‘Stick to your knitting’ is an adage more technology companies should heed. They rarely do however, as they look enviously over the wall at another firm’s shining business model, forgetting that it may be entirely at odds with their own. No firm is more envied than Apple, and there have been some momentous failures to emulate its vertically integrated hardware/software model (not to mention its image creation).
Google, at least, hastily realized that low margin devices had no place in its world of web services and advertising, and offloaded Motorola Mobility to Lenovo (and of course it got some valuable patents in the process). Now Microsoft and Amazon need to do the same.
Microsoft’s operating systems, apps and services rely on reaching as many devices as possible, hence its multivendor PC ecosystem and its increasing willingness to run Office and even Cortana on Android and iOS. But it still went ahead and acquired Nokia’s devices business, and though CEO Satya Nadella has slashed that unit, he refuses to let go completely, a hesitancy which could be costly, not just in direct losses, but in conflicts of interest with device partners like Acer. Microsoft may have achieved the rare feat of wrongfooting Apple, whose iPad Pro is a clear response to the Surface Pro hybrid, but it should not let that go to its head – one of its Windows tablet licensees could have done the same. The only device which works for Microsoft is the Xbox, and that is because it is profitable (which was itself a long hard road) and it does not compete with the Windows giant’s own partners.
Amazon launched its Kindle readers and tablets to disruptive effect, tying them tightly to an optimized experience for its own content and services. But its smartphone failed, and as a retailer, it has been ill-equipped to build a broad developer and apps ecosystem for its forked Android implementation. Like Microsoft, it really needs to get its goods and content to as many devices as possible, and let go of investing in its own tablets and app stores – rather than launching even cheaper Fires (as it did this week) and preparing to take on the iPad Pro with a large-screened Fire.
Amazon has not distinguished the reading and viewing experience on its own tablets sufficiently from that on mainstream Android, and it has lost the initial impact of pricing its slates very low, as loss-leaders for the content, because there are so many cheap Android devices on the market now. The ereaders and Amazon TV are worth keeping because they do support an optimized content experience and do not compete with important Amazon allies. But like Microsoft, Amazon needs to remember what it is good at (cloud services, retailing, content negotiations) and avoid the bear-pit of the smartphone market.
Neither firm looks likely to heed this advice just yet. Considering the challenges he inherited, Nadella has made some brave choices, but one area where his strategy is still bemusing is hardware. In the spirit of his new start as a ‘mobile first, cloud first’ company, Nadella wants to be in “every mobile end-point”, but that doesn’t require it to create the hardware.
Of course, he did slash the former Nokia division and backed away from many of its products, but he retained three lines of devices – enterprise, entry level and high end – which is pretty much a complete handset business, though with fewer models than before. A big event scheduled for October 6 will focus almost entirely on mobile hardware, showing off the smartphone thread of Windows 10 – a signal that Nadella is certainly not cutting the hardware albatross loose.
His renewed enthusiasm for devices gave some credibility to Wall Street rumors, which swirled over the weekend, that Microsoft might acquire all or part of troubled chipmaker AMD. That should be a ridiculous idea, if the Windows giant really was turning its back on its handset experiment, but in fact, many analysts were taking the idea of a second illogical hardware acquisition seriously.
While the conflicts of interest with Microsoft’s Intel relationship are a major hurdle, ‘Wintel’ is not as strong as it was, and Microsoft has been seeking to extend Windows onto the ARM platform. Windows Phone is already there, and W10 will run on small tablets as well as handsets, but after the poor launch of ARM-based Windows 8 RT, the W10 focus has been strongly back on x86. But of course, AMD would bring both an ARM licence and long x86 history, plus growing expertise in cross-platform x86/ARM developments.
In a client note, analysts at Piper Jaffray wrote that a deal “would be consistent with the recent beefing up of chip design talent by other large tech vendors.” That has been seen most notably at Apple – but Apple is a major hardware designer, while Microsoft should be drawing a firm line under former CEO Steve Ballmer’s dream of following the iPhone maker into an integrated device/software/content platform.
Where an AMD deal would make more sense is not in the mobile arena but for the Xbox, Microsoft’s most successful hardware product, which uses AMD’s Jaguar processing platform. Microsoft could gain greater control over the development of the Xbox’s silicon and wrongfoot rival AMD customers like Nintendo.
Such an acquisition would be a distraction, however, in a year when it is vital that Microsoft establishes W10 not just in its PC heartland, but in the markets where Windows has never thrived, like smartphones, as well as new segments which are till up for grabs, like connected cars and homes and the emerging internet of things.
The October 6 event should give a far better idea of how W10 will work on smartphones and is expected to see the launch of the first new flagships in the Lumia range for several years. Before and after the acquisition of this business with Nokia, the focus has been on squeezing rich feature sets into midmarket and entry level devices in order to push Windows into emerging markets and build on Nokia’s traditional strengths in countries like India.
Now the new Lumia 950 and 950 XL will, once again, attempt the impossible, stealing high end share from iOS and Android at a time when even giants like the Samsung Galaxy S6 Edge are struggling.
According to reports, the Lumia 950 will sport a 5.2-inch WQHD screen while the 950 XL will have a 5.7-inch screen. Both phones will have Nokia’s trademark strong imaging technology – 20-megapixel PureView rear cameras with triple LED flash and 5-megapixel wide-angle front-facing cameras. The 950 XL is expected to have a slightly faster processor and larger battery, but both will support Qi wireless charging.
Other devices should also make their debuts, including a Surface Pro 4 tablet/PC hybrid, which will be particularly significant given the new challenge from Apple’s iPad Pro; and a new Microsoft Band wearable.
Since Microsoft finalized its acquisition of Nokia Devices & Services in April 2014, it has seen its share of the global smartphone market fall from 2.8% to 2.5%. However, a report from OperaMediaworks said that in large economies like India, Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam, about one-third of the population does not use Android or iOS.
That means there is still a significant addressable market for alternatives – whether Windows or a new OS such as Jolla Sailfish – and some of those have strong bases of legacy Nokia devices. But having dropped the Nokia brand, Microsoft cannot take advantage of the high awareness of that name, and does it really want to enter the vicious price war which is mounting in the entry level smartphone space, taking on companies like Xiaomi rather than seeking to build on its early W10 relationships with that vendor, and many others.
Meanwhile, Amazon may have backed away from smartphones, but it will not give up on tablets. This week, it unveiled its cheapest Kindle Fire yet, a 7-inch model priced at just $50.
This is in line with Amazon’s device strategy since the first Fire – making them cheap enough that everyone can buy one, including children, and they can even be an impulse purchase, or given away free with content such as a newspaper subscription. The new addition to the family even comes with a bulk buying option – buy five, get the sixtho one free.
The budget approach was refreshing and interesting when the first Fire made its debut, at a time when tablets were still seen as premium items. Now, Amazon could leave the work of getting tablets into every pair of hands to the makers of low cost Chinese gadgets, and either do deals with them to pre-instal its Kindle and Prime apps, or rely on the huge power of its brand and advertising.
However, it continues to flesh out the Fire range and it does pack in more features than most low cost tablet makers provide for under $100. Indeed, it claims that the new device is twice as powerful as other budget tablets and with a better quality screen, and it comes with a memory card slot and an updated version of the Amazon Android-based OS, called Bellini. It also unveiled two new Fire HD models with 8-inch and 10.1-inch displays, and a 4K upgrade to Amazon TV.
Its next release will, according to Wall Street Journal sources, be a 12-inch tablet targeted at business users, probably with a keyboard like the Surface Pro and iPad Pro. Given the direction of the tablet market – declining sales for slates, with growth focused on the enterprise and on hybrids/detachables – this is likely to be true. But that will pitch Amazon against Microsoft, Apple and Samsung in a market where it does not have their natural advantages. Retailers usually succeed by being ferociously single-minded – indeed, that is often cited as the reason for WalMart’s success. Amazon should remember that, for all its digital trappings, it remains a retailer, and should stick to its knitting.