Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2007

Motorola proposes more transparent approach to WiMAX IPR

One thing that the various legal actions surrounding Qualcomm have highlighted is that the wireless industry needs a new intellectual property system. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the arguments against the CDMA giant, new standards certainly suffer from ill-defined IPR policies and the threat of patent hoarders appearing out of the woodwork at a post-standard phase, to skew the economics of the platform with unexpected and high charges, or disruptive lawsuits. The WiMAX community has been particularly sensitive to this, as an important aspect of 802.16e’s claims for operator favor rest on promises of a more transparent IPR structure and a low cost handset that, because of a small royalties burden compared to 3G, would need little or no subsidy. Fears remain that this dream will prove unachievable and now Motorola, the vendor with arguably the greatest investment in WiMAX’ success, is proposing a new approach that could restore confidence in the process.

Jon Meyer, the company’s senior vice president for intellectual property law, hopes to set a precedent for other suppliers by submitting patents the company believes it holds for WiMAX to an independent third party for critical review. Meyer said the aim is to offer WiMAX stakeholders full disclosure of the types of patents that Motorola holds and how essential they are to the standard, with making formal declarations to the IEEE standards body. If all IPR holders did the same, a clear picture would emerge of the essential patents and their owners, and so players could make a realistic assessment of likely royalties and avoid nasty surprises later on.

The system proposed by Motorola, which echoes that used successfully in some other standards such as MPEG video coding, is clearly aimed to aim yet another indirect missile at Qualcomm. The CDMA giant has hinted heavily that it holds significant essential IPR in OFDMA and specifically in 802.16e, but has not detailed those patents before a public body. This has created uncertainty and fear that the company – which, unlike most claimed WiMAX patent holders, is not part of the WiMAX Forum and therefore not subject to its codes of practise on licensing – will suddenly spring large royalty claims on WiMAX vendors once their products appear. Qualcomm has signed OFDMA-related licensing agreements with several small players, such as SOMA Networks, so far, but has not taken on any of the majors, which are keen to downplay the likely importance of the chipmaker’s patents. However, through its own extensive R&D program in this area, plus its acquisitions of Flarion and Airgo, it has certainly built up an arsenal of technology related to OFDM and MIMO, the key cornerstones of 802.16e.

The Forum has conducted analysis of the IPR position in 802.16e and claims that no vendor has a dominant position. There are reported to b over 1,500 patent holders, with the largest player being Samsung, which has about 25% of the patents deemed essential (but is fully signed up to Forum guidelines, that licensing should be on a ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory basis). So far, the Korean giant has shown no signs of trying to exploit its IPR position further. Qualcomm’s own licensing terms are different from those of the rest of the industry’s as they include all their technologies in one blanket license, so the cost burden is greatest, in WiMAX, on non-CDMA licensees.

Meyer admitted Motorola’s approach would significantly change the way IPR works in wireless, and could disadvantage some of the major players that use their patent stocks to great advantage when negotiating the bilateral trade-off agreements that are a key feature of the mobile sector. “This is new and different, and we’ve never done it before,” said Meyer, telling reporters it was like showing one’s hand in advance in a poker game. “We debated whether it was a good thing, and we came down on the side of improved transparency. There is fear, uncertainty and doubt surrounding IP.”

Other giants are seeing the benefits of openness, despite the potential loss of bargaining power. Nokia, one of the largest patent holders in wireless, gains a cost advantage of perhaps 30% in its handsets, over companies with no significant patents, by being able to trade IPR rights. But it has recognized that, with the growth in the handset and infrastructure market coming from developing economies, a new cost base is required, and high royalties will work against low priced devices and high volume growth. Nokia and others are proposing a cap on handset royalties at around 5% of device price, something Qualcomm opposes.

Motorola said it already has support from several WiMAX stakeholders, which are prepared to submit their patents to the same as-yet unnamed third party. Not that scrutiny of the patents necessarily leads to lower rates, but at least it takes away the element of surprise and uncertainty. The next step would be to move away from the bilateral talks approach and start to introduce centralized patent pools, as happens in some consumer electronics standards. After that, we might even see some vendors contributing their patents for free, or under an open source process, as is becoming a major feature of mobile software. As in the enterprise world, this will only happen if the benefits of rapid technology growth and uptake – as stimulated by open source – outweigh the revenues from royalties. Motorola and Intel, with their high dependence on rapid adoption of WiMAX, are already close to that point. Chipmakers that play across different technologies and have heavy investment in unique design will see less reason to open up the system – and for companies like Qualcomm and Ericsson, which would like to slow down the uptake of WiMAX, there is every reason to cling to the old IPR ways when it comes to 802.16e.

Standards bodies:

The standards bodies are also trying to reform their approaches to IPR. The IEEE announced a significant change to its patent policy earlier this year, one that has been unpopular with some members. From April 30, the organization is promoting advance disclosure of ambiguous or restrictive licensing caveats associated with patents that might be included in its standards.

In particular, the voluntary policy permits and encourages the optional and unilateral disclosure of royalty rates and other licensing terms before a patented technology is included in the standard. The disclosed terms may include, for instance, the maximum royalty rate that the patent holder will look to charge – but announcing that in advance clearly removes competitive advantage from companies as they go into licensing negotiations.

The European body ETSI led the way on reform last year, under pressure from large operators like Vodafone to help reduce handset costs and subsidies. ETSI is making significant changes to its policy and procedures regarding declaration of IPR claims. It wants to insist that any such claims are made in advance of a standard being finalized, to avoid patent holders emerging from the woodwork once a market is established and demanding high fees once vendors are over a barrel. It is also introducing safeguards that will enable IPR holders voluntarily to declare the terms and conditions attached to their IPR ahead of the standardization of a new technology.

ETSI has also declared that it will no longer be mandatory for the organization to select technologies purely on the basis of their technical merits and regardless of other considerations, a more realistic approach that needs to be emulated by the IEEE, which is still living with the fiction that its workgroup decisions are not influenced by commercial and political agendas. To back up its new stance, ETSI has created a permanent IPR Committee that will meet when significant IPR-related issues arise.

ETSI’s changes were spurred last year when a group of operators led by Vodafone, T-Mobile, Orange and KPN threatened to hold patent holders to ransom by delaying finalization of standards until the IPR issues were solved. They claimed that, if suppliers did not sign up to the proposed agreement, they would lobby to exclude their patents from the standard.

The cellco trade body, the GSM Association (GSMA), recently urged the wireless industry to increase the transparency around intellectual property rights related to new technology standards. It suggested other standards bodies should follow the lead of ETSI.

The issue came to a head as standards bodies started looking at the intellectual property licensing costs likely to relate to LTE. ETSI suggested capping the IP rights for this emerging technology to 3-5% of the cost of all LTE gear.

Alex Sinclair, chief technology officer of the GSMA, said: “As the underlying technologies in mobile telecommunications become more intricate, there is a danger that excessive cumulative license fees for the use of intellectual property will slow, or even prevent, the adoption of new technologies within the worldwide mobile operator community. The changes announced by ETSI will reduce that danger. Other standards bodies should consider taking similar steps to create a less unpredictable commercial environment around new standards.”