Indian operators are racing to restructure their businesses and grab new spectrum, as they face declining 2G subscriber bases and a shortage of capacity. India has recently bucked the global trend for mobile subscriber growth, partly because of changes in ways of reporting inactive users, but the figures also highlight a crisis for cellcos, many of which lack adequate spectrum to meet mobile demands, as well as sufficient cash to invest in higher value services.
This situation is likely to spark a wave of consolidation. This is ongoing as operators struggle with low ARPUs and look for economies of scale and, in many cases, investment from foreign players. The latest deal looks likely to be between Indian cellco Tata Teleservices, part of the giant Tata industrial group, and Telenor of Norway.
Telenor recently withdrew from its Uninor joint venture in India in the wake of the scandal over cancelled GSM licences, and formed a new venture, Telewings, in order to bid for the re-auctioned spectrum and boost its activities in the subcontinent. This is now reported to be in talks about a merger with the Tata unit.
This would form the fourth largest cellco in India, after Bharti Airtel, Vodafone and Reliance Communications, giving the partners greater ability to compete and a stronger position in spectrum, coverage and capacity. It would also give Uninor access to the 3G market, where much of India’s growth and margin improvements are seen ‘ its 2G subscriber base, by contrast, has the lowest ARPUs in the world and was even seen declining in the last quarter amid capacity constraints, changes in reporting of active subscribers, and quality of service concerns.
Expansion is essential for Telenor in India, whose ventures showed sharp decline in the last quarter. According to figures from the operators’ association, the COIA, India ended the third quarter with 671.91m GSM subscribers, having lost 8.3m net customers in August and September combined. Bharti Airtel added 0.49m customers, taking its customer base to 186.41m, or market share of 27.7%. Vodafone and Idea also added some customers, but Uninor and Videocon showed the sharpest drop in their customer bases, losing 1.1m and 60,000 customers respectively.
According to Bloomberg sources, Japan’s NTT Docomo would also remain a shareholder in the combined entity, if agreement is reached. It currently holds a 26% stake in Tata Teleservices, which it acquired in 2009 for $2.4bn. A combined operator would have about 120m mobile subscribers.
However, the sources say that the merger may founder, if new rules on telecoms ownership –
due to be decided by the Indian cabinet soon ‘ are unfavourable. Particularly, the deal could fail if those new rules require a merged company to return start-up spectrum to the government, which would cost the recently reallocated 1.8GHz 2G licences. Telewings was the biggest spender in that recent sale.
The government does want to ease M&A restrictions to encourage inward investment in the telecoms sector and to encourage consolidation, which would make the market more viable for operators and so boost the commitment to new services and networks.
Meanwhile, the cellcos are looking for significant cost savings elsewhere, and selling off towers is a popular option, currently being pursued by Bharti Airtel and state-owned BSNL. Bharti is widely reported to be planning to sell off some of its tower networks via a stock market listing by the end of this year. The company first announced plans to sell a stake in the company in September, but did not offer any timescales. The IPO could raise between US$800m and $900m if it sells 10% of the Bharti Infratel unit.
The proposed listing would include a fresh issue of equity shares by Bharti Infratel and an offer to sell some shares by current investors Compassvale Investments, GS Strategic Investments, Anadale and Nomura Asia Investment. Bharti itself will not buy shares when they are listed, thus diluting its stake in the firm. Infratel owns around 30,000 towers and is also a 42% shareholder in another towers joint venture, Indus Tower – with Vodafone and Idea Cellular.
BSNL is taking a different tack, and aims to spin off a separate tower company to manage its cell sites, the Hindustan Times reports. The scheme will see BSNL lease access to its 70,000 towers to rival service providers, which chairman Rakesh Kumar Upadhyay claimed could generate up to INR16bn ($289.94m) within five years for the debt-laden operator. BSNL expects to have chosen an advisor by the end of December. Upadhyay added in the interview that the tower leasing plans were just part of a wider set of proposals to ‘bring the company back on the right track’.For example, we have streamlined the procurement process, improved our billing system and have started enterprise resource planning. All these steps will give results in the next financial year’.
Another urgent priority for Indian cellcos is to gain more spectrum to boost capacity and new services. The large players have their sights set on possible digital dividend auctions next year to support a move to FD-LTE (currently only the TDD spectrum has been sold off). They also want more 2G capacity. The 1.8GHz GSM licences – famously cancelled by the Department of Telecom after scandals about the earlier auction ‘ were re-auctioned this month, but the CDMA licences went unsold when no bidders emerged.
Now Bharti Airtel, Vodafone and Idea Cellular want regulatory TRAI to allow this 800MHz spectrum to be refarmed for GSM, which has better roaming and device economics for a country where costs have to be minimized to cope with ultra-low ARPUs, and where GSM is the main platform for national coverage. The three cellcos have sent a joint letter to the DoT, saying: “We recommend that the 800MHz spectrum band is harmonized with the international band plan to become part of an ‘extended’ 900MHz band; this will increase the availability of spectrum in the 900MHz band by up to 10MHz (or over 40%).’
The CDMA operators all refused to participate in the recent auction, citing the high reserve price, which was 1.3 times higher than the price for the 1.8GHz licences ‘ whose own minimum cost was already criticized for being too high for this price sensitive market. TRAI has said it will try again to auction the CDMA franchises, perhaps with lower prices, but the three cellcos argue: “With the diminishing interest of operators in CDMA and the reducing subscriber base of the technology, we believe that we need to harmonize and reconfigure the existing Indian CDMA band in line with the global practice.’
However, TRAI has refused to sell the remaining 2G frequencies this fiscal year (to March). The regulator says that, under current legislation, it cannot revise its recommendations on spectrum pricing to make the licences more attractive. The law gives the government just one veto over TRAI pricing recommendations, which it already used to reject the agency’s first proposal on reserve prices. The only way to get round this obstacle is to begin the whole consultation process again, which would take at least four months.