Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2008

Nokia and Qualcomm head for court in landmark Delaware case

The next round in the intense legal battle between Nokia and Qualcomm commences this week, with a hearing in the Delaware Court of Chancery starting today. A decision by this court, which specializes in business disputes, will certainly not result in a final outcome for the two companies’ bitter patent and licensing disputes, which have raged since their cross-licensing deal expired 15 months ago. But it could provide a significant indicator of how the tide is flowing and put pressure on the losing side to make a settlement ‘ a settlement that could actually benefit both companies, by opening the road for Nokia to use Qualcomm’s more advanced chips in future. And given the power of both players in their respective markets, any decision in Delaware will have knock-on implications for the structure of the handset business, and for future IPR policies as the mobile world shifts towards open source.

The court will rule on two claims: Nokia’s that Qualcomm is unfairly charging too much for its patents and therefore abusing its market position; and Qualcomm’s that Nokia has automatically extended their cross-licensing agreement because it continues to use the technology, and is doing so illegally.

However, the companies could be in for the long haul, with some analysts predicting this hearing will not be decisive and the series of trials will take almost two years to resolve. However, optimists believe a decision in Delaware ‘ expected in September – will prompt the antagonists to return to the negotiating table. “One position will be compromised after this case,” said William Davidson, senior VP for global markets at Qualcomm. “Someone will feel motivation to go foward [with a resolution].”

The case is to be televised and webcast by Courtroom View Network on a pay-per-view basis, with many financial institutions apparently signing up for the service, which carries fees starting at $400. One of a string of lawsuits in the US and Europe – concerning both companies’ patent holdings and the fees they charge, as well as some broader antitrust issues ‘ the Delaware case centers on Nokia’s 1992 licensing agreement for Qualcomm CDMA patents, which expired in April 2007. At this stage, Nokia had paid about $1bn in royalties for these patents. It believes a new deal should carry significantly lower fees, partly because of the huge sum paid out to date, which it says means it is ‘paid up’ for CDMA patents; and partly because the Finnish giant claims the value of its own patents has increased radically in the past 15 years, so a cross-licensing deal should be weighted more heavily in its favor. It argues that Qualcomm’s newer W-CDMA patents carry far less value than its old CDMA ones. It also alleges that Qualcomm is breaking fair business practices agreed by ETSI (European Telecommunications Standards Institute) by suing for better terms.

Nokia has set aside funds equivalent to the amount it argues it should now be paying Qualcomm – $20m a quarter – but has not actually paid the chip giant any royalties for 15 months, something that has not yet visibly damaged the US company’s financial performance, amid a series of strong quarters. In setting aside the cash, Nokia sought to set market expectations for what it believes it owes Qualcomm – but based on Qualcomm’s estimated impact from the loss of Nokia royalties this year, the $80m a year sum is only 15% of what Qualcomm believes it is owed.

Qualcomm acknowledges that the older patents have been paid off but contends that its newer patent portfolio is just as valuable, warranting the same licensing fees. It points out that 90 companies pay for its W-CDMA patents, all of them at the same rate as for the older CDMA technologies.

A likely outcome, according to legal analysts, would be Delaware Chancery Court Judge Leo Strine ruling that Qualcomm does have a right to charge its standard licensing fee rate, while also declaring that Nokia’s actions do not constitute an automatic extension of the agreement. This would be a useless call from the point of view of progressing the debate, since it would in effect preserve the status quo, but it might drive the parties into arbitration. However, it could also have the opposite effect and spark a series of US cases ‘ the opponents previously agreed to consolidate five cases into a single Delaware trial but could restart some of the individual cases if no clear settlement is reached. In addition, four US cases have already been settled (at a score of two all), and Nokia is also one of six companies that have brought an antitrust case against Qualcomm before the European Commission, which is under investigation.

If the dispute drags on, certainly beyond year end, Qualcomm’s likely next move to escalate the situation would be to sue Nokia for illegal use of its patents ‘ so far it has agreed to stop short of this step, just demanding payment and arguing that Nokia has tacitly extended the old licensing pact (under its old terms) by continuing to use the patents.