Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2007

NextWave and Horizon poise to give Clearwire a run for its money

Sprint Nextel and Clearwire may be making the running among US providers in terms of WiMAX build-out, but others are emerging to challenge them and apply 802.16 technology to similarly ambitious business plans. One, of course, is NextWave Wireless, which continues to combine its assault on the WiMAX chip market with spectrum ownership, and has now acquired a controlling stake in European innovator WiMAX Telecom. The other is Horizon Wi-Com, which is starting to build out the 2.3GHz spectrum it aquired from Verizon Wireless, pre-empting AT&T’s efforts in the same band.

NextWave may see its long term future in WiMAX/Wi-Fi chip architectures, currently heavily geared to metrozone-type applications, but it is taking the Qualcomm approach of proving and kickstarting its inventions with its own deployments. It has considerable stores of US spectrum in the AWS and 2.5GHz bands and is now emulating Clearwire by expanding its holdings to Europe. It has already purchased some licenses, notably in Germany, (where it paid $23.1m for a 3.5GHz franchise) through its joint venture Inquam. Inquam is co-owned with BFR Mobile Radio Partners and Omnia and is also a voice from the past, having previously been the Qualcomm vehicle for buying up 450MHz spectrum, in particular, to push the deployment of CDMA into non-traditional markets, notably in Europe. Qualcomm is also an investor in NextWave and the latter’s CEO Allen Salmasi was a Qualcomm senior executive. Now NextWave is spreading its wings further in central Europe by acquiring a 65% stake in Swiss-based WiMAX Telecom, which operates in Austria and Slovakia and also holds spectrum in Croatia.

Such activities will allow NextWave to own a real world testing ground for its new technologies and generate revenues ahead of availability of its supposedly breakthrough, multi-spectrum chip technology that will tie together a patchwork of different spectra into a single network. It expects its chips to be commercially shipping in 2008 (see Wireless Watch June 11 2007). In a recent interview with RCRWireless, Salmasi said: ‘In the long term, we’re going to be a chipset maker. Everything that we have is built around our chip. ‘ All of our acquisitions are aimed at ultimately bringing WiMAX to the market.’

‘Our idea there was that we develop a great chip and great network equipment with our software defined radio, and we obviously have the software that goes with our chipset, which makes it a lot easier for the handset vendors to bring products to the market,’ he said. ‘We have all those great things, but then if we don’t find the customer that has the spectrum to take advantage of all these technologies, then effectively we are not going to generate a lot of sales. So the idea was that acquiring the spectrum ahead of some of the other folks that would have ultimately been the buyers for the spectrum. Then, that gives us a way to effectively bring ourselves into a partnership, or into a deal that results in selling a lot of chipsets and products to that customer.’ The company – which says it has raised $1.2bn to date since emerging, as ‘NextWave 2′, from bankruptcy protection in 2005 – aims eventually to make deals with the top US carriers.

For now, its sights are set rather lower, but it continues to make acquisitions to boost its products – IPWireless and PacketVideo among others – and its spectrum asset hoard. WiMAX Telecom’s spectrum is in 3.5 GHz and covers around 16.8m people. In Austria at least the regulator has already allowed mobile services to be offered in this band and NextWave hopes to get the same from regulators in Slovakia and Croatia. WiMAX Telecom currently has 8,500 customers in Austria and Slovakia. It has 49MHz of nationwide spectrum in Austria and 56MHz in Slovakia, while its license in Croatia covers 68% of the population, with 39MHz. Commercial services in Croatia will begin at the end of the third quarter this year, using Alvarion BreezeMAX gear.

Dov Bar-Gera, WiMax Telecom’s founder and CEO, said the new investment will enable the company to accelerate its strategy of expanding its fixed – and in future, mobile – services across the whole central European region. The deal should closed early in the third quarter of 2007, and no terms were given.

Back in the US, Horizon Wi-Com has completed its 2.3GHz build-out in nine north eastern cities using Navini’s pre-certified 802.16e wave two gear. Unlike Clearwire, which has tended to stick to mid-tier cities and suburbs, Horizon is going for major population centers, rolling out first in Boston, New York, Philadelphia, Washington DC, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Richmond and Cincinnati. Commercial trials are already underway and full services will launch in a staggered way from the fall.

Like NextWave and Clearwire, Horizon sees strong potential for WiMAX, standalone or combined with Wi-Fi, in city networks, where this platform could provide superior quality of service and therefore more viable business models than Wi-Fi mesh metrozones in unlicensed spectrum alone. With WiMAX, such operators believe they gain the benefits of relatively quick build-out of dense population centers through an outdoor network, as well as snapping up the bonus of visiting and casual traffic, and can then extend this indoors and into mobile devices as CPE evolves. This is a model that has been pioneered, also using Navini equipment, by Unwired Australia in Sydney and other cities, but will be tougher to turn to profit in the US, which does not share Australia’s dream combination (for carriers) of high average urban income and low broadband penetration.

NextWave is focusing heavily on indoor/outdoor WiMAX/Wi-Fi combinations, using a mixture of licensed and license-exempt spectrum, which gives it the flexibility to step up revenues gradually and move more nimbly than the deep pocketed quad play carriers. It seems that Horizon and Clearwire have seen the same attractions in this model, and are aiming to take advantage of the disappointment in many municipalities with the limitations on a Wi-Fi only business model. Clearwire last year announced its first metrozone deal, with Grand Rapids, Michigan, and Cisco – not generally a WiMAX enthusiast – has also been vocal about the need for commercially successful metrozones to offer many levels of QoS, by introducing WiMAX in licensed bands to the basic Wi-Fi mesh. “Citywide Wi-Fi is not a realistic way of providing broadband,” said Sai Subramanian, Navini’s vice president of product management and strategic marketing, in an interview. “Wi-Fi is a good mechanism in the home.”

Horizon Wi-Com will offer its services in markets with about 70m points of presence in its first phase, and is positioning itself competitively against municipal mesh deployments in some of its target cities, including Philadelphia, home of the most famous of the metrozones, which has started deployment by EarthLink; and Cincinnati, which already has a Wi-Fi metrozone.

The 2.3GHz spectrum, although less valuable than the 2.5GHz in the US because it is fragmented, gained new profile last year when it became part of the conditions attached to clearing the merger of AT&T and BellSouth. These conditions insisted that the combined telco sell its holdings in 2.5GHz, most of which have now been acquired by Clearwire, and commit to building out its near-nationwide 2.3GHz frequencies with services to cover 25% of the POPs by July 2010. It also agreed to offer broadband services to 100% of potential users living within the AT&T/BellSouth territory, and that up to 15% of this territory would be provided with broadband connectivity using WiMAX or satellite.

This decision endorsed 2.3GHz as being a usable band for broadband wireless – something some critics had questioned, given that it is split in half in the US by the satellite radio operators’ allocations – and gave a fillip to Navini, one of only two broadband wireless vendors (along with Alvarion) that offers products for the US band (though Alcatel is testing a 2.3GHz version of its Evolium product with BellSouth, and Samsung could adapt its Korean 2.3GHz platform. BellSouth has, to date, used Navini kit for its limited roll-outs in 2.3GHz in rural areas).

Despite the limitations of 2.3GHz in the US, Navini has put considerable effort into harnessing spectral efficiency techniques such as smart beamforming to maximize its usefulness, and already has several customers for 2.3GHz pre-certified kit, including Scarlet Broadband in Mexico, Liberty Technologies in Panama and Meganet Broadband in Massachusetts. This last, though a small local provider based around New Bedford, has pointed the way that larger players in 2.3GHz might go, offering a mobile service in direct competition with cellcos, with a flat rate for data and open access to the internet.

Horizon will have far greater ambitions, having purchased the WCS A Block spectrum previously owned by Verizon late last year. Its initial target customers will be residential last mile users, businesses and emergency services and Navini will also provide turnkey services including network design, deployment and testing, network optimization and network management. Horizon will use Ripwave MX8, which will be submitted for certification as 802.16e wave two compliant when that process kicks early in 2008. Horizon is also implementing the Smart WiMAX solution, which combines MIMO smart antennas and smart beamforming techniques. These performance and range enhancing systems are particularly important in restricted bands such as the 2.3GHz WCS spectrum in the US.

2.3GHz holders in the US:

The 2.3GHz band (in the US, called WCS or Wireless Communications Service and consisting of twin 15MHz slots, from 2305MHz to 2320MHz and from 2345MHz to 2360MHz), is problematic because the 25MHz gap between the two bands is assigned to the Digital Audio Radio Service, raising possible interference problems from DARS terrestrial repeaters.

In the US, the main holders of this spectrum are Horizon (having bought Verizon’s assets), BellSouth-AT&T, NextWave and Metricom, along with some smaller operators.

Existing holders of 2.3GHz such as NextWave may well look to snap up the spectrum assets of WCS Wireless, a holder which had signed a merger deal with satellite radio provider XM in 2006, which then fell through in May, probably putting those licenses back on the market. The companies announced the stock-based agreement ‘ then valued at almost $200m – in July 2005 but between then and May 2006, XM’s stock price plunged from the mid-$30 range to less than $16 per share.

WCS Wireless holds 10MHz of 2.3GHz spectrum in 15 of the top 20 US markets, covering 163m people – spectrum that is adjacent to XM’s own holdings. The radio provider had hoped to use the additional capacity to expand its offerings to include video and data services but was unable to receive regulatory approvals for the deal, following objections from the Wireless Communications Association, XM arch-rival Sirius Satellite Radio and the National Association of Broadcasters. Radio broadcasters were up in arms because the addition of WCS to XM Satellite’s business would have given the latter terrestrial radio capability, allowing it to compete with local over-the-air radio. The WCA argued that a pending waiver that would allow WCS Wireless to operate at higher power levels in the 2.3GHz band shouldn’t be transferred to XM.

Sprint Nextel buys spectrum:

Sprint Nextel may be considering new financing options for its WiMAX operations (see Wireless Watch June 18 2007), but it continues to build on its ambitious roadmap, and its latest move is to acquire further 2.5GHz spectrum from Bell Industries. Sprint will pay $13.5m, pending FCC approval, for a chunk of spectrum of undisclosed size for “operation of Broadband Radio Service channels”. This is assumed to refer to 2.5GHz, though Bell also had a 900MHz network.

The licenses were originally acquired by Bell in its purchase of SkyTel, a paging, telemetry, two-way messaging and email subsidiary, from Verizon Communications late last year. The spectrum licenses were not producing revenue for Bell, according to the company, which had turned its back on previous plans to use Skytel as the basis for a metrozone business. This was hatched when Skytel was still part of MCI, acquired by Verizon in 2006. As Skytel’s core paging business declined, MCI had said it would use the network to establish a national metrozone footprint and a new brand.

‘SkyTel views metro scale Wi-Fi mesh networks as an important new technology with great business potential,’ said Bruce Deer, president of the paging unit, in a statement in 2005, when the strategy was launched (see Wireless Watch March 24 2005). ‘Bringing broadband access to areas where it was previously unavailable or unaffordable is a major objective for us.”

Bell operates three units – technology solutions (from CRM to mobile solutions), SkyTel and a recreational products group.