The cellular industry badly needs to achieve a strong position for LTE among the connectivity standards for the internet of things (IoT), or risk its ecosystem losing out to WiFi or specialist M2M networks. While most players accept the IoT will run on a range of different, interconnecting networks, Mobile World Congress was the logical venue for 4G vendors and operators to put the case for LTE.
Huawei was demonstrating its contributions to future LTE-M standards (see Wireless Watch February 26 2015), while the LTE-only baseband specialists, such as Sequans and Altair, have a major opportunity to push 4G-only solutions into a mass market. While the 3GPP works on LTE Category 0 as the underpinning of LTE-M, for now the vendors have resurrected Cat-1, whose low data rates made it a Cinderella specification in the broadband world, but whose ultra-low power consumption now makes it a candidate for the cellular IoT.
France-based Sequans recently completed a national US trial of LTE Cat-1 in partnership with Ericsson and Verizon, using Sequans’ single-mode LTE chipsets. Cat-1 dates way back to Release 8 of the LTE specifications, and defines a far lower bandwidth version of the standard that can potentially be used for the types of M2M application that currently use GSM.
The current push to move to LTE from 2G (now) and 3G (eventually) is being driven by the MNOs’ desire to reuse their existing 2G spectrum and refarm it into LTE-ready deployments. With the benefits of LTE in IP packetization, reduced latency, and IPv6 addressability; if the MNOs eventually sunset their 2G infrastructure, the existing and potential future M2M and IoT deployments need to find new homes in LTE – hence Cat-1 and eventually Cat-0.
However, Cat-1 and then Cat-0 require new hardware at the infrastructure level to function, and this was the main thrust of the Sequans-Ericsson-Verizon trial – which aimed to prove that the new Cat-1 technology was interoperable with existing LTE deployments, so that smart meters or remote sensors don’t brick someone’s Netflix stream.
All three companies are calling the trial a success, with the lower data rate Cat-1 technology (up to a maximum of 10Mbps download and 5Mbps uplink) proving itself capable. As Cat-1 applications, such as remote sensing, don’t require a lot of bandwidth (preferring a longer battery life and smaller form factor to blazing-fast upload speeds), the spec has been designed to lower the device cost and power consumption – at the expense of the (unnecessary) bandwidth.
Craig Miller, Sequans’ VP of worldwide marketing, does not believe Cat-1 will overtake 2G for remote sensing. For most apps in this area, it doesn’t clearly provide an advantage over the established technology. Cat-0, which is part of Release 12 and was designed from scratch for M2M, will be a different case. It promises to provide 1Mbps download and upload, using only one physical antenna, compared to the two that are required for other LTE implementations. Consequently, this promises to reduce the cost of the device modules, as well as reduce the complexity of the software that is needed to manage them, and the hardware on which to run that – thanks to the parallel reductions in the size of the frequency channels that the modules use.
As such, a Cat-1 chip isn’t really software upgradeable to Cat-0, as it still packs the redundant (and expensive) LTE hardware – offsetting any savings in bandwidth usage or power consumption. Cat-0 requires a ground-up development approach.
So for operators who make the transition to LTE Cat-1 and -0, which requires significant capex and R&D investment in their networks, the opportunity to provide connectivity services for a new class of IoT device awaits. But ‘waits’ is the key word here, as Cat-0 roll-outs are not going to appear until 2016 or early 2017.
On the module side, once the correct cellular networks exist, Miller said that the opportunity exists for Cat-1 and Cat-0 to outperform the legacy 2G devices in terms of module cost.
Meanwhile, Altair has unveiled two chipsets for Cat-1 and Cat-0. Co-founder Eran Eshed said that the 2G M2M networks are “going to be sunset in the not-so-distant future. Carriers really need some upgrade paths and way to address the needs of the next billion devices.”
Altair’s 1160 chip supports Cat-1, while its 1150 is a “stepping stone toward Release 13”, at 2G price points.