Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 March 2019

MWC19: 5G faces multiyear hiatus before its three key enablers are ready

This year’s Mobile World Congress was a serious reality check. Operators and vendors alike cast aside a lot of the hype and over-optimism of the pre-commercial days and acknowledged that ‘true 5G’ would be really hard. The first wave of 5G – deployed with the 4G, mainly non-virtualized core and the integrated RAN – makes very little difference except to operators’ PR and governments’ self-satisfaction. This is especially true of the 90% of countries where millimeter wave spectrum is not yet available for 5G.

This is not to belittle the transformative potential of 5G. It is just not ready yet in any real sense. A faster, more efficient mobile broadband radio is fine, but does not enable brand new business models or user experiences or cost economics. Those will come when the 5G platform achieves its three key goals – full automation, full virtualization throughout the network, and a cloud-native core supporting the full service-based architecture (SBA).

Other gaps need to be filled too – shared spectrum support, improved security, low latency (though ultra-low latency, for so long 5G’s calling card, really is a red herring, with only a few specialized use cases really needing it). But the big three are what will transform the operator business case, the customer experience and the overall value chain, and none of them will be fully ready for several years.

Even when vRAN and cloud-native core platforms are fully tested for large-scale commercial usage, established operators need to make other strategic and difficult decisions – to integrate inhouse or turn to an IT services partner; to manage inhouse or put everything into a managed service provider’s cloud; to focus on scaling up a smart pipe with highly efficient costs, or to try to be a digital service provider and generate new revenues?

This is why there was so much buzz about Rakuten – not just a greenfield MNO, with no legacy networks to transition, but a cloud provider. Why wouldn’t such a company put its whole network in the cloud? For most of its old-style counterparts, this will focus the mind on how to respond should other cloud companies stretch out into the network itself – AWS, Alibaba, Microsoft? They are starting to form strategic alliances with these cloud providers, perhaps to forestall them in any ambitions to become operators (see separate item).

For now, they need to work out their next steps for vRAN, 5G core and the cloud, including the edge cloud. Unsurprisingly, then, these three platforms were front and center at MWC, among traditional OEMs, IT and cloud suppliers (sensing a chance to get deeper into the mobile network market), and challengers like Altiostar, Mavenir, Affirmed and JMA Wireless.

Most vendors agree they are on a journey from first generation virtualization based on virtual machines, to a C-N architecture with software decomposed into microservices and containerized. As well as the efficiency and flexibility of the latter architecture, it has also seen a shift from just adapting existing core network functions to run as VMs, to designing entirely new, Lego-like software modules specifically to leverage a cloud environment.

This brings many benefits in terms of flexibility and agility for operators, but requires significant changes to culture, skills, customer relationships and even billing. A constant stream of software updates, rather than periodic big launches or upgrades, has deep implications for all those areas.

And virtualizing the RAN is even more complex, with key decisions to be made about the correct split between central virtualized functions and physical cell site functions. Neville Ray, CTO of T-Mobile USA, was open about the challenges of vRAN, as he spoke at MWC in his capacity as chair of the 5G Americas trade association.

“The radio world was complex, and now when you think about new radio technologies like massive beamforming and millimeter wave, there’s massive intelligence in the radio environment,” he said. “It drives challenges into that disaggregation.” The more complex the baseband has become, the more difficult virtualization is – one reason why the optimism about Cloud-RAN of a few years ago has largely dissipated. It would have been easier to disaggregate the RAN at that earlier stage, he said, when functionality was simpler, even though that might, in turn, have held back some of the subsequent advances in the radio network.

If virtualization does not go hand-in-hand will full automation, many of its efficiency and flexibility benefits will be compromised and it will be hard for operators to pursue other 5G corollaries like greater density and network slicing. Automation must, of course, be intelligent – if operators are going to automate the provisioning and verification of a dynamic slice to meet a demanding service level agreement, the technology investment to achieve that will be significant. There is a big opportunity for the optimization and assurance companies to expand their addressable market, aided by new tools like network AI (artificial intelligence).

But operators will have to change theirinternal processes too, as Sanjay Goel president of Nokia Global Services, told Total Telecom. This is yet another area where, for the majority of MNOs, the necessary change of approach and mindset may take several years to accomplish.

Goel said: “Extreme automation is the biggest underlying differentiator for the future. My belief is that the way we deliver service deliveries today and service capabilities build out will have to radically change to address cost, quality and agility. That’s where we are creating a digital architecture.”

He added: “For operators, the biggest cost in EBIDTA will be building of networks for 5G. If you have the same cost structure as today, you will not get it out the door. Our ambition is to radically cut the cost of deployment through automation. It’s about lowering the cost of the field in terms of the number of site visits that are required. Can we build out a radio site in one physical visit? That is our ambition and our desire because today it takes multiple site visits to get a radio base station up.”