Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 January 2006

Mobile TV and UWB are key wireless themes at CES

In the largest annual gathering of the consumer electronics industry, the CES show in Last Vegas last week, wireless devices took a more central role than ever before, as the giants intensify their focus on home networks and mobile services. Among the vast array of innovations on show, two of the key themes were mobile television and the emerging personal area network platform, UltraWideBand (UWB).

There was a rush of developments in the mobile television arena in CES week. Samsung, as well as showing off its first Wi-Bro smartphones, also said that it would build handsets for Qualcomm’s mobile TV system, MediaFLO, as will fellow Korean LG. Both handset makers have their main strength in the Qualcomm CDMA market. The phones, which have no launch dates as yet, would be mainly for the US market, where MediaFLO will be used by Verizon, but possibly also for Korea itself. Although the Korean government favors the homegrown T-DMB standard, operators claim they will trial alternatives ‘ primarily MediaFLO and the DVB-H (Digital Video Broadcasting-Handheld) platform supported by Nokia and others ‘ unless the regulator, KCC, supports a more attractive profit model for DMB. The regulator has insisted that it is a free to air TV service and will not allow a delivery charge for the service.

Consequently the entire Korean mobile TV ecosystem seems to have ground to a halt. Carriers do not want T-DMB because they see no ARPU in it for themselves, and worry it will cannibalize existing services. As a result broadcasters will not adapt content for the service. Consequently LG and Samsung are both supposed to have phones ready for T-DMB, but few orders, and so have held back on production. Qualcomm may yet get into Korea by the back door by offering operators a way of charging for mobile TV services, although of course MediaFLO can only be launched on spectrum that is controlled by the KCC, making the entire process circular.

A more certain market for MediaFLO will be Japan, following the creation of a joint venture between Qualcomm and second placed cellco KDDI to explore the licensing of suitable spectrum for MediaFLO. The unit, MediaFlo Japan Planning, will be 80% owned by KDDI, which will make an initial investment of $85,000.

The news came just days after the largest Japanese cellco, NTT DoCoMo, announced a $185m investment in Fuji Television Network, with a view to developing and controlling new mobile broadcasting services.

Not that DVB-H is falling behind either. Heavily backed by Nokia, it is expected to dominate in Europe and Crown Castle and Nokia are building a network in the US, which could well be adopted by Cingular. Crown Castle will launch commercial mobile TV services in the 30 largest markets in the US during 2006 and 2007 under a new brand, Modeo, and is currently trialing handsets and portable devices developed by Nokia and Motorola. It plans to offer 10 video channels and at least 24 audio channels, though the company hasn’t signed a programming deal or named any operator partners. It is also looking beyond cellphones, citing plans to offer viewing on other portable devices such as music players and laptops, and in cars.

The most recent convert is in Italy, where Mediset ‘ the broadcaster controlled by the family of premier Silvio Berlusconi – has bought vital spectrum for the delivery of a DVB-H service, which it will launched by the middle of the year in time for the football World Cup. The infrastructure and frequencies have been purchased from Europa TV, a firm controlled by businessman Tarak ben Ammar and the French broadcaster TF1. The deal was announced with no price tag, but it must have been measured in hundreds of millions of dollars.

Europa will retain a minority stake, thought to be around 20%, and the option to take its own TV channels onto the mobile datacasting network. Telecom Italia will also have a stake. Mediaset cut a deal in October for Telecom Italia Mobile to pool resources to bring the precious Italian football viewing rights to the mobile phone. The joint venture has signed up for football broadcasts from 2006 to 2011 from both the Serie A Italian League and the European Champions League, and will also offer programming from Canale 5, Retequattro, Italia Uno.

Mediaset is now proposing to also invite mobile operator H3G to carry the datacasting channels rather than build a separate competing network, and is known to be in talks with Vodafone to offer the same broadcast mobile TV channels through its Vodafone Italy service.

Meanwhile, the mobile TV market is getting even more crowded. As well as MediaFLO, DVB-H and DMB, some vendors are experimenting with broadcasting over WiMAX in future, while IPWireless, the main proponent of the UMTS TDD broadband wireless technology, is poised to launch its own mobile television system next week. This will be a solution that uses spare capacity in the 3G network itself ‘ as does the most commonly used current system, MobiTV ‘ rather than requiring a dedicated network as the other options do.

MobiTV has been upgraded recently and Sprint Nextel and Cingular will both offer MobiTV2 from this month. This update improves the user interface, with a programming guide that displays two hours of show information and enhances the older service’s audio and video quality. It aims to provide a user interface that is identical to that of the home cable or satellite channel guide.’

Although many regulators are expected to join the US FCC this year in legalizing UWB – which promises to carry data at up to gigabit speeds over short distances and form the basis of home networks and fast interconnect standards ‘ the industry remains split between two would-be standards. One, backed by the WiMedia Alliance, has now been ratified by standards body ECMA, while the other, Freescale’s Direct Sequence UWB, remains a candidate for the upcoming IEEE standard, 802.15.3a. However, it is more probable that the IEEE will, rather than splitting the industry, adopt the WiMedia specification too, leaving the Freescale group to fall into line or pursue a de facto platform.

However the politics play out, the vendors are starting to make their choices and the UWB chipmakers from both camps are rolling out real world products at last. The WiMedia Alliance plans to start interoperability testing for supporting chipmakers later this month, with an event on January 23, which will build on informal tests already carried out by various suppliers in Intel’s laboratories. Formal certification of devices as being compliant with WiMedia and interoperable with each other is expected in the second half of this year.

One of WiMedia’s key victories last year was to be adopted as the basis of the Wireless USB standard, providing a wire-free version of the most widely used PC-peripheral interconnect mechanism. Undeterred, Freescale is offering its own wireless route for USB manufacturers, which it claims will be adopted, despite its lack of standards backing, for its more immediate availability and performance advantages. Called Cable-Free USB, it will be incorporated into consumer products from Belkin and Gefen shortly.

Cable-Free USB, initially announced last year, leverages the existing USB 2.0 specification and so does not require consumers to upgrade or replace their hardware, install software or new drivers.

One of the most innovative companies in UWB is Pulse~Link, which focuses on extended range for the standard and on the high definition television market. The CES show saw a bid by Pulse~Link to usurp the wired home network, with a version of its CWave UWB running over coax, instead of over its usual radio pulses. Pulse~Link is the largest patent holder in UWB technology and has previously targeted connecting high definition devices around the home using wireless UWB.

This is effectively a bid for the cabling protocol for the home, and the CWave signal will carry a 400Mbps signal throughout a home. Other signaling systems, such as powerline, MoCa or 802.11n run at around 90-100Mbps.

Also focused on UWB for HDTV was Focus Enhancements, which demonstrated transmission of high definition television through a wall using WiMedia-supporting technology. The company expects to sample UWB chipsets in mid-2005, and modules containing UWB chipsets towards the end of the year. “The demand on the video application set is going to be a taxing set of goals, and the radios and the configuration are going to have to be tweaked and looked at’so I think it’ll take a little bit longer than just being able to do wireless,” the company said. Like Pulse~Link it is looking at longer range than most UWB specialists, around 25 meters at 200Mbps, or 880Mbps over eight meters.