The speed of change in the mobile industry can make fools of anyone, nobody more so than former Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer, with his determination to turn the firm into a ‘devices and services’ company like Apple, just as the real money was moving to the cloud. That has left his successor, Satya Nadella, with a handset arm, acquired from Nokia, that never looked like a good fit for Microsoft’s model, and is now rapidly becoming a white elephant. The new CEO issued a manifesto for his company’s future, disguised as a communiqu’ to employees, which clearly illustrated a shift away from devices, and followed it with a plan to axe 18,000 workers, 12,500 from the former Nokia business. The key reasons are to make Microsoft more streamlined and agile, and to ‘align’ Nokia with the rest of the company, but the balance of the job losses suffered by the newly acquired handset division highlights the radical change of emphasis, away from devices, under Nadella’s regime.
Nadella, who had taken the reins less than three months before that, never looked enthusiastic about the Nokia purchase he had inherited, and his initial statements put the focus heavily on ‘cloud first, mobility first’ ‘ by which he clearly meant mobility in the sense of delivering software and services across mobile networks and to a wide range of devices, not making the gadgets themselves. Not that he is suggesting axing hardware like Surface or Xbox, but we can expect a slowdown in any new moves to expand the mobile range, as borne out by the layoffs.
His 3,000-word email to employees makes his new direction even clearer, and places the cloud platform Azure ‘ which Nadella formerly headed up ‘ at the heart of the company, replacing Office and, eventually, Windows itself, the move which has become increasingly inevitable in the world of open OSs and cloud services, but which Ballmer could never bring himself to contemplate. In a pointed strike at his forerunner, Nadella writes: ‘While the devices and services description was helpful in starting our transformation, we now need to hone in on our unique strategy.’
Nadella wants Microsoft to become the ‘productivity and platform company for the mobile-first and cloud-first world’, he writes ‘ and by productivity, he looks ‘beyond solely producing something to include empowering people with new insights’. He argues that people are ‘swimming in a growing sea of devices, apps, data and social networks’ and need applications and gadgets that can make sense of that, for instance by dividing work and personal data intelligently.
Given the tone of Nadella’s document, it was clear that, had he been CEO a year earlier, he would not have made the Nokia acquisition and would have pushed more quickly away from devices, and even client-side Windows, and towards universal cloud and mobile services. So it came as no surprise that, as Microsoft confirmed one of the biggest programs of layoffs in its history, the former Nokia division was the chief casualty.
Microsoft may be increasingly multiplatform with its cloud applications and mobile enterprise tools, but it still wants to offer an end-to-end, Windows-based solution for the still substantial base of enterprises which trust that approach. Nadella may know that ‘Windows everywhere’ is no longer a viable strategy, but that doesn’t mean Microsoft will not still push its own OS as a superior option, enhancing it and reducing its licensing fees. So the mobile devices strategy, after flirting with Android, will now be refocused entirely on Windows Phone. Here, Microsoft will pursue a ‘bottom-up’ approach, seeking to make WP8 a serious competitor to Android on low end devices and attract OEMs in that space.
That will involve the axing of the Nokia X Android line, despite recent upgrades to it post-acquisition, and also Nokia’s elderly Series 40 platform, which gained its second wind in the past couple of years by powering the Asha range of ‘smart featurephones’. The shift to Windows Phone-only does remove confusion for OEMs, and sees Microsoft doing what it should have done all along ‘ optimizing its smartphone OS for the segments where there is still significant growth; where many emerging market operators are less wedded to a particular platform than their western counterparts; and where the Nokia brand and installed base remained strong. Instead, it went head-to-head with Apple and only latterly squeezed Windows Phone into smaller, less resource-hungry form factors, leaving Nokia to major on Asha rather than WP, to retain its users in key markets like India.
It is almost certainly too late for Microsoft to gain mass market share for Windows Phone, despite its attractions and differentiated experience, at this stage, and a bolder Nadella might just have killed it ‘ as surely he will one day. After all, if he was serious about being a high volume smartphone maker, he would have stuck with Android and Nokia X. So soon after the acquisition of Nokia, however, it would have angered shareholders to make a complete U-turn, effectively telling them Microsoft had wasted its money. So, like Google with Motorola, Microsoft will hang on for now and seek to extract the jewels from its purchase, such as R&D inputs to Xbox and Surface, its more important hardware activities.
And Android activity will not be dead of course ‘ Microsoft is increasingly releasing business and consumer productivity apps, and web services, for Android and iOS ahead of its own operating systems.
The change of emphasis in devices will cost 12,500 former Nokia employees their jobs, in a total cull of 18,000 staff (14% of the workforce) across Microsoft, designed to meet Nadella’s objectives of streamlining and reducing time to market. Nomura analysts also expect the firm to take a charge of at least $1bn ‘to mitigate the risk of the Nokia acquisition’ ‘ finalized, of course, less than three months ago.
A memo from Stephen Elop, former Nokia CEO and now head of a much-reduced Microsoft devices kingdom, said that the cellphone unit will now target two markets ‘ ‘future high end Lumia products’ and ‘more affordable devices’. R&D for both lines will be driven out of Finland, from the former Nokia centers in Salo and Tampere.
The high end products – which presumably will, one day, converge with, or replace, Windows RT ‘ will be delivered ‘in alignment with major milestones ahead from both the Windows team and the Applications and Services Group’, which likely means a new version of WP and Office early next year.
At the low end, handset design will focus on ‘driving Lumia volume in the areas where we are already successful today in order to make the market for Windows Phone’, which suggests a concentration of the pared-down resources on Nokia’s traditional strongholds such as India, but also on South America via Brazil. Microsoft has new manufacturing hubs in Vietnam and Brazil but will reduce engineering in Beijing and San Diego, though both sites will continue to have ‘supporting roles’, the Chinese team in developing affordable devices in Beijing and the California group in specific US requirements. Two more Nokia centers in Finland, Espoo and Lund, will still operate and will focus on application development, Elop said. Microsoft will shut down the Nokia plant in Hungary, which employs about 1,800 people.
Although it seems probable that the high end devices efforts will eventually migrate into the tablets and Xbox family, and the main push will be in low end Lumia handsets, Microsoft will end the Nokia distinction between ‘Smart Devices’ and ‘Mobile Phones’ and will have a single cellphone business led by Jo Harlow. Elop said her team would be responsible for all the Lumia products; the transition of the Nokia X roadmap items to Lumia/WP; and the ongoing operation of the own-brand phone business. For now, Microsoft says the reorganization will have little impact on other devices such as Surface and Xbox, but we may expect changes to that in future.
However, under all this vision there are plenty of old Microsoft favorites being dusted off for the new era. We might have hoped Nadella would be bold enough to turn his back on hardware altogether, given the limited success of Surface and the conflicts with OEM partners. But he insists that Surface Pro 3 ‘is the world’s best productivity tablet’ and that ‘we will build first-party hardware to stimulate more demand for the entire Windows ecosystem’.
This is, however, a shift away from older Microsoft claims that it would take significant tablet and handset market share over time. Instead, like Google with Nexus, it is focusing on making new markets, stimulating interest and showing what can be done, and then stepping back for OEMs to ramp up the volume. So Nadella continues: ‘That means at times we’ll develop new categories like we did with Surface. It also means we will responsibly make the market for Windows Phone, which is our goal with the Nokia devices and services acquisition’ (well, it has apparently become the goal now, but that certainly wasn’t the objective stated by Ballmer when the acquisition was announced).
Nadella is treading the same fine line with Windows and Office – between moving the strategy cloudwards without throwing the baby out with the bathwater in established markets. So of course the firm will continue to upgrade the two key software platforms, which are important cash cows and drivers of other services. But it will also encourage businesses to move more of their activity into the cloud with Office 365 and Azure. Azure, combined with Windows Server, is now repositioned as the Microsoft Cloud OS.
And for consumers and business users, Nadella wants to stop talking about individual devices, or even about mobile, and to create ‘experiences’ which are common across all kinds of screens, gadgets and connections. ‘While today many people define mobile by devices, Microsoft defines it by experiences,’ he says. ‘We’re really in the infant stages of the mobile-first world. In the next few years we will see many more new categories evolve and experiences emerge that span a variety of devices of all screen sizes.’
As well as the new definition of ‘productivity tools’ he is promising, these experiences will include new user interfaces and web services driven by artificial intelligence, as seen in the Cortana riposte to Apple Siri, and in Delve, also singled out by Nadella. Delve
uses machine learning techniques to connect people to relevant Office 365 documents, as well as conversations and contacts, in an intelligent way ‘ and actually predates similar activities by Facebook and Google (so again, not really a brand new platform, but one that has been polished up for the new direction).
So the missive does not say anything radically new about Nadella’s strategy, but it makes it more concrete and should be quickly followed by more practical changes to help facilitate it. The CEO acknowledges that achieving his goals will need ‘fundamental cultural changes’, including management and organizational shake-up, which will prompt groans in many quarters, given what a short time has elapsed since Ballmer’s last big restructuring. That changed many key business units and managers in order to regroup around devices and services, and now Microsoft is set for another wave of change and uncertainty.
One of the critical aims of the latest shake-up will be to address criticisms, from the Microsoft board as well as many customers and partners, that development times are too slow for the rapidly changing needs of enterprises, consumers and the mobile world. ‘Every team across Microsoft must find ways to simplify and move faster, more efficiently,’ Nadella writes. ‘We will increase the fluidity of information and ideas by taking actions to flatten the organization and develop leaner business processes.’
He adds, with loud echoes of Google: ‘In order to deliver the experiences our customers need for the mobile-first and cloud-first world, we will modernize our engineering processes to be customer-obsessed, data-driven, speed-oriented and quality-focused. We will streamline the engineering process and reduce the amount of time and energy it takes to get things done.’