Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 May 2008

LTE patent situation remains fragmented, threatening no-subsidy handset

One of the main upsides that cellular operators can see from the move to open mobile internet models is the opportunity to do away with the handset subsidies that squeeze their margins in many developed markets, including north America and most of Europe. Open access to their networks from any device creates many nightmares for cellcos, but also the chance to avoid the subsidy ‘ initially a tool to stimulate uptake when mobile networks were new, but now a millstone around their necks. But there are many obstacles in the path of the no-subsidy handset. One is that, unless IPR charges in advanced devices are lower than in 3G, device costs will be prohibitive for most users, curbing uptake of open internet services. If this proves true, operators may see customers reluctant to venture off the closed network, as AT&T has already predicted ‘ with the advantage of keeping control of the subscriber and keeping his or her bandwidth usage at a manageable level for the network; but with the downside of being stuck with the subsidy indefinitely. Already, the cheerleader for open access and the ditching of the subsidy, Sprint Nextel, is widely expected to pay towards a user’s adoption of its flagship Xohm device, the upcoming Nokia 810 internet tablet for WiMAX; and even the notion that a sufficiently desirable handset will lure users to pay full price is fading, as AT&T prepares to subsidize the Apple iPhone as its European carriers already have (it is reported to be planning to offer the $399 and $499 3G iPhones at $200 discount).

But the critical issue as the industry moves towards next generation mobile broadband systems is the level of IPR charging. Intel and Samsung have sought to spearhead an open, transparent and low royalty structure for WiMAX patents, in order to deliver the WiMAX Forum’s promise that its technology would be better than 3G in this respect ‘ but so far actual charges remain vague. Last month, a group of vendors ‘ the big European cellular vendors plus NEC and NextWave ‘ formed an alliance that mutually agreed to limit the royalty fees they would charge one another for LTE technologies in handsets, and invited the rest of the industry to join. However, at least four probable major patent holders in LTE ‘ Qualcomm, Nortel, Motorola and InterDigital ‘ have remained outside, and now Nortel has confirmed fears of a long-drawn out debate over licensing practises and fees, announcing a unilateral system of its own.

The LTE grouping (see Wireless Watch April 15 2008), whose major members are Nokia Siemens, Nokia, Ericsson, Sony Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent, wants the maximum aggregate royalty bill in an LTE handset to be a single digit percentage of the sale price (Nokia and Ericsson have pushed, so far unsuccessfully, partly due to their own charges and partly to Qualcomm’s opposition, for a 5% ceiling in 3G.) Nortel says it will have its own licensing system, rather than joining a group, but this will be consistent and open to all and will be based on ‘about’ a 1% royalty rate to handset vendors. It claimed its early statement of intent would ‘provide increased transparency and predictability’ and ‘help simplify the current guesswork, while ensuring that its innovation is rewarded.’ Clear statements certainly help reduce the risk associated with early deployment of new technologies ‘ and would be welcome from some WiMAX patent holders ‘ but the nature and timing of Nortel’s announcement also shows it holding itself aloof from an even more productive approach of joining an industry consensus. This may be for political motives, but also suggests Nortel believes ‘ as it has often stated ‘ that it has significant IPR in LTE that might go under-rewarded in a communal system where it would have to fight for its share against other giants. Although its suggested rates are lower than Qualcomm’s are in existing technologies (the CDMA giant, short of refusing to join the new group, has not shown its hand on its licensing position in LTE) Nortel is essentially pursuing the same route as its chip partner, preferring to set its own rates and maintain control rather than join any pool.

‘Nortel believes that pioneers and innovators should be entitled to a reasonable return on their investment in R&D and leading contributions to the next generation standard, where not all patents are created equal,’ said John Hoadley, VP of 4G ecosystem and development at Nortel, in a statement.

Nortel has been placing greater stress on its IPR assets in the past year or so, as its equipment business has come under pressure. The first sign of the importance to the company of its patent holdings in the future LTE standard was highlighted in March 2007 when it was reported as signing a four-year, $15m licensing deal with Alcatel-Lucent for pre-LTE technologies and IPR (shortly after the French giant had purchased Nortel’s UMTS activities). In this era of consolidation of equipment makers, vendors will look to apply their R&D results to a wider market through licensing to their traditional rivals.

Nortel believes it has contributed significantly to OFDMA-based standards including LTE. In 2006, it gained 3GPP approval for its HSOPA (High Speed OFDM Packet Access) technology, which combines OFDM and MIMO smart antennas, for inclusion in LTE, although it is not yet clear how the mixture of technical elements, and IPR, will work out in the final specs. The HSOPA project drew on many of the areas into which Nortel has ploughed R&D resources in recent years, particularly smart antenna arrays, OFDM and mesh networking. Nortel claimed that its HSOPA/LTE prototype demonstrated the potential to increase tenfold the number of users that could be served by an operator’s network and to reduce the cost per megabyte to the operator to a potential one-twentieth of current UMTS costs.

Of course, the 1% of the company’s new proposal is not quite as consistent as it may seem, since most licensing deals involve an element of cross-trading for other patents. In the footnote to its announcement, the company says: ‘Nortel will license its LTE standards essential patent claims for LTE handsets at a royalty rate of about 1% on the sale price, subject to specific terms to reciprocity, defensive suspension, and grantback to Nortel products, services and solutions, as well as other customary license terms and conditions.’

Meanwhile Qualcomm, which tends to be blamed ‘ and sometimes scapegoated ‘ for the high IPR charges in UMTS (ignoring the fact they used to be even higher in GSM, where Qualcomm did not play), has been predictably negative about the Nokia-Ericsson LTE group. ‘This type of approach would have a negative impact on competition within the industry and consumer choice as it would restrict innovations,’ the company told RCRnews.

UK chipmakers: CSR down, picoChip up, mixed fortunes for Icera

Last week was one of mixed fortunes for UK semiconductor companies. In the wake of reduced Q1 profit and further job cuts at ARM Holdings, Bluetooth specialist CSR saw its shares fall by 25% as it reported a $41.9m quarterly loss, and Icera said it would have to delay its planned IPO. On the positive side though, Icera revealed details of its next generation wireless modem chipset, which should enable it to expand beyond PC cards to handsets; and its neighbor picoChip, a pioneer of chips for femtocells, saw products based on its silicon claiming all top three places in the first survey of these high profile miniature indoor base stations.

Cambridge-based CSR has been struggling to expand its revenue base beyond the Bluetooth market, where it has major market share, but where it faces falling prices and challenges from multi-radio chipset makers like Broadcom. The company’s shares fell by as much as 25% on the announcement that it had taken a $52.9m charge for its 2005 acquisition of Ubinetics, a charge that helped create a first quarter loss of $41.9m, reversing a $3.3m profit in the same quarter in 2007. CSR also suffered a drop in demand for its Bluetooth products from its core customer bases, mobile phonemakers and vendors of Bluetooth headsets. Sales during the quarter rose by less than 1% to $160.9m and the company said second quarter revenue will be $175m to $200m, again weaker than expected.

CSR took the charge because the ‘market has moved on’ since it bought Ubinetics’ software business ‘ which specialized in protocol stacks for cellphone development ‘ and it can no longer justify the price it paid, in a sector that is overcrowded and slow growing. In a statement, the company said: “In the three years following the acquisition, the market has evolved and CSR’s view, which is shared by most in the industry, is that integration of Bluetooth and other communications technologies onto the baseband is unlikely to happen due to the practical difficulties of integration and the differing timescales of product development. The standalone baseband market is crowded and mature and as such does not offer CSR an acceptable level of growth opportunity. In contrast, we are focusing on the connectivity center to expand the footprint in the handset.”

Over at Icera, the privately held fabless chip company acknowledged it had delayed a planned IPO until about 2010, planning instead to raise more venture capital to fund its moves into LTE. Icera is the most highly funded wireless chipmaker in the UK, followed by picoChip. According to EETimes, Icera may need to look for about $100m in new funding, which would be a colossal sum by the standards of European fabless chip start-ups. Vice president of marketing, Nigel Toon, said in an interview: “We were thinking of an IPO in 2009. With LTE coming down the pike we will likely delay the IPO until 2010 and raise some more money privately. It will allow us to address coming standards at a more aggressive pace.” Icera, founded in 2002, has raised $142m and also diluted its venture capitalists’ position when it bought Sirific Wireless in April, adding Sirific’s $63m of VC to its total. Adding another $100m would mean the investors would be looking at an IPO that could raise about $1.5bn, something Toon claims is achievable.

Icera may be burning cash, with its W-CDMA modem chipset only in the market for less than a year, but it is acknowledged to be ahead of the game in its sector, with a flagship customer in Japan’s Softbank and a technical lead over the only other company shipping working HSPA silicon for this product category, Qualcomm. In July, benchtests by Signals Research showed Icera’s HSDPA chipset outperforming those of Qualcomm and Ericsson Mobile Platforms, the latter pre-commercial; and also inhouse designed products from Motorola and Nokia. However, Qualcomm has since been hard on its heels with its MSM7200, which adopts techniques like simultaneous equalization and receive diversity techniques, which Icera had implemented to achieve its performance boost. This makes it imperative that Icera gets its next generation product to market quickly, and can spread its tentacles wider than the important but limited laptop card sector. The card market went from 5m units in 2006 to 20m units in 2007 and is expected to reach 45m-50m units this year, but Qualcomm has the vast majority of that (the US giant is reported to have done $350m in the card area alone last year). Icera CEO Stan Boland is now targeting 33% of this sector by the end of 2009, which could equate to about $250m in revenue, and the company also expects to expand into handsets in the latter half of 2009, around the time it also anticipates hitting cash positive status.

Now the company is launching its next generation HSPA product and moving to LTE, a shift it says will be efficient because it uses a software programmable architecture, and so relies on the same silicon as in 3G. It also claims to balance the power inefficiencies often associated with programmability, by allowing sections of its baseband to be switched off and on as required. The more data-focused the Icera DXP processor’s work becomes, the greater advantage this gives.

More immediately, the company is sampling the ICE8040, the second iteration of its Livanto chipset, which uses a 65nm process, and should be in volume product in July this year. Livanto ICE8040 supports Icera’s Adaptive Wireless software modem to deliver Category 8 HSDPA at up to 7.2Mbps and Category 6 HSUPA at up to 5.76Mbps with dual antenna receive diversity. The chipset also provides full 2G/3G support including GSM, GPRS, EDGE and W-CDMA and a compressed mode handover between 2G and 3G. Included in the product is the former Sirific product, a multiband RF CMOS transceiver, the ICE8215.

Also ahead of Qualcomm and the other wireless chip giants is picoChip with its femtocell silicon, which is the only openly available such product on the market, although some vendors are delivering products based on their own designs, while large players like Texas Instruments may enter the market as femtocells reach the mainstream from 2009. picoChip’s technology is at the heart of femtocells from Ubiquisys, Sagem (for Alcatel-Lucent), and ip.access, which have emerged as the three winners in a new survey by ABI Research. The research house has analyzed all the available products according to a range of technical and commercial criteria, presenting the results in a Femtocell Vendor Matrix (see http://www.abiresearch.com/products/vendor_matrix/Femtocell_Equipment_Vendor_Matrix).

In terms of ‘implementation’ – which covers areas like carrier relations and RFPs, vendor stability, ecosystem and ability to scale ‘ Alcatel-Lucent comes out top. In the other set of criteria, ‘innovation’, ABI picks out RadioFrame Networks, with elements including technical and functionality advances, scalability, cost and integration with other devices such as gateways or IPTV set-top boxes. Across all the categories, UK-based Ubiquisys scores most highly, followed by AlcaLu, ip.access, Airvana, Huawei, Samsung, RadioFrame, Airwalk, Ericsson and 2Wire (in that order). ABI research director Stuart Carlaw commented: “Interestingly, major players in this market such as Cisco, Motorola, NEC and Nokia are not represented in the measurement matrix as they are positioning themselves as complete solution providers and have chosen not to produce their own products but to partner instead with dedicated box vendors.”

Despite its general positivity about femtocells, ABI’s latest forecast on the technology predicts that only 100,000 will ship this year, but this number will soar to tens of millions in 2010, when the operators’ coveted $100 price tag will be within reach.