Ericsson has invested heavily in becoming an all-round IP player, not just lord of a mobile ghetto, but its efforts are dwarfed by Cisco and even Alcatel-Lucent. Meanwhile, Cisco has danced around Ericsson’s RAN territory in various ways but never scored much success. In a world of fixed/mobile convergence and all-IP, the logic of the two companies uniting is overwhelming.
The news that the two giants were entering a deep strategic partnership focus nevertheless still came as something of a surprise, given that the recent history of the networks industry has centered so heavily around which firm would lead the IP market of the future – and by inference, whether the established 3GPP community would set the agenda, or the more enterprise-focused players like Cisco and Juniper.
In the event, there will be a joint effort, and we really will stop talking about mobile networking firms. Huawei already covers all the service provider and enterprise bases; Nokia is abandoning its mobile broadband-only strategy by acquiring ALU’s IP and SDN (software-defined networking) jewels; NEC is leading the charge to move above the network altogether and create a new playing field around virtualization and orchestration (see separate item).
Ericsson and Cisco will cooperate on a broad basis, combining their efforts across the key customer bases (carriers first, then enterprise); across the product lifecycle, from development to delivery; and across the technology spectrum, including cloud platforms, SDN, IoT (internet of things) and of course the IP connectivity itself. Ericsson will resell some of Cisco’s IP products as well as gaining access to its partner’s formidable enterprise sales channels. That major benefit to the Swedish firm will be balanced by its contribution of services resources – together, the partnership will have 76,000 services employees, 65,000 from Ericsson, and will be active in 180 countries.
The companies are predicting a full $1bn each in additional revenue by the end of 2018, as a direct result of the alliance. Ericsson will receive patent licence fees from its new friend. The Swedish firm also expects to save SEK1bn ($115m) a year from the deal.
There are huge challenges in achieving workable cooperation between two companies with such different approaches – Ericsson still R&D-heavy and increasingly services-driven; Cisco a sales machine focused on hardware and software, and tending to buy in the new technologies it needs. There are sure to be some meetings which recall the worst days of the Alcatel-Lucent merger, as these two corporate cultures seek to find common ground. There will be many areas of uncertainty and dispute – who has final say in key strategic decisions; how future IPR will be shared; how major mutual customers will be approached; which industry alliances and open source groups to support; just how much the companies will feel comfortable sharing, since an alliance, however deep, can fall apart.
Vestberg tried to address some of these concerns in an analyst call. He said mutual solutions “will be jointly developed but one party will own it. We will agree on that … it will be defined very clearly in the partnership agreement”, adding that it would make sense for Cisco to take the lead on enterprise-focused products and Ericsson on carrier ones. He insisted that the deal would be structured so that benefits were balanced and fair. “It will not result in $5bn in sales for Cisco and $100,000 for Ericsson,” he said.
But despite all the difficulties ahead, it is positive that the firms are steering clear of an actual merger. The deal has far fewer risks than that (even supposing it could get past antitrust) and is a decisive move to preserve both partners’ markets in the face of the rise of Huawei and the merger of Nokia and Alcatel-Lucent. Both companies are traditionally wary of major acquisitions and Ericsson resisted all pressure to follow Nokia’s lead and acquire a router company like Juniper. “I don’t believe in big mergers – this is by far the best solution you can get,” Ericsson CEO Hans Vestberg told Bloomberg. “This is much faster and more efficient.”
Cisco’s executive chairman John Chambers agreed, saying in an interview: “The odds are good that [the Nokia/ALU merger] will fail. By the time you shake out the efficiencies and get regulatory approval, it’s a two- to three-year process. This industry, the winners and losers, will be decided in three years. I’d love to see a lot of our peers tied up with large acquisitions.”
On the conference call, he enlarged on the theme, saying: “While we are a huge believer in big-to-small and big-to-medium acquisitions, partnerships, if you can do them, are the way to go large-to-large. Joint ventures add an extra level of complexity.”
But both firms needed to come up with some response to the consolidation in their businesses, itself partly a reaction to the rise of the Huawei superpower, as well as to the lurch towards software and new platforms which neither had invented or, probably, wanted. The need to build economies of scale while accelerating moves into new revenue streams were highlighted just days after the announcement when Ericsson cut its outlook for the overall network equipment business. It believes that sector will grow at a CAGR of 1% to 3% in 2014-2018, down from a previous projection of 2% to 4% (though that was to 2017). It pledged to grow more quickly than the market, and of course the ability to resell Cisco’s products will help with that.
The wireless infrastructure business is consolidating as traditional hardware becomes a game of scale and the value shifts to virtualization and SDN, services and cloud platforms. That has created a long ticklist of capabilities which a dominant player will need, many of which Huawei already has. Whatever 5G ends up looking like, it is clear that the next decade’s networks, wireless and wireline, will be driven by the cloud, and will mirror some of the features that have developed in cloud infrastructure – high levels of intelligence combined with high levels of automation and enormous scale; massive distribution of resources right out to an ever-more granular edge; high speeds and availability serving vast numbers of devices; all of this tied together by AI, analytics and big data, not to mention the essential ingredient of security.
In these areas of future growth, Ericsson and Cisco are far more complementary than they are in their traditional markets. While Cisco had little chance of penetrating Ericsson’s mobile RAN fortress, nor Ericsson Cisco’s enterprise IP heartland – despite strong attempts by both around the edges – they can target one another’s customers with their software-oriented platforms.
Ericsson has a far more developed services offering – Cisco’s structure and roadmap is still mainly product-focused, though the cloud, IoT and SDN markets will inevitably bring elements of managed services into the mix. Their strengths and weaknesses in virtualization, orchestration and SDN are different, and while Cisco has a more end-to-end approach to the IoT, Ericsson has been developing the links between a hosted cloud service and billions of endpoints.
And of course, they both have a core customer base of large service providers, though they usually sell different products to different departments. Even that is changing – as seen in AT&T’s Domain 2.0 and many other operators’ bids to shake up their supply chains, the providers of base stations, routers and other kit are being brought together around SDN.
Better then, to play nicely in those playgrounds than try to muscle each other to the sidelines, and in doing so, wrongfoot the other competitors, without the disruption of a huge merger or joint venture, Nokia/ALU-style. Indeed, as those two vendors spend much of 2016 working out the details of their marriage, with the aim of offering a full scale IP/mobile platform plus software, Ericsson and Cisco could leapfrog them and provide a similar combination in a simpler way. Nokia may be regretting its recent statements that it would be a “more complete player” than Ericsson, post-merger, though it responded to the news bravely, telling the Financial Times: “The integrated sales team of the new Nokia will look forward to pitching against a Cisco salesperson selling Ericsson products.”
Both partners will have the chance to squeeze rivals – Huawei for both of them, Nokia/ALU for Ericsson, Juniper, ALU and agile SDN specialists for Cisco. Even Huawei will have to look nervously at an axis which boasts $75.4bn in combined revenues in the last fiscal year and has 76,000 professional services staff. By comparison, Nokia and ALU generate $27.8bn between them (based on current exchange rates).
And there will be question marks over other partnerships. Though Ericsson insisted that the Cisco deal would not replace existing deals,Vestberg did talk of the focus shifting to Cisco’s broader portfolio when asked, on the analyst call, about reseller relationships with Juniper and Hewlett-Packard Enterprise. There will be a few overlaps to deal with too. The Swedish firm said it would continue to sell its own SE line of RAN routers, the product of its Redback acquisition, but there might be a sell-by date on those products now. Other areas of overlap include Carrier WiFi (after Ericsson’s purchase of BelAir) and indoor small cell platforms (Cisco owns Ubiquisys and has a partnership with Spidercloud, while Ericsson offers the Radio Dot system as well as various picocells).
Despite the obvious uncertainties, the firms proclaimed their new alliance as one which would create the “networks of the future”, and offer customers “the best of both companies: routing, data center, networking, cloud, mobility, management and control, and global services capabilities.”
The program is ambitious but will be split into stages. “This is a multi-phased approach – this is just phase one,” said Chambers. “You can see us already working on phase two and we are dreaming about what phase three is. That gives the staying power – it won’t be a year or two transaction. We will be so deeply intertwined it will be like a marriage except we can make it happen faster.”
While phase one will center on current products and offering an end-to-end portfolio, phase two will include three other key goals – to create a new mobile enterprise platform based on a “highly secure technology architecture for seamless indoor/outdoor networks”, which would presumably tap into Cisco’s WiFi and Ericsson’s LTE and 5G work; to accelerate development of platforms for the IoT; and to design a network management system that will integrate Cisco’s IP and virtualization smarts with Ericsson’s OSS/BSS capabilities, to support multivendor SDN deployments.
This is one of Ericsson’s most significant public statements about the need to relinquish control of the actual network and move more rapidly towards the management and orchestration layers above, something Nokia has been talking up for several years.
Among the details of the deal are commitments to create reference architectures and products; systems-based management and control; a broad reseller agreement; and collaboration in key emerging market segments. Also, a combined team will start work on a joint initiative focused on SDN and virtualization.
They will cross-licence each other’s patent portfolios – they have a combined 56,000 patents, though clearly the weight is towards Ericsson, which will receive the revenues from the agreement. They will also discuss Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) policies.
Vestberg said in a statement: “Foremost, we share the same vision of the network’s strategic role at the center of every company’s and every industry’s digital transformation. Initially the partnership will focus on service providers, then on opportunities for the enterprise segment and accelerating the scale and adoption of IoT services across industries. For Ericsson, this partnership also fortifies the IP strategy we have developed over the past several years, and it is a key move forward in our own transformation.”
His counterpart at Cisco, Chuck Robbins, said: “With the pace the market is moving, the successful companies will be those who build the right strategic partnerships to accelerate innovation, growth, and customer value … We have worked with Ericsson during the last year on developing a strategy for future industry leadership, and can start executing together today.”
The firms secured public support from the CEOs of key customers including Vodafone and AT&T, welcoming the potential to accelerate innovation in the integration of wireless and IP, and the move to the IoT.
And Roger Gurnani, chief information and technology architect at Verizon, summed it all up, saying: “This global partnership has the potential to reshape the industry.”