Rather like Qualcomm, Vodafone would prefer that WiMAX had never come along to challenge the technologies and models in which it has invested so much, but would rather turn the newcomer to its own advantage than let it become only a weapon for new competitors. So the news that the giant cellco is deploying WiMAX in the European island state of Malta almost certainly sets the stage for wider experiments with the technology, though whether these are geared to serious adoption of 802.16, or to pressurizing vendors to hasten progress on LTE, will depend on how quickly Ericsson and the other WiMAX naysayers respond.
Vodafone has been relaxing its once hostile stance on WiMAX for more than a year, and has been unofficially interested in it for far longer than that. It publicly accepted that WiMAX would be part of the mobile broadband picture, even while asserting that HSPA would be adequate for all Vodafone’s needs in areas where it had appropriate spectrum. Now, as the cellcos start to look to early migration to post-HSPA capabilities, to fend off challenges from WiMAX and converged IP operators, Vodafone has shifted its position again, most famously when CEO Arun Sarun issued his wake-up call to the LTE community at this year’s 3GSM conference, urging it to speed up its efforts or risk losing out to 802.16. Vodafone has some other WiMAX trials, most geared to DSL replacement rather than full mobility, the most public one being through its joint venture with MTC in Bahrain. Other activities are underway through partners in France (SFR), Greece, New Zealand and South Africa. And the cellco, unlike most other UK mobile operators, came out in favor of technology neutrality in the upcoming 2.5GHz auctions when responding to consultation with regulator Ofcom (see Wireless Watch December 18 2006).
All this has created a situation where Vodafone’s once simple – if high risk – technology strategy may give way to a more complex one in which it can spread its bets and adopt the right network for the right application or terrain. It will clearly be interested in WiMAX for some markets where there is no 3G license, or it does not have a venture with a 3G carrier, especially as it sharpens its focus on emerging markets such as Africa and the Middle East.
In its western European heartland, there would still be little sense in Vodafone building out WiMAX instead of HSPA, followed by LTE, if it were still attached to a mobile-only plan. But as well as shifting its focus from creating a universal brand in all mature markets, towards high growth emerging economies, Vodafone has also been forced by the changes driven by all-IP to move towards convergence. In some countries this has meant buying or partnering with wireline broadband ISPs, such as British Telecom in its home territory, but in others it may well look to a technology that can support fixed access as well as mobility, or work as a fixed/nomadic, data-driven overlay for a 3G voice-oriented network.
The Malta roll-out will be powered by equipment from Airspan, and will deliver fixed and nomadic services, including VoIP, for residential and business customers, under the ‘Mobile Plus’ brand, which will also be integrated with the cellular offerings to support fixed/mobile convergence. This will provide a direct equivalent to the Wi-Fi/DSL/cellular systems being adopted by wireline carriers such as BT, and shows the way Vodafone could go in other markets where it does not have an ISP, but can gain a 3.5GHz license, as it has in Malta and Greece. If mobility is permitted in these fixed-only bands in future, Vodafone will be able to upgrade its Airspan HiperMAX base stations in software to mobile 802.16e (Airspan uses the picoChip base station designs, which support software upgrade between different WiMAX variants).
In its last annual results, Vodafone reported fixed line and DSL revenues of £1.5bn ($3bn) in a total of £31bn ($62bn). Most of that is from its German fixed line subsidiary, Arcor, the second largest broadband player in the country after Deutsche Telekom.