Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 April 2008

Nokia shares fall on warnings over handset prices and ‘crazy currency’

The announcement of Nokia’s first quarter figures followed a familiar pattern for the Finn ‘ strong results overshadowed by market worries about the prospects for the handset sector, intensified by the vendor’s own characteristic caution. While Nokia stuck to its previous forecast of a 10% growth in handset unit shipments in 2008, it warned that the overall value of these devices, in euro terms, would fall, reflecting a squeeze in the high end categories caused by price competition and consumer spending fears, plus a broader shift in the cellphone market towards low end, low cost models. This is a shift that Nokia has, so far, handled masterfully compared to casualties of the race to ultra-low cost, notably Motorola, but its feat of growing market share in all segments last year while also boosting margins is unlikely to be repeatable in 2008, and investors are getting nervous about how dramatic the change in the balance of business may be for the market leader.

Nokia rarely gets as much credit for a strong quarter’s showing as a US counterpart would, a factor of its own tendency to be very cautious in its outlooks, and of its relatively low profile in the US. This was not helped in Q1 of 2008 by an absence of real evidence that Nokia is succeeding in crossing its final frontier, gaining a US presence commensurate with its weight in other parts of the world. Instead, its quarterly figures were announced amid a rush of speculation that this year would see Samsung snatching the number one US handset spot from Motorola, and Nokia’s sales in the US almost halved in value compared to the first quarter of 2007, with its market share in the world’s third largest market down from 20% at the start of 2006, to 7% now). Of course, the weakness of the US dollar against the euro is only worsening the trans-Atlantic situation for Nokia, but the situation is worrying for the company’s continuing ability to maintain a healthy balance between unit growth and resilient margin. Almost 75% of its shipments in Q1 were to India and China, with the latter up 30% year-on-year, but such patterns need to be balanced by stronger growth in smartphones and high value markets like the US – particularly with the US carriers poised to start to invest in new 3G and 4G networks, which could give Nokia the foot in the door it requires as the dominance of CDMA, where it hardly plays, wanes.

In other respects, though, it had a sterling quarter, with revenues up 28% year-on-year to $20bn, and net income up 25% to $1.9bn despite continuing difficulties at the Nokia Siemens infrastructure joint venture ‘ whose figures are consolidated and reported by Nokia; rising competitive and recessionary pressures in all its activities; and the fact that its hope for new high value revenue streams, internet services, are at too early a stage to have tangible impact on quarterly results (a situation unlikely to change for a couple of years, at least). So far, the margin squeeze that has afflicted most handset makers, even the until-recently immune Sony Ericsson, is not rearing its ugly head at Nokia. Operating margins in handsets were 20% in Q1, up from 15% in the easier climate of a year earlier, while operating profit in the newly reorganized ‘devices and services’ divisions was up 50% year-on-year. However, company-wide, there was a drop in operating margin, largely down to Nokia Siemens and some other factors, with the figure down from 12.9% in 2007 to 12.1%.

However, shares fell more than 13% in value to $28.95 because of fears about falling handset prices. Nokia shipped 115.5m handsets in the first quarter, which gave it 39% global share ‘ up from 36% at the same time in 2007, though short of the 40% it achieved for 2007 as a whole, and a magic figure that analysts had hoped to see repeated in each quarter of this year (Nokia is still forecasting 40% for the full year.) Smartphones seem to have been the main culprit in this, reinforcing fears that the ‘credit crunch’ is squeezing consumer spending in developed markets, and will force Nokia to rely more heavily than it had planned in 2008 on low end models and growth in developing economies where growth is high and boom/slump cycles different, but margins are low.

All this means the company is still looking for an industry-wide increase in sales of cellphones of 10% this year, but with much of that growth coming from low cost markets, and so leading to a decline in the euro value of the handset market as a whole. It said that its change in outlook ‘primarily reflects the negative impact of the recently weakened US dollar, the general economic slowdown in the US, and possibly going forward some economic slowdown in Europe’. CFO Rick Simonson said on the analyst call that 50% of Nokia’s sales were in dollars or dollar-linked. ‘There is growth in this market in volume and value if you knock out this crazy currency,’ he said.

With average selling prices (ASPs) falling in midrange and low end handset categories, and high end smartphones apparently under pressure, Nokia’s great challenge will be to harness its super-efficient supply chain and massive purchasing power, and even enhance this through new partnerships, in order to preserve its margins even in a world of lower ASPs. Carolina Milanesi, an analyst at Gartner Group, commented: ‘Falling revenues will put more strain on handset vendors. They will have to focus on making low end devices at a profit and this is not easy. Only Nokia seems to be able to do it at the moment. Samsung has been talking about low end products but it takes time to learn to cater to this market.’

This, because of its scale and logistical excellence, is the one area ‘ unlike design, brand, carrier loyalty or technical advances, all of which are subject to leapfrog by others ‘ where Nokia does have a unique advantage, and a gap which its rivals show no signs of being able to narrow.

Nokia Siemens Networks:

Nokia Siemens Networks, the infrastructure joint venture, finished its first year as a merged entity on a down note, reverting to a loss in Q1, after the fourth quarter turned an operating profit that investors hoped was a sign of sustainable turnaround.

In Q1 of 2008, NSN reported revenues of €3.4bn ($5.37bn), down 26% on the fourth quarter of 2007, with gross margins of 28.2% and an operating loss of €74m ($117m). However, before one-off costs, including items associated with the formation of NSN on April 1 2007, operating margin was 2.4%, rather than the 2.2% negative it reported.

And there seems to be greater confidence in NSN from its parents than there was during its turbulent first two quarters of life, when Siemens was widely rumored to be considering an early exit and Nokia was less than publicly supportive. This time, Nokia CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo said during the earnings conference call with analysts: ‘Progress has been difficult but steady in the first 12 months of operations. The first quarter saw effective cost control and good progress in key markets and product segments including a stronger than expected performance in China, especially in the services sector. NSN has been running its business well in an extremely challenging market.’

He admitted that the companies had underestimated how tough the market would be for NSN in its first year, and that more radical cost cutting should have been initiated more quickly, but he insisted that, despite the setbacks, the first quarter was broadly ‘encouraging’. However, Nokia changed its outlook for the network infrastructure market to flat in Euro terms in 2008, down from its previous view of ‘very slight growth’.