Microsoft has scored an important victory in its long-running patents battle with Motorola Mobility, which has gained additional prominence since the handset maker was acquired by Microsoft arch-rival Google.
US District Court Judge James Robart has ruled that Motorola cannot gain an outright ban on the sale of Microsoft products even if they violate its H.264 patents, because these are essential to the compression standard. The ruling saves Windows and Xbox products from potential sales injunctions in the US and also blocks Motorola from seeking bans in Germany.
The licensing norms for standards-essential patents are at the heart of several of the current wave of mobile IPR lawsuits, and new precedents may emerge from the rulings. Many judges are taking the line that firms with essential IPR have the right to seek licensing fees, but only under Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) guidelines, and to sue non-payers; but not to block sales of rivals’ products, which could amount to abuse of their unavoidable patents.
Motorola has argued in various countries that Microsoft has used its H.264 technology illegally and should have its products banned until it agrees a fair licensing deal. Microsoft counters that it is willing to pay royalties, but Motorola has been demanding excessive fees which violate Frand principles. Motorola has asked for 2.25% of product price, which would amount to about $4bn, and Microsoft says that is too high.
Judge Robarts’ ruling is only preliminary at this stage and a final decision is not due until the spring. However, he is unlikely to change his mind about the basic judgement, but is likely to add more detail on licensing terms and reasonable royalty levels.
Motorola previously won an infringement case against Microsoft in Germany and sought an injunction. However, that ruling was postponed and made subject to Robarts’ decision in the similar US case.
Also on the patents front, Ericsson has stepped up its new legal actions against Samsung, asking the US International Trade Commission to ban imports of the Korean firm’s products should they be found to infringe its IPR. This comes a week after the Swedish firm filed suit in a federal court in Texas accusing Samsung of infringing a number of patents, after talks to renew a licensing deal broke down after two years of negotiations.
‘We anticipate that the ITC will resolve our patent infringement claims in our favor,” Ericsson said in a statement, adding that it hopes that this latest action will prompt Samsung to sign a cross-licensing deal. Ericsson has no interest in barring Samsung’s products, but has pledged to chase revenues from its vast patent portfolio more aggressively.
According to last week’s court filings, Ericsson claims that Samsung is seeking to reduce the fee it pays to license standard-essential patents dramatically. Samsung, which is in a stronger position in wireless IPR than it was during the 3G era, argues that the Swedish giant’s fees are too high, but its antagonist says it cannot give one licensee a better deal than competitors which have already signed licensing deals.
Meanwhile, Judge Lucy Koh, who presided over Samsung’s landmark $1bn patent trial defeat at Apple’s hands, has ruled that Apple’s licensing deal with HTC must be made public. Only the pricing and royalty terms of the agreement can be sealed, she ruled, not the identify of the patents or other details. “There are compelling reasons to seal pricing and royalty terms, as they may place the parties to the agreement at a disadvantage in future negotiations, but there is nothing in the remainder of the agreement that presents a sufficient risk of competitive harm to justify keeping it from the public,” Judge Koh explained in her order.
The court has also required HTC to produce an unredacted copy of the agreement, which Samsung has argued is relevant to its fights with Apple, since it almost certainly covers some of the same patents. This will be viewed only by attorneys in the case. The Korean firm argues that Apple’s willingness to license patents to HTC may undermine its claim of irreparable harm in the Samsung case ‘ Apple has used this plea to seek product bans as well as just royalties. Apple’s motion for a permanent injunction on some Samsung smartphones comes up for hearing on Thursday. Both parties have added further devices to their tit-for-tat suits in San Jose, some of which will wait over a year to be heard if no settlement is reached in the meantime, and Samsung is appealing the original $1bn jury verdict.