With most large vendors trying to streamline their product efforts around as few architectures as possible, the maverick NextWave Wireless is taking a huge amount on to its plate, and is now set to become Japan’s only foreign operator by acquiring almost 70% in wireless carrier IPMobile. The company is the largest customer for the TD-CDMA technology of IPWireless, which NextWave acquired earlier this year. While it was widely assumed that IPWireless’ systems would be incorporated into NextWave’s ongoing development of a next generation wireless architecture, which has been WiMAX-led, it now seems that it will support the existing TD-CDMA systems for a while longer, giving it a possible route into LTE, and enabling it to test out its end-to-end ‘spectrum to chips’ business model on a real live customer.
NextWave’s model:
NextWave, initially set up to be a US cellular operator, emerged from bankruptcy protection totally reincarnated as a would-be chipmaker somewhat in the mode of Qualcomm, from which many NextWave executives hail. The company held on to its 2.5GHz spectrum holdings post-Chapter 11, and made significant purchases in last year’s AWS auction. It is also accumulating licenses and stakes in operators ‘ including central Europe’s WiMAX Telecom ‘ in non-US territories. But the point of buying the spectrum is not, this time around, to be an operator per se, but to develop a differentiated business model that NextWave founder Allen Salmasi believes will set it apart from its larger chipmaking competitors. While the company will sell its silicon and reference platforms on the open market ‘ the first, for WiMAX/Wi-Fi, will sample early next year ‘ it expects its major gains to be in offering chips, customized equipment and spectrum as a one-stop shop for companies wanting to make an early leap into pre-4G services.
This model will enable NextWave to target would-be operators that have not been able to get their hands on spectrum, or do not wish to purchase it outright. This represents an early ‘ perhaps premature ‘ recognition of the different models that will evolve for spectrum ownership if mobile internet services are to be fully deployed and exploited. It is probable that, over the next decade, the close association between spectrum ownership and service delivery will break down, and there will be greater potential for new entrants to play in the market without making massive upfront commitment to spectrum, by leasing other company’s capacity in selected markets and even on a dynamic basis. Google has already proposed a system where spectrum would be held by one or several major owners, and would be auctioned on a real time, on-demand basis to a wide variety of service providers. This is the kind of futuristic model NextWave has in mind, though in the short term, of course, it will target more conservative approaches to challenging the telcos in the US and elsewhere, hence its strong focus on combining WiMAX and metro Wi-Fi.
Some disruptive operators have already entered by using license-exempt spectrum, of course, as seen in the groundbreaking, if largely commercially unexciting, metrozones. NextWave itself is targeting metrozones aggressively, partly by helping revive interest in the neglected 5GHz license-exempt profile for WiMAX, but also with an eye on the growing trend for metro operators to introduce licensed elements to their service, often using WiMAX, in order to support higher value services with full quality of service and carrier account control (Clearwire’s activities in Grand Rapids Michigan, and Cisco’s in many major cities, are good indicators of this trend, which other WiMAX/Wi-Fi vendors such as Proxim are also chasing).
The role of TD-CDMA:
While WiMAX has been NextWave’s major focus, since it sees this as the primary licensed spectrum technology that will be available to new or non-traditional operators, the end-to-end model is clearly not dependent on a single technology. Just as the company will acquire spectrum opportunistically wherever it is well priced and the territory has commercial potential for the business model, so it says it will develop a range of technologies according to what operators require. Ultimately these may be converged into a single ‘3.9G’ architecture, as the various network platforms start to harmonize, to some extent, around OFDMA, MIMO and all-IP.
NextWave has grand ambitions to take an early march in this process, despite its relatively late entry to the R&D race and its small resources compared to other contenders, such as Qualcomm itself. But while it works away at the overall architecture that it hopes will propel it into the wireless silicon major league around the turn of the decade, it will generate revenue wherever this is to be found, operating its own networks in parts of the US; owning going concerns like WiMAX Telecom; and adapting its existing technologies for near term carrier requirements.
The most complete product line that it has is, of course, the TD-CDMA based line acquired with IPWireless, which was the most active proponent of this standard, an implementation of W-CDMA for the underused TDD spectrum in the 3G bands. Although it shares some of the same qualities as WiMAX as far as operator models go, and is part of the 3GPP standards family, TD-CDMA never gained the vendor backing or large carrier contracts to take a mainstream position. There have been some traditional BWA deployments in 3.5GHz , although these have had limited commercial impact (the most famous, PCCW’s UK Broadband, switched from TD-CDMA to WiMAX). The greatest hopes lay with the European cellcos, which gained TDD spectrum with their 3G licenses and largely let it lie fallow. Some major players have trialled and even deployed TD-CDMA, notably Orange and T-Mobile in parts of eastern Europe. IPWireless positioned its platform as an early stepping stone to LTE, and this may well be a line that NextWave starts to promote again. The technology, IPWireless argued, allowed operators to implement many of the features of LTE a couple of years ahead, and in existing spectrum ‘ TDD data-optimized operation, full IP support, high bandwidths with mobile broadband. This would fit neatly with the NextWave goal of devising an architecture that would go beyond vanilla standards in its performance, but would be applicable to WiMAX, LTE and other emerging pre-4G networks (even, potentially, the 3GPP2’s UMB or China’s FuTure Network).
IPMobile:
IPMobile has been thinking on similar lines, aiming to use differentiated technologies with rapid roadmaps to 4G in order to make its mark alongside far larger and better resourced competitors, notably the LTE flagwaver, NTT DoCoMo. With this in mind, the company adopted TD-CDMA, having acquired spectrum whose conditions fit neatly with the network’s characteristics. By acquiring a 69.23% stake, NextWave keeps control of a large user, and can tap into its ongoing revenues, plus using it as a showcase for its developing platforms. It bought its stake in the Tokyo-based operator from Mori Trust, which bought the holding in April. The investment comes at a crucial time for IPMobile ‘ having purchased its license in 2005, at the same time as fellow new entrants Softbank Mobile and eMobile received theirs, it now has to start offering services by November or lose its franchise.
‘NextWave, through its IPWireless subsidiary, is a leading global supplier of TD-CDMA wireless broadband products and networks. Our investment is aimed at helping IPMobile accelerate its deployment of this powerful 4G wireless broadband technology before the end of this year in Japan, one of the most advanced telecommunications markets in the world,’ said NextWave CEO Salmasi,. ‘The 2GHz spectrum allocated to IPMobile by MIC specifically calls for the deployment of TD-CDMA technology in Japan. We intend to help IPMobile implement one of the first 4G wireless broadband network deployments that can provide speeds of up to 30 Mbps and support a wide variety of user applications including bandwidth intensive video streaming applications.’
Once the network is launched, Salmasi expects to use it as a springboard to work with the Japanese consumer electronics industry to create new classes of device for the network and so potentially attract some CE powerhouses into its ecosystem. As Sprint knows well, the available devices will be critical in deciding the success of new networks, and NextWave needs to work on this aspect of its ‘end-to-end’ model ‘ activity to which it will also apply the expertise of some of its other recent acquisitions, particularly PacketVideo in the mobile multimedia field.
Prior to IPWireless’ acquisition, IPMobile has signed a supply agreement with Oki Electric for its TD-CDMA base stations, IP core network and central control facilities, and it is assumed this deal, which uses equipment made by TD-CDMA’s main manufacturing firm, UTStarcom, will continue.
While Japan is a peculiar example, particularly because the regulator specified TD-CDMA in IPMobile’s frequencies rather than making it technology neutral, it is also a highly competitive market and one where NextWave will be able to gain valuable experience of how its technologies work in anger, as well as useful revenue streams. And though supporting the TD-CDMA platform in parallel to creating the WiMAX-oriented architecture may be a matter of expediency to support IPMobile and other smaller customers, it could also give NextWave a valuable entry point to LTE and to the ultimate goal of an OFDMA architecture that can be easily adapted to different standards, according to the particular business needs of the operators.