Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 September 2016

Nokia builds its bridge to 5G, updating everything but the radio

While Ericsson was congratulating itself on the enthusiastic operator response it claimed for its New Radio announcements, its rivals remain more focused on a staged progression towards 5G, which will allow operators to implement key enablers, such as Cloud-RAN, Mobile Edge Computing and dense HetNets, as they require them, and before they make the transition away from the LTE radios.

Huawei was the first major OEM really to articulate a step-by-step progress towards 5G when it outlined ‘4.5G’ in 2015. This initially saw it developing new technologies for new use cases, such as low power wide area networks (LPWANs), without requiring a move on from the LTE macro network. However, it largely lost the battle to get its cellular IoT technology, based on its acquisition of UK-based start-up Neul, adopted as a standard – there are elements of it in the 3GPP’s NB-IoT, but in the end, that went for an approach with far greater backwards compatibility with LTE.

That fight revealed the dilemma that faces vendors and operators when they are between generations of technology – stick with the one they have, even if it has to be shoehorned into new ways of working; or adopt something shiny and optimal, but with the problems of coexistence and legacy. This basic dilemma will pursue the stakeholders throughout the road from LTE to 5G, and different companies will take different positions along the spectrum from ‘rip it all out’ to ‘eke out performance from LTE for another 20 years’.

The challenge for the network OEMs is to support all those variations, and provide equipment to suit the trailblazers and the cautious operators, while allowing them to adopt new architectures like C-RAN and MEC either in an LTE environment or a 5G one.

The key to all this will be common interfaces, some coming from 3GPP, but others from the IT world where software-defined networks (SDN) will be created. Industry bodies like Small Cell Forum and Broadband Forum also publish interfaces and APIs which should enable operators to mix and match equipment from different vendors, different architectures (virtual or physical) and different radio generations.

That multi-generational HetNet is still largely a dream in 2016, however, and operators which want to lay firm foundations for 5G tend to be relying heavily on their usual vendors doing the groundwork.

Along with Huawei, Nokia is also rising to the challenge. At the CTIA Super Mobility show in Las Vegas earlier this month, the company was positioning itself as the primary provider of bridging technology between 4G and 5G, reiterating the messages of its recent launch of 4.5G and ‘4.9G’ systems (basically referring to LTE-Advanced and LTE-A Pro, or Releases 13 and 14).

At the start of this month, Nokia said it would bring 4.9G to market in its AirScale radio platform, the underpinnings of its ‘bridge to 5G’ story, at the end of next year. It is promising “10 times the speeds of initial 4G networks”, and a seamless upgrade for current customers of Nokia 4.5G. These number about 90 worldwide, says the company. Among the features which will power 4.9G Pro’s speed boost are five-band carrier aggregation.

Nokia is billing ‘4.9G’ as a parallel technology to early 5G, allowing operators to continue to enhance their LTE networks even as they start to deploy the next generation standards. According to the vendor, 4.9G will bring “significant capacity and data rate enhancements and network latency reductions to let users maintain a continuous 5G service experience complementing 5G radio coverage”.

It will boost speeds to “several gigabits per second”, by aggregating even larger numbers of carriers and using highly directional antennas which will “allow signals sent via multiple transmit / receive paths to be added together”. It also promises to enable cloud-based RANS, with significant intelligence at the edge to reduce latency to below 10ms. This is an area where Nokia has been a pioneer among the network OEMs, particularly via its work on Mobile Edge Computing with Intel.

At CTIA, the company enlarged on its promises. Phil Twist, VP of mobile networks marketing, told a media briefing: “What we’ve done with 4.5G Pro effectively is turbocharged what goes at the bottom of the tower” to support greater carrier aggregation, higher order MIMO, 3G beamforming and other elements which will be added to the 3GPP specifications next year. He said that, in previous generations, each iteration represented about 10 times improvement, but 5G is targeting 100 times improvement over 4G. This requires a ‘4.5G’ bridge. “The fundamental reason that we’re doing this is that we need an LTE network that when you go from 5G radio implementation outside, you don’t fall off a cliff,” Twist said. “So if we’ve got 10Gbps in the early 5G implementations, having something which is close to that in the rest of the network means that you can offer ubiquitous services across the network. This service continuity is one of the key elements.”

He believes that 5G will complement 4G for many years and will initially be deployed for very specific use cases, not as another generation of wide area coverage. In that way, it will enable the OEMs to reach out to new entrants in the service provider space – Nokia said it was actively engaged with webscale and cable companies, which could harness dynamic and shared spectrum, as well as sub-nets built around Mobile Edge Computing, virtualized packet core and small cells. It is also interested in opportunities to replace private networks in areas like public safety and city services.

For these reasons, 4.9G may stick to a well-known radio, but it involves a transformation of the network architecture, so that ‘5G-like’ use cases can initially be supported on 4G. Nokia has built 4.5G Pro to be compatible with the device chipsets it understands are coming to market in 2017, but updates to the core will be required. “To make what we would call a 4.9G network, you need to have done the modifications to the core side as well, otherwise you can’t achieve the latency,” Twist said. “We’re aiming 4.9G as a network solution which incorporates the ability to use Cloud-RAN, use edge computing, have centralized core elements for some of the non-real time and control plane stuff, but the user plane stuff needs to be distributed out towards the edge. So there are some architecture changes in networks that need to happen in order for the specifications we’re talking about.”

However, in all the excitement about 5G, Nokia believes 3G, too, will have a long life in some areas. At CTIA, it promised that its AirScale platform would also deliver  operational and cost efficiencies to those 3G networks, as it announced the AirScale RNC, claiming to be the first cloud-based 3G radio network controller. According to the GSA, about 40% of mobile users will still be accessing 3G networks in 2020. Moving the RNC to the cloud can increase automation and flexibility, and networks which span multiple air interfaces.

And Nokia also sees opportunities for its services business in helping operators move to 5G at their own pace. It has launched 5G Acceleration Services, which develop a dedicated plan for each operator, including  business case analysis, spectrum assessment and a phased roadmap for business, technology and operations.

Nokia held up Tele2 Russia as an example of its services approach. It recently signed a memorandum of understanding with the operator to work together on how LTE-A and 5G can deliver a wide range of use cases, from real time HD video to IoT to network automation. They will explore technologies such as MIMO, multiple carrier aggregation, LTE-Broadcast, edge video orchestration and traffic optimization.

Ritvars Krievs, CTO at Tele2 Russia, said: “We expect 5G to become mainstream technology by 2021. Working with Nokia we can take advantage of the technologies that capitalize on the efficiencies enabled by 5G to differentiate our offer and exceed the expectations of our subscribers.”

Ericsson seeks vertical industry views on 5G:

Ericsson has been polling the views of vertical industries – likely to be the main justifications for 5G roll-out – about their real interest in the capabilities. The Ericsson report, ‘Opportunities in 5G: The view from eight industries’, concludes that most executives in these chosen industries do regard 5G as an “innovation engine”.

“Emerging technologies, such as IoT, are becoming integral parts of our economy and lifestyle, and this is driving major change across industries,” said Rima Qureshi, Ericsson’s chief strategy officer. “5G will accelerate this transformation and create new uses, new revenue streams, and new business models for industries and consumers alike. With 5G, industries will have connectivity that is customized for their requirements and the agility to move quickly to meet customer needs and be innovative.”

The eight industries which the vendor believes will initially be the most impacted by 5G, are:

  • automotive
  • utilities
  • public safety
  • high-tech manufacturing
  • Internet/digital natives
  • healthcare
  • financial services
  • media/gaming

According to the report, 94% of public safety respondents said they will make significant changes to their business to take advantage of 5G networks, a figure that was even higher among Internet/digital natives, at 96%.