Siemens has hardly hidden its willingness to offload its lossmaking Com network infrastructure division, so in the wake of Alcatel’s agreement to merge with Lucent, it was inevitable that attention would quickly turn to the German company. First in the frame to take on the unit is Motorola, though the deal would be complicated unless the US company decides to increase its focus on wireline networks; while Nortel would be a better fit. Nokia and a private equity bid are also in the picture as possible bidders.
Consolidation of the infrastructure market seems highly likely, with Alcatel setting the pace in a sector that will depend on broad product range and economies of scale to offset commoditization, increased operator pressure to reduce spending plans, and the looming competition from China. Of course, a Chinese company ‘ most likely Huawei ‘ could be a candidate for Siemens anyway. Several of the large network vendors, notably Alcatel and Siemens itself, have already offloaded their handset units to Chinese or Taiwanese players, and Huawei was known to be interested in bidding for Marconi last year, despite being trumped by Ericsson.
Ericsson itself might have seemed a logical contender for Siemens Com, since it is keen to build up its abilities in wireline/wireless convergence and reduce its dependence on 3G alone, but it has stated that it believes it is strong enough to compete in the new-look market on its own strengths.
The flaw in a possible Motorola plan is that the US company is less interested than most of its rivals in wireline infrastructure and is heavily focused on building up its offering across multiple wireless platforms, particularly Wi-Fi and WiMAX. This is a strategy that in itself might need a rethink, as operators become increasingly interested in converging wireline and wireless systems, but for now Motorola would be unlikely to want to keep the whole of the Siemens Com unit. Nor is it probable that the German giant will be keen to sell off the most profitable element of the company, the wireless operations, on its own, leaving it saddled with a far less saleable set of wireline products.
Not that the wireline operations are without their attractions, but a new owner would have to be prepared to take on a significant financial turnaround job, one Siemens itself has struggled with. This would be the main case against another rumored candidate, Nortel, whose new CEO Mike Zafirowski has enough turnaround challenges of his own without taking on a difficult merger. The product line would dovetail more neatly with Nortel’s than Motorola’s, however, although it looks less attractive in the wake of the Canadian company’s extensive alliance with Huawei, which has filled in several gaps in its convergence product line.
A Nortel-Siemens combination would be strategically sound, since the combined entity would be in the number one or two position in several growth markets ‘ enterprise telephony, next generation voice, optical switching and wireless infrastructure ‘ creating a real challenge to Lucent-Alcatel. It would certainly strengthen the resolution, announced by Zafirowski earlier this month, that Nortel would stay only in markets where it could achieve 20% share or more. Indeed, in optical equipment, Nortel-Siemens would overtake long-time leader Alcatel. Siemens is particularly strong in the next generation voice trunk media gateway sector and in softswitches (number two in both) and would give Nortel a story in DSL customer premises equipment, an area where it currently relies on Huawei and which it needs to boost as it enhances its lacklustre broadband strategy.
Off paper, however, there would be a difficult cultural alignment to achieve, with all the complexities that will beset the Lucent-Alcatel merger ‘ such as contrasting American and European employment law, when it comes to cutting staff ‘ but with more serious financial problems. Siemens, though its portfolio and market shares are well balanced and fairly strong across the convergence board, has struggled to make profits in this business, while Nortel is emerging painfully from years of financial scandals, losses and accounting mis-statements.
Indeed, if it were not for Siemens’ apparent medium term move away from telecoms altogether, it would make more sense for the Germany company to acquire Nortel in order to build up and rejuvenate Com. Analysts estimate Nortel could be bought for about $12.8bn, which would not be impossible for Siemens, which has almost $10bn in cash.
Klaus Kleinfeld, Siemens’ CEO ‘ like those of Motorola, Nokia and Nortel, still fairly new in the job and committed to a radical turnaround ‘ certainly sees this as a good time to sell underperforming divisions. He has already offloaded the handsets to Taiwan’s BenQ, sold Siemens’ holdings in chipmaker Infineon and network vendor Juniper, and last month conducted a major overhaul of senior management, in which the CFO was the most prominent casualty. Kleinfeld has committed to meet ambitious profit targets for all 11 Siemens divisions by April 2007 and Com will be one of the hardest to revive.
Com is the largest unit of Siemens and has sales of around $16bn and 55,000 staff. However, it contains several lossmaking units and its overall operating profit fell 13% in its last reported quarter, the first quarter of fiscal 2006, which ended on December 31. Without the sale of its stake in networking vendor Juniper, Com would have made a loss of €43m on sales of €3.42bn (up 10% year-on-year) in the quarter. The unit falls far short of Kleinfeld’s performance targets for the various Siemens divisions, which include a target margin of 8-10% by 2007.
If Motorola offers a sufficiently attractive price for the mobile operations, Kleinfeld may reluctantly be willing to undertake the difficult task of breaking up Com and selling it off in parts ‘ which will be made even more difficult by the fact that most employees have generous redundancy contracts. He has already reportedly been in talks with Nokia about certain product lines, although a Nokia bid for the whole of Com would signal a huge change in the Finnish giant’s thinking ‘ moving from a strategy that is entirely mobile, and in which infrastructure plays a fairly minor role, to a full convergence play.
Siemens, medium term, is likely to withdraw from electronics and telecoms, which it sees as being too cyclical, and focus on steadier revenue streams such as power stations and healthcare technology. This means that a sale of Com, rather than a merger or other strategy to build it up, will be preferable to Kleinfeld, and less of a distraction from reviving the core businesses. However, the German company faces the problem that the companies in the best financial and structural position to acquire Com are those least interested in taking it over as a single unit, while the best strategic fit, Nortel, would be taking a risk that would surely be unacceptable to still nervous shareholders in shouldering such a burdensome merger effort while its own fortunes remain in flux.