Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2015

Nokia Here aims for second standard, proving why it should not be sold

Nokia’s Here mapping division is something of a crown jewel, and one which, despite talk of a bidding war for the unit, is in danger of being sold off too cheaply. Of course, the location platform sits uneasily in a network infrastructure-driven business, but it is still tempting to think that, when Nokia re-enters the devices space next year (see separate item), it might do so with more than just licensing deals for the venerable brand plus some basic reference designs.

Nokia could licence something that would really disrupt the device game, by incorporating some of the diamonds of its still-powerful R&D engine, while avoiding the pitfalls of manufacturing execution by relying on partners like Foxconn. In this more ambitious scenario, location awareness could be at the heart of the effort – just as it is at the heart of Google’s attempts to redefine the future mobile and web experience.

The Finnish firm may feel it needs to sell Here in order to improve its funds to acquire Alcatel-Lucent, and it has reportedly spurned a $3bn bid by taxi hailing firm Uber, holding out for a price of at least $4bn. That means talks are focused on the chief remaining bidders, a group of German carmakers (Mercedes-Benz, Audi and BMW), possibly backed by China’s Baidu. If that group prevails, it will have interesting ramifications for Google, in particular, placing its main mapping rival at the heart of efforts by powerful connected car players, as well as the ‘Chinese Google’.

But the price will still have been too low. After all, Nokia paid twice that – $8.1bn – for Navteq, on whose maps Here was built, and has invested significant development since then. Its revenues were only €261m ($287m) in the first quarter of this year, but that was up 25% year-on-year – growth unachievable in traditional mobile businesses – and gross profit was up 21% to €194m.

And then there is opportunity cost. As Apple knows from painful experience, developing a location service from scratch is extremely difficult – once Here is gone, Nokia will not have the chance to return to this business except by licensing a third party offering (perhaps its own).

The potential is for Here to turn Nokia into a powerful company in the important areas of navigation, location awareness and proximity services – in cars and smart cities, not just handsets. This is highlighted in the way that the company is pushing itself, via Here, into the standards process to try to define and control important emerging areas of mobile activity. Such efforts might be better directed at making itself the dominant player in location in the future, rather than just adding value for potential acquirers.

A couple of weeks ago, Nokia Here published a set of specifications for integrating data from a wide range of in-car sensors via the cloud, aiming to set a standard way to support sensor interoperability. This helps to update maps in near-real time to support live views of road and traffic conditions, based on the information from huge numbers of cars. That information, in turn can be used by a variety of traffic applications especially in safety.

This week, Here is pushing to create a standard for NFC-based mobile payments for transport tickets. It has formed the Open Mobile Ticketing Alliance (OMTA) to develop the specs which would, if widely adopted, allow travellers to purchase public transport tickets in cities across the world using a single smartphone application.

In a statement, Nokia said the goal of the OMTA is to enable consumers to “register once, travel anywhere” by standardizing the interface between handsets and transit infrastructure. This, in turn, could boost usage of public transport by making it easier to buy tickets, and so contribute to easing car congestion in urban areas. Justus Brown, head of urban mobility at Here and OMTA chairman, said easier public transport systems also had a social impact as they allowed non-car owners to be fully mobile.

Alliance launch partners include transportation service providers Scheidt & Bachmann and Thales, and mobile payment Verifone Mobile Money. These companies have already demonstrated pre-commercial versions of the specs working with the Here Maps app, and aim to conduct trials with transit agencies in a number of cities around the world in the second half of this year.

While NFC has been slow to take off for general m-payments, it is used widely in transportation smart cards, so there is likely to be high consumer acceptance of this function if it moves to the phone with the rising inclusion of NFC chips in mobile devices.

All of this just helps to make the case for keeping Here within Nokia’s walls. CEO Rajeev Suri said recently, when asked about the Here negotiations: “We may not end up selling it if we don’t get the right value.” The ‘right value’ may, however, be higher than the $4bn Nokia is reportedly asking for its mapping jewel.