Motorola has outlined plans to focus WiMAX efforts on Asia-Pacific, but some operators from the region are lukewarm about the prospects for wireless broadband.
Speaking at the Wireless Broadband conference in Singapore last week, several operators complained that the technologies are not yet ready for prime time and are still too expensive to be competitive against DSL or cellular options.
From India’s Bharti Televentures, CTO Jagbir Singh said that wireless broadband had to meet the price points of DSL if it were to become a truly competitive platform.
“Current CPE prices are in the range of $150 to $300 and CPE with advanced features is even more expensive,” Singh said. “How do I compete when an ADSL modem is just $20?” Singh said that the business market was the only viable target for wireless broadband at present, and that the platform needed to offer voice to become genuinely attractive. “Data only is a very tough business case,” he warned.
The managing director of Pacific Internet, Kevin Lim, said his firm had trialled wireless in Singapore but found that it was technically difficult to deploy.
Head of technology and development for Maxis Communications of Malaysia, Gregory Dayton, had also had mixed experiences, though his trials were based on UMTS TDD. The economics of wireless broadband limit its potential against DSL, he argued, especially as it is not financially viable to deliver television, and since Telekom Malaysia is now selling DSL for $11 a month.
“One minute of TV is 22,500Kbps and programs are of over one hour durations,” Dayton said. “The cost of the depreciation on your towers wouldn’t be covered by the revenues.”
At the same event, Motorola said it was launching initiatives to raise awareness of mobile WiMAX among operators and users in Asia Pacific. Motorola will target its forthcoming MotoWi4 WiMAX platform at operators in mature markets such as Singapore and Australia as a cost effective last mile connection and at extensions to Wi-Fi metrozones.
It will also focus on operators in emerging markets such as India, Bangladesh and Vietnam to broaden network coverage and deliver services such as distance learning, video on demand and real time medical support.