Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 April 2013

New antitrust complaint hurled at Google and Android

Rivals of Google have raised another European antitrust complaint based around the dominance of the Android operating system. This comes just as Google seems on the verge of reaching an agreement with the European Commission over how it must conduct its search business in the region.

The complaint comes from the same group of companies- calling itself FairSearch Europe ‘ which made the initial complaint over Google practices. It includes major Google rivals Microsoft and Oracle, as well as Microsoft’s key European ally Nokia. The complaints alleges that Google is using Android as a deceptive way to build advantages for its key applications.

FairSearch issued a press release on its web site saying it has filed the complaint with the European Commission. It talks about “Google’s anti-competitive strategy to dominate the mobile marketplace and cement its control over consumer internet data for online advertising as usage shifts to mobile.”

The release claims that Google’s Android is the dominant smartphone operating system, running in 70% of units shipped at the end of 2012, citing numbers from Strategy Analytics. Google also dominates mobile search advertising with 96% of the market, according to eMarketer. The complaint says Google uses deceptive conduct to lockout competition in mobile.

“Google is using its Android mobile operating system as a ‘Trojan Horse’ to deceive partners, monopolize the mobile marketplace, and control consumer data,” said Thomas Vinje, Brussels-based counsel to the FairSearch coalition. “We are asking the Commission to move quickly and decisively to protect competition and innovation in this critical market. Failure to act will only embolden Google to repeat its desktop abuses of dominance as consumers increasingly turn to a mobile platform dominated by Google’s Android operating system.”

FairSearch says it has 17 members with each one specialized in search or technology and these include Expedia, TripAdvisor, Kayak, Hotwire, Sidestep, Foundem, Twenga, Shop City, Ad Marketplace, Travel Tech Assoc, Buscape, The Find, Allegro and Level France.

The accusation is straightforward, suggesting that in order to get your hands on Android you have to include Google apps such as Maps, YouTube or Play and these must be pre-loaded or Google will not let you use Android. It is not clear how that marries with the Android-based platforms supported by companies like Amazon ‘ and more recently Facebook (see separate item) ‘ which exclude many of the key Google services. Amazon’s Kindle Fire OS has its own app store, maps and browser, for instance. The contracts that govern use of Android are mainly in the open domain or under the auspices of the OS’s supporters’ group, the Open Handset Alliance. Combined with the various de-Googled overlays available, these factors make the search giant, whatever its other hints at megalomania, look more open than its accusers when it comes to mobile platforms.

After all, it may seem rich for Microsoft to accuse its rival, via FairSearch, of “predatory distribution of Android at below-cost,” after its own run-ins with the EC over bundling Windows with free software like IE.

“European consumers deserve a rigorous investigation of Google’s mobile practices, and real protections against further abuses by Google,” said Vinje. “Given Google’s track record of ignoring the law, mobile Internet users should be very concerned.”