Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 November 2012

Nokia must build its comeback around services not Windows

Bringing smartphone-like qualities to low end handsets is an important strategy for companies looking to tap into the high growth rates in emerging markets. While conversion from featurephones to smartphones is a gathering trend, there remains a huge addressable base ‘ including first-time mobile users ‘ which still buys cheaper devices, but still wants web functionality. The best way to establish brand loyalty ‘ and hopefully provide a smartphone upgrade in future ‘ is to support those applications, as Nokia is trying to do with its Asha range of webphones.

Asha is arguably as important to Nokia as the Lumia flagship because, if successful, it could help stem the flow of users in markets like India where the Finnish giant has natural strengths and installed base, and thus could deliver quicker revenues than Windows Phone, which is generally acknowledged to be a slow burn, and one which has to fight with Apple and Google head-on. And Nokia is well aware that Asha will succeed not because of hardware or brand, but because it delivers a simple yet rich web experience, and a range of useful or desirable apps, to people with simple devices who still want the mobile web (or actually need it ‘ Nokia has worked hard on applications such as e-agriculture and remote learning, which can open up new economic opportunities for rural people in emerging economies).

The Finnish firm took an early lead over Google, Apple and others ‘ with their focus on premium users and smartphones ‘ in working on applications that would breed loyalty in emerging economies. In particular, it was the first tier one vendor to work intensively on local language content and apps, especially for countries like India and Indonesia which have many languages. And long before the Windows alliance, it created products like the Life Tools which offer basic capabilities like email, messaging, data feeds on crops or markets, and productivity aids ‘ all on featurephones and with simple interfaces.

Although Nokia dropped some developments – including the creation of a new operating system for the important no-man’s land between real smartphones and low end featurephones ‘ it is still building on its work in emerging market apps, and now has a hardware vehicle for this, in the shape of Asha.

Asha has its own fierce challengers, notably the Chinese handset makers and Samsung, but in many emerging economies, Nokia is still coming from in front. Its featurephone business has suffered in recent quarters, so the pressure is on this family to differentiate it against the rising tide of Asian and white label phones.

The latest duo of models include Nokia’s first handset to feature a dedicated Facebook button ‘ a tactic already adopted by several operator and vendor brands including Hutchison’s INQ device unit. The Asha 205 and 206 are both priced at US$62 and will ship this month in a range of markets, in single-SIM and dual-SIM variants. The 205 has a Qwerty keyboard, while its stablemate is in the candybar form factor.

Another new feature of both devices is ‘Slam’, which allows for sharing content such as photos and videos between phones, using Bluetooth. It can exchange media with almost any Bluetooth enabled device (though not Nokia’s own Lumias or the iPhone) without the need to pair devices, and without the recipient needing to have Slam. The capability, exclusive to the new Asha models (and future additions) exchanges content more rapidly than conventional Bluetooth sharing, claims the vendor, and does not consume any internet data.

Both the new handset also support the Nokia Xpress Internet platform, one of the rising number of web platforms targeted at low end devices, which process data and web requests mainly in the cloud, to reduce strain on the phone and its connection. Nokia has been a pioneer in this area, which also features in offerings from Opera, Myriad, Amazon and others ‘ it says Xpress reduces data consumption by up to 90%.

Another feature originally showcased on the Lumia smartphones, but finding its way to Asha too, is Nokia Nearby, a web app which identifies local points of interest such as restaurants and ATMs.

The 205 also supports Twitter, Gmail and eBuddy Chat, and the free Nokia Life+ web app, which includes the Life Skills and Live Healthy services. The 206 has a 2.4-inch display with direct homescreen access to Facebook and Twitter.

The most difficult, but essential, target for Nokia is the entry level smartphone ‘ in many ways its natural home, but fiercely contested by the Android vendors. Here, upgrades to Windows Phone 7 will be important to support lower specified devices than the new WP8.

The Asha strategy mirrors that on smartphones, where Nokia increasingly puts the services where it has a lead ‘ location and imaging ‘ at the heart of the experience in its bid for differentiation. Of course, services are a tiny part of its otherwise declining business, but they are growing and giving Nokia new respectability and partnerships (its Maps is used by Microsoft, Amazon and several auto makers, among others).

When former CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, who had pledged to turn Nokia from a phonemaker into a web services firm, was ousted, it seemed his vision of Nokia as software platform was dead. Key assets like Qt and MeeGo were closed or sidelined ‘ but the challenges of competing in smartphones and the success of the mapping unit mean that some of his services instincts remain alive. Since 2009, Nokia has acquired eight software and services firms (Bit-side, Cellity, Plum, Dopplr, MetaCarta, Novarra, Motally and Smarterphone) and is quietly building a software platform, not to try to challenge Google or Amazon, but to have something that not only makes its own devices attractive, but makes it relevant and attractive to important partners which lack their own web platforms ‘ the convergence with Microsoft’s mobile software, of course, but also the potential to build on the maps pacts and lure potential partners for a full web system (potential candidates which need an alternative to Google include the operators, plus Facebook, Amazon and many vertically focused firms).

The mapping activity has been highlighted on smartphones, but all Nokia’s software advantages are strongest in emerging markets where it has large, if declining, market presence and less direct competition from Apple and Google. And there is growth to tap into. According to a study by management consulting firm Zinnov, the Indian mobile value added services (MVAS) market is expected to move from the traditional SMS-based services to web services and applications, and to grow in value from over $5bn now, to well over $6bn in a year’s time. The decline in voice and even data ARPU is forcing carriers to focus on MVAS, particularly m-health, m-government, m-education, plus mobile payments and infotainment. These will generally be led and branded by operators, but these carriers will need content and services partners, and Nokia already has important deals with cellcos like Reliance Communications. The next step, though, must logically be to separate the services from Nokia’s own devices and operating systems. Of course the software will be used to differentiate these, for as long as the Finnish company can still compete in hardware, but it needs a back-up option that relies on multiplatform apps, and can ride on the growth of Android ‘ especially in Nokia’s vertical markets ‘ rather than fighting against it.

The company has shown signs of this with the recent launch of Nokia Here, which takes its famous Maps platform and places it at the heart of a cloud-based service targeting most mobile operating systems and HTML5. This is the future for Nokia and means that, assuming it does not exit or sell the handset business, it must address the same difficult balance as Microsoft, Amazon and Google ‘ how to differentiate their own devices by harnessing their services and user experience, while also ensuring those web apps remain broadly adopted across third party gadgets too. It’s a difficult task ‘ and one which Apple does not have to take on, giving it competitive advantage. But for once this is a challenge where Nokia starts with some advantages ‘ Navteq, its understanding of device channels, and its urgent need to start with a clean slate. Put bluntly, it has less to lose than the web giants, and if there is a comeback for Nokia, it must be based heavily around services, just as the underrated Kallasvuo predicted.

Apple regains smartphone lead in US, but not Europe

The iPhone 5 has propelled Apple back into the number one spot in the US smartphone market, according to the first of the usual string of market share calculations, but the pattern is not repeated elsewhere. Meanwhile, after a few days of good news and share price jumps, RIM was back to gloom, as its stock fell on the same survey, showing its US share down to just 1.6%.

The report for the 12-week period ended October 28, from research firm Kantar Worldpanel ComTech, found that iOS took 48.1% of US smartphones sales in those three months, beating Android’s 46.7% and leaving just 5.2% for the other contenders, notably Windows and BlackBerry.

However, in other areas studied by the company, the new iPhone was having less impact. In Germany, 73.9% of smartphones purchased during the period were running Android, and in Spain the figure rose to 81.7%. The US has always been the strongest territory for iOS, but the contrast with Europe seems to be sharpening. A combination of factors could be assumed to be behind that ‘ more diverse user bases in Europe, the high impact of the Samsung Galaxy range, and the availability of lower cost Android models in the recession-struck region.

The iPhone 5 only shipped in late September, so it is likely to affect the ratings more clearly in the next study, even outside the US.

‘Apple’s rise in the US has not been replicated in quite the same way across Europe where Android still takes the lead, accounting for 73.9% of sales in Germany and 81.7% in Spain. However, it is now enjoying share gains in four of the five major European countries with a particularly strong performance in Britain where it holds a 32.7% share,’ said the researchers in a statement.