M2Z Networks, the US start-up whose proposal for a free broadband service in the 2155-2175MHz band was rejected by the FCC, is not giving up without a fight. It is taking the regulator to court to seek an overturn of the decision, and bolstering its case by creating a partnership with rural telcos to provide low cost services in underserved areas ‘ provided the FCC rethinks its ruling.
The perceived value of this spectrum has grown since the FCC started considering its usage, and the regulator says it believes there are other business cases to be taken into account, and so the licenses should not be handed over too automatically to one organization. This goes to the heart of an important debate in US telecoms ‘ how to balance the need to stimulate advanced new services and mobile internet business models, with the need to get basic broadband to underserved rural or low income regions. Many of the spectrum bands coming available can be used for both purposes, but depending on which driver takes precedence, will need to be adopted by different types of operators with different commercial models.
M2Z, headed by former FCC wireless chief John Muleta, is firmly in the camp that believes new US spectrum allocations should prioritize on achieving universal, affordable broadband, before supporting new services that primarily target existing user bases with enhanced experiences and ARPU.
The organization, set up last year specifically to lobby for spectrum licenses, is now asking the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to overturn the agency’s dismissal of its nationwide wireless broadband plan. It proposed gaining a 15-year license for free and paying the FCC 5% of gross revenues for the period of the license. It would then offer a mixture of free, paid-for and wholesale services with an emphasis on family friendly offerings. The wireless industry objected to the idea that M2Z would not have to compete in an auction.
Silicon Valley-backed M2Z claims the FCC violated numerous laws in throwing out its free broadband idea. Last week FCC chairman Kevin Martin said his agency would launch a rulemaking exercise to examine all the options for the band. Other proposals were also made, though they were not public like M2Z’s.
Muleta’s organization is now adopting a new tactic, which is to strengthen its case through its new deal with rural telcos. This involves M2Z wholesaling wireless broadband services to 20 rural wireline carriers, which would then sell this on as part of a converged bundle. M2Z also would purchase access to rural telecom facilities and coordinate marketing with rural telephone service providers. The participating carriers serve two million customers in 35 states.
‘M2Z has always been committed to a wholesale business model and partnerships like these will help our company achieve our goal of closing the digital divide in the United States,’ said Muleta.
Muleta said the deal demonstrates the need for a wholesale nationwide broadband network, especially as this has not been mandated in any area of the 700MHz band, despite calls from companies like Google. He also pointed out that the FCC has not extended obligatory voice roaming between mobile carriers to wireless data, so some rural areas could find they have no access to services. Rural carriers see the January 2008 auction of 700MHz spectrum as a huge opportunity, as the low frequencies support large cells and cost effective coverage of sparse populations, but with all the sound and fury around the band, it may well fall into the hands of internet players or large carriers, whose track record is not strong in underserved areas.