The past week has shown off the two key faces of Qualcomm ‘ the aggressive defender of a power base built on its intellectual property, and the company increasingly embracing multiple technologies within its tightly integrated platforms. The chip giant stepped up its battle with Nokia, filing a new patent lawsuit against its Finnish nemesis, and also announced a single-chip offering supporting three mobile broadcasting would-be standards.
The Universal Broadcast Modem (UBM) follows in the footsteps of other recent Qualcomm announcements combining its own technologies with more open standards ‘ notably CDMA or W-CDMA with Wi-Fi. UBM supports not only the chipmaker’s own FLO mobile television system but also DVB-H and one-segment ISDB-Terrestrial.
The UBM is designed as a companion to Qualcomm’s Mobile Station Modem (MSM) baseband chipsets, but also can be used with other products. It draws on the processing power of the Enhanced Multimedia and Convergence Platforms, eliminating the need for additional dedicated application processors, and works with CDMA2000 or W-CDMA, in bandwidth from 470MHz to 862MHz, in channels of 5MHz to 8MHz. This excludes it from DVB-H deployments, such as Modeo’s in the US, which are in higher frequencies such as 1.6GHz.
“Mobile TV on handsets is gaining momentum in the wireless industry, even as network operators continue to evaluate the various standards available,” said Mike Concannon, vice president of strategic products for Qualcomm CDMA Technologies.
Meanwhile, Qualcomm has extended a lawsuit it previously filed against Nokia in the US, to the UK, where it asking for an injunction and monetary damages. Qualcomm claims that Nokia has infringed on two patents in phones that have built-in GPRS and EDGE technology and is now asking the Patents Court of the High Court of England to hear its case, calling for an injunction on all future sales of Nokia’s GSM devices ‘ still the bulk of the portfolio – as well as damages for all previous data-enabled GSM devices sold, which would account for millions of phones in the UK alone.
Nokia is also getting more obdurate. Instead of trying to bring Qualcomm to the negotiating table, it is now basing its arguments on the strength of its own patent portfolio. Nokia noted in its initial response to news of the UK suit that it holds 223 patents of the 800 related to GSM data technology and claimed: “Qualcomm’s position in GSM is clearly inferior to Nokia’s.” The suit is the latest action in a psychological war between the two companies, which are in conflict on several key fronts. Nokia, along with Ericsson, Broadcom and others, has initiated a European Commission investigation into Qualcomm’s business practises and licensing policies, as part of their bid to reduce the potential burden of royalty payments to the CDMA giant now that its technology forms the basis for both major 3G platforms. Nokia, through alliances with Texas Instruments and Sanyo, is also the only real challenger to Qualcomm’s chip business in its native CDMA2000 market, where it holds massive market share. And now the two sparring partners are deadlocked over the renegotiation of Nokia’s licensing deal for Qualcomm’s patents, which is due to expire next April.
Qualcomm’s challengers have scored some points in this war in the past few weeks. Recently, investment bank UBS reported the opinion of an International Trade Commission staff attorney that Broadcom had merit in its own patent dispute with Qualcomm, and last week UBS analyst Maynard Um wrote in a research note on Nokia that the Finnish giant’s intellectual property position within the industry was ‘strong and getting stronger’ due to significant assets in GSM and W-CDMA. Further, Um wrote, Nokia’s position relative to Qualcomm ‘appears to have improved materially’ from the time the current agreement with the chipmaker was first signed in 1992 (and extended in 2001).
Siano Mobile Silicon
Siano Mobile Silicon is to introduce a standard receiver chipset for mobile digital television (MDTV) to the Asian market.
Designated the SMS1000, the chipset is a low cost, low power, quad-band receiver that combines an RF tuner and demodulator. The SMS1000 supports DVB-H, DVB-T, DAB, Enhanced Packet Mode DAB (IP-DAB) and T-DMB mobile digital standards, in various spectrum ranges.
Siano teamed up with Taiwanese handheld device maker Inventec to integrate its chips into Inventec’s mobile and other handheld devices. The chipset will be bundled with software from InterVideo, a Taiwanese supplier of integrated digital and high definition multimedia and audio/video content solutions.
Nokia’s first EV-DO handset
Nokia has finally brought to market its first CDMA EV-DO handset, although this is not yet manufactured by the Finnish company itself, but under license by SK Teletech of Korea. Despite Nokia’s determination to avoid buying chips from Qualcomm, SK Teletech is a customer of the dominant CDMA chipmaker and the manufacturing deal may be a way for Nokia to accelerate market roll-out while it waits for new designs from its own chip partner Texas Instruments.
The Nokia 6305i is expected to be offered initially by Verizon Wireless, and is the first small step in the Finnish vendor’s planned expansion of its CDMA handset revenues. The model runs Verizon’s VCAST interface and comes with a 1.3megapixel camera and stereo speakers, but not Bluetooth, a memory card slot or access to VCast Music.