Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 October 2012

Nokia and even Apple have pre-results nerves

Nokia is expected to report another lean quarter on Thursday, although the markets were feeling unforgiving this week, even raising doubts about Apple’s figures, due the same day, because of iPhone 5 supply constraints. But its problems are trivial compared to those of Nokia, whose CEO Stephen Elop is under rising pressure to accelerate the promised turnaround.

Although the vendor is building some momentum behind its Lumia Windows Phone handsets, the latest models, including the flagship 920, will not have shipped in time to affect Q3. Analysts expect performance to be weak in its largest business unit, Devices & Services, though with some pick-up in featurephones. However, its quarter will likely reflect that the transition from Symbian to Windows Phone has been even more difficult than expected. Analysts believe Symbian sales will have dropped off more quickly than anticipated, while the Lumia family, though growing in sales, is nowhere near the level to compensate for the loss of the once market-leading smartphone OS.

This will put more pressure on Elop, who was over-confident in predicting, when he announced the alliance with Microsoft, that there would still be several years of life in Symbian yet. Instead, Nokia is suffering intense challenges in all its device markets. It has not yet pushed Windows Phone down into its natural heartland, the entry level smartphone, and Symbian is being ousted here by Android. And even in emerging markets, despite the strong performance of the Asha Series 40 webphones, its higher volume ranges are losing out to cheap alternatives from Chinese and even Indian manufacturers.

Strategy Analytics analyst Neil Mawston told Associated Press that he expects Nokia to ship around 83m devices in total, which would put it even further behind Samsung than in Q2 (the Korean firm is expected to sell 98m units spanning Android, Windows and featurephone models). And Nokia is likely to see its smartphone sales fall from 10.2m in Q2 to about 8m, though most observers think featurephones will be holding up better than in the first half of the year.

If Lumia has put in a strong performance in Q3, investors will be more ready to give Elop more time to effect the transition. It sold 4m units in Q2, doubling the previous quarter’s figure. However, it is probably optimistic that Nokia could better even that modest total in Q3, because the market was waiting for the new Lumia models with Windows Phone 8; and users were aware that there was no upgrade path from WP7 to the new operating system, further deterring them from purchasing older Lumias.

Though hardly in the same league as Nokia’s problems, there are also some dark clouds over Apple’s forthcoming results announcement. Supply constraints for the iPhone 5 might bring earnings in below Wall Street’s admittedly optimistic forecasts and several analysts pared back their estimates. Since about half Apple’s revenue comes from the handset, any glitches have a huge effect on overall performance. And while an inability to meet huge demand is a problem Nokia would love to have these days, there is still nervousness around the delays in getting iPhone 5s to all consumers.

One investment firm, William Blair, cut its iPhone estimates for the September and December quarters and now expects Apple to sell 26.5m handsets in its fiscal fourth quarter, down from a previous forecast of 33m. For the fiscal first quarter ending in December, it expects shipments of 45m rather than 46m. “Apple’s inability to keep up with demand is being amplified by its aggressive global launch schedule and the company reducing its exposure to its traditional partner, Samsung,” William Blair analyst Anil Doradla told CNet. Other analyst reducing their estimates included Morgan Stanley and Gabelli. Another issue is whether the success of the iPad is starting to cannibalize MacBook sales rather than generating incremental revenues.