Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 March 2006

Money flows to techniques that increase value of existing infrastructure

In the past decade, wireless communications have seen the creation of new platforms at a rate scarcely equalled in any other area of technology, but with new concepts come new investment requirements, and service providers are increasingly wary of high risk proposals. So the attentions of the operator and venture capital community are drawn to a wave of new ideas that are designed to capitalize on existing infrastructure, addressing key issues such as indoor and ad hoc wireless coverage without the need for significant new systems.

This pressure is particularly strongly felt in the cellular community, where some of the traditional weaknesses of the GSM and CDMA-based systems are being addressed by Wi-Fi and WiMAX, in the hands of competitive providers. On a grand scale, we have seen the efforts to accelerate the evolution of 3G as an indoor technology to suit fixed/mobile convergence plans, but there are similar attempts to bolster cellular networks in other key areas.

One is mesh, currently the stronghold of Wi-Fi because of the relative low cost and ease with which 802.11 systems can be installed in this structure. Mesh scores highly for networks that need to be set up very quickly, but with blanket coverage, particularly in emergency situations ‘ technologies like Wi-Fi and WiMAX have gained new credibility from their use in setting up emergency communications in situations such as last year’s US hurricanes. Agilent Technologies is one company seeking to enable cellular systems to address this need too, with the filing of an interesting patent that allows handsets to communicate in a mesh-style manner.

The patent, which will be incorporated in products in the coming year, allows the cellphone to get round line of sight requirements in 3G by communicating with an out-of-range base station, by hopping via other handsets in a daisy chain manner, similar to a mesh connection. This is particularly aimed at temporary networks for emergency response or applications such as conferences, but is sure also to catch the eye of the large cellcos, which are keen to find a way to infiltrate the growing trend to create large city metrozones, rather than let these be controlled by competitive forces. Cingular and Verizon, in the US, have argued to government authorities and metrozone integrators that 3G is just as effective as Wi-Fi mesh for providing blanket wireless access ‘ though they have failed to suggest a business model that would offer it as cheaply as many city schemes. Indeed, allowing users to piggyback off other people’s cellphones – in the same way that companies like Intel envisage happening with spontaneous Wi-Fi meshes between laptops ‘ would throw up a range of dilemmas in terms of billing and customer ownership. All the same, the cellcos know that the mesh and Wi-Fi phenomena have already undermined their traditional models and they will need to rethink these anyway ‘ and so a cellular mesh option using standard handsets rather than expensive proprietary gear could help them stand their ground in some important markets.

As well as spontaneous mesh, another hot area where 3G has significant weaknesses is indoor coverage, increasingly important as providers look to converge their services over fixed lines to the home as well as mobile links. The debate rages over whether it is practical to use wireless links, whether HSDPA or WiMAX, for both fixed and mobile broadband, but in the former case, indoor penetration certainly needs to improve to get round the natural limitations of the spectrum and power regulations. Clariton Networks of Israel is one example of a host of companies looking to address this need and to allow cellular networks to integrate more neatly with wireline infrastructure such as cable.

Clariton has developed bypass infrastructure to penetrate the home using existing CATV cable systems, passing native RF signals wirelessly indoors, but then passing them over the CATV network device to the base station to avoid problems of signal loss when going through walls. Such technologies could be important to the cablecos as they ramp up efforts to add in-home and mobile wireless platforms to their bundles of services. The transmission is done in the 900-1200MHz range, currently unused by the CATV system, and so does not affect existing CATV services. Existing coaxial amplifiers in the CATV system, the only element in the network that does not currently handle these frequencies, are bypassed with Clariton bypass filters and amplifiers.

Finally, one of the most expensive elements for cellular operator, in introducing new technologies to enhance their 3G services, is additional investment in cell sites. Shoehorning a network such as WiMAX into an existing pattern of towers may lead to severe compromises in performance since the network planning issues are very different. There are many efforts to make coexistence more viable without degrading the performance of the combined network, including moves by major vendors such as Nokia and Siemens to create flexible base stations. From the start-up community, TenXc is claiming its own breakthrough, with cell site enhancement products aimed at allowing new advanced applications to be supported without new towers or roofs.

The Canadian company’s PCS Bi-Sector Array device promises a ‘drop and insert’ approach to network expansion and the vendor is particularly targeting operators looking to add WiMAX to an existing structure. Like companies such as Arraycomm, it is refining smart antenna techniques to increase spectral efficiency, indoor penetration and frequency reuse, and is focused in particular on what it calls the ‘last and most promising performance frontier’, the spatial wireless channel. Its spatial processing advances are incorporated into its Intelligent RF technology, which uses key smart antenna techniques – adaptive beamforming, arrays and multi-dimensional signal processing – to reduce interference and optimize the wireless signal link between base stations and devices.
In addition, its system is designed to counteract the sacrifices in performance and quality that are typically experienced when using more than three sectors ‘ until recently the conventional number in a cellular base station ‘ and implementing six or even more for greater capacity. Signals are split into parallel streams, with a number of virtual antennae created to provide a claimed 70-80% performance improvement over off-the-shelf solutions. TenXc is a member of the WiMAX Forum and sees its techniques as being highly suitable to 802.16 as well as 3G, or to combinations of the two.
The impact of the smart antennas on deriving more capacity and reach from existing sites and allowing more flexible planning could equate to cost savings of $250,000 per site, claims TenXc. Product trials begin in the US, with unnamed partners, in the second quarter.