 7% of developers were creating apps for Android or mobile Mac OS, though of course, both are newcomers to the market. In terms of devices, 56% are targeting Nokia products, followed by Motorola (33%) and Sony Ericsson (29%). Respondents said the biggest obstacle to creating wireless applications remains cross-platform testing requirements, followed by lack of access to device APIs.

OpenMoko:

Open source mobile phone developer, Openmoko, has revealed the first five distributors that will be selling the consumer version of its Linux-based touchscreen device, the Neo Freerunner.

Openmoko has begun shipping the Freerunner to Pulster, Golden Delicious Computers and TRIsoft located in Germany, Bearstech in France and IDA Systems in India. The consumer gadget has a suggested retail price of $399 and will also be available from Openmoko’s web site. The company said it will announce availability in other regions of the world at LinuxWorld Expo in San Francisco on August 5.

Openmoko, a subsidiary of Taiwanese manufacturer First International Computer, unveiled its gadget earlier this year. Based on the open source Neo 1973 platform, it uses a similar form factor, with a 2.8inch VGA touchscreen, Assisted GPS, 128Mb of memory, a microSD card slot, Bluetooth and USB, as well as Wi-Fi and motion sensors and a 500MHz processor. The device will come in two versions – an 850MHz triband and a 900Mhz triband – and will ship with a basic developer platform. Subsequent software can be downloaded from the Openmoko developer site.

The Symbian open source process:

The formation of the Symbian Foundation may have wrongfooted the Linux camps, but it will be a long process to deliver the first truly open source products of the new venture. Nokia’s senior VP for Series 60, Lee Williams, outlined a three-phase process in an interview with EETimes.

First, it will contribute to the new, non-profit Symbian Foundation the core code behind Symbian’s operating system along with Nokia’s Series 60 user interface, middleware and other elements, under a royalty-free license program. However, royalty payments will not stop until the first quarter of next year, so until then, handset makers will still be paying up to $5 a unit for the OS plus other fees if they use Series 60.

In phase two, other technology members will go through the same process. For instance, Sony Ericsson and Motorola will donate the UIQ platform and NTT DoCoMo its MOAP technology, and these will be integrated into the unified Symbian platform. This could take up to two years, starting from the end of 2008, said Williams.

In the third phase, expected to begin in 2011, the Foundation’s offerings will finally start to evolve with the help of the open source community. Development results will be released to the community under the Eclipse Public License (EPL), often described as the most ‘business friendly’ of the open source license models, thanks to its roots in technology backed by IBM and other enterprise software majors. Williams said EPL can provide “proper protection for core sourcecode’, allowing developers to do “derivative work” while giving licensees “strong ability for differentiation’.

Symbian makes an average royalty of just over $8 on each unit carrying its OS. More than 18m Symbian phones were shipped worldwide in the first quarter of 2008, according to the firm. This suggests Nokia underpaid when it shelled out $411m for the 52% of the organization that it did not own, but of course, it will forgo royalty revenues after this year. Symbian has over 1,400 freeware programs, 5,500 developers, and countless commercial applications (including, of course, Google search), with an average selling price of $20.35, according to the company.