The mobile enterprise software market is an increasingly competitive one. IBM’s deal with Apple threw a major cat among the pigeons, but Microsoft and Samsung have been fighting back nobly, and the company which stood to lose most – BlackBerry – is showing the first signs of a successful transition to be a software-driven player.
Samsung has announced a partnership with Red Hat which is similar to the IBM/Apple alliance. The pair will build “enterprise-ready, industry specific” applications in areas like business intelligence, customer service and inventory management, which will run on the Linux giant’s newly unveiled mobile app platform. The software will run on Android and other operating systems and will be jointly marketed by the two companies, initially in the US.
Red Hat clearly benefits from association with the world’s largest smartphone maker, especially as Samsung has been building up its enterprise credentials with developments and acquisitions in key areas like security. For Samsung, the advantages are less clear – Red Hat is very new to the mobile space, but it associates the Korean vendor with a powerful name in business software.
Such alliances are piling the pressure on BlackBerry’s own efforts to reinvent itself around its existing strengths in mobile enterprise software platforms. And CEO John Chen will certainly not be putting the company up for sale at this point, just when he is seeing the first signs that his reinvention plan is working. His aim is to turn the ailing handset maker into an enterprise software vendor, not only stabilizing performance, but raising the value for any future acquirer. Software revenues were up by 150% year-on-year in BlackBerry’s fiscal first quarter results, though overall, the figures fell short of Wall Street expectations.
Speaking at the company’s annual general meeting, Chen was asked whether he was considering a sale – BlackBerry is almost continuously the subject of M&A speculation, with Samsung a recent, and recurring, rumor. “No. No, no, no, no, no,” Chen responded, as reported by Bloomberg. “Not at this price.”
Chen repeatedly emphasized that the BlackBerry turnaround is a work in progress. “We’re not done yet, not by any stretch of the imagination,” he said. This, of course, would make it a bad time to sell the firm. Certainly, though it continues to disappoint the markets, it is no longer at risk of a fire sale, as it was a couple of years ago, before Chen took the helm. He came with a reputation as a turnaround wizard and an enterprise software expert, based largely on his stellar performance in reinventing database company Sybase as a mobile-driven software powerhouse.
Along with the inevitable cuts and job losses, Chen put in place a strategy to tap more effectively into BlackBerry’s remaining strengths – its enterprise base and mobile software platforms – while making them more relevant in the era of BYOD (bring your own device).
That has meant converting the key BlackBerry software products to support multiple device operating systems; building up assets in growth areas like security and the internet of things (the QNX operating system may have flopped as the basis of BlackBerry 10, but it remains significant for the connected car sector); and defocusing on the famous devices (though not dumping them altogether, as many had hoped).
The next priorities are to build up the software portfolio further – Chen has made three acquisitions already of Movirtu, SecuSmart and WatchDox – and to make the smartphone unit, which still accounts for 40% of sales profitable. The latter objective has seen BlackBerry offloading its device manufacturing to third parties (Foxconn, Compal and Wistron) to lower costs.
The strategy has generally pleased investors, and BlackBerry’s stock price has risen by 36% since Chen took the CEOship. However, the stock fell by 4.2% to $8.81 on the Q1 report, which saw the company posting a larger than expected loss.
For the period, the company reported a net loss, excluding one-time items, of $28m, higher than analysts had projected. With those items, it made a profit of $68m, up from $23m a year earlier, on revenue down 32% to $658m. Operating income was $89m, up from $20m.
Still dragging down performance are the devices. Hardware revenue fell to about $263m, from $379m in the year-ago period. BlackBerry recognized hardware revenue on about 1.1m smartphones, with an average selling price of $240. This ASP was up from $211 in the previous sequential quarter, but unit sales were down from 1.3m, despite wider distribution of the new flagship, the BlackBerry Classic. Chen said, however, that Classic sales were on the “uptick” and the Passport was still shifting units, though it was “a little early to tell” about the newly shipped Leap.
But there were good signs for the software strategy. Chen has pledged to double software and licensing revenue to $500m by March 2016, and in Q115, he achieved $137m, up 150% on the year-ago quarter. This represented 21% of total sales, while services were 38%.
BlackBerry said it made 2,600 enterprise customer wins during the quarter, with 45% of the licences involved in those deals being cross-platform. Chen was pleased with enterprise software and technology licensing growth, but less so with the BBM messaging service, which he said, on the results call, was “off to a slow start in my opinion … BBM I still need to work on.” He is also looking for further acquisitions, aimed at “extending what we have, and also in the IoT world”.
Chen also announced a “broad patent cross-licensing agreement” with Cisco, which will involve licence fees from the router giant, reminding investors that BlackBerry is still a major IPR holder, and may have been wise not to sell off the portfolio to address short term financial woes. Chen said the licensing business has “a very deep pipeline”, and said that a second deal had been concluded in Q1 with “another major technology provider”, but this one was “off the radar”.
Chen said: “Our financials reflect increased investments to sales and customer support for our software business. In addition, we are taking steps to make the handset business profitable. We believe these actions are prudent and necessary to grow the business and we believe the remaining milestones in our strategic plan are achievable.” He added that he expects to maintain positive free cashflow throughout the year and achieve sustainable profitability in the second half of the fiscal year.
In a research note, Wells Fargo analysts Maynard Um, Munjal Shah and Jason Ng wrote in a client note last week: “With a potential sale of the company less likely in the near term, we believe BBRY will likely look at other strategic alternatives (further restructuring, potential divestitures, aggressively target multi-platform strategy, et al).”