Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2015

Nokia signs LG in first post-handset IPR deal, but no royalties agreement

Nokia has signed its first major patent licensing agreement since selling off its handset division, with LG, though the companies have failed to agree on royalty rates.

The Korean handset maker will pay royalties to Nokia for use of its mobile communications IPR, but the firms will have to seek arbitration to determine the appropriate fees. Nokia and Samsung went through the same process when the larger Korean company renewed a licensing agreement with its then-rival in 2013. Nokia and LG said the process could take 1-2 years, but in the meantime, LG will have the right to use Nokia’s technologies.

This two-step process may become increasingly common in the mobile industry, where the issue of royalty levels has become an intensely debated one. For instance, Ericsson offered to take its dispute with Apple over patent licensing to arbitration, in order to establish an independent view of appropriate royalties for its key IPR (Apple refused and their litigation continues).

There are calls for a complete overhaul of the licensing system, especially for standards-essential patents (SEP), in a market where price competition is forcing firms to cut the cost of producing devices but royalty burdens are often rising. Several major holders of SEP, such as Samsung (though not Nokia) have come under scrutiny, amid fears that the Frand (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) guidelines for licensing essential patents are not being followed, to the detriment of fair competition.

Nokia is behaving characteristically by preferring arbitration to litigation in settling the matter with major licensees (though when pushed, it can be powerful in the law courts, as its victory over Apple showed). However, some speculate that the failure to agree terms with LG means the company is being more aggressive in how it prices its patents. And of course, it no longer has to license many of LG’s patents in return, since it no longer makes handsets.

This means Nokia will have greater freedom to exploit its huge store of patents. When it was the market leader in handsets, its IPR was largely a trading counter, to exchange with other patent owners and reduce its royalties burden. Now the IPR can be turned into pure revenue.

Nokia has about 30,000 patents related to 2G, 3G, 4G and surrounding technologies, and over 60 licensing deals. It currently makes around €500m a year from patents, but it wants to increase that sum significantly. Although Microsoft paid $2.2bn to access this IPR portfolio, as part of its purchase of the Finnish firm’s devices business, Nokia hung on to ownership of virtually all its patents. These are sufficiently numerous and fundamental to make it a continuing power behing the scenes of the smartphone industry – especially as it continues to invest in R&D, which will turn into further IPR even as older patents, such as many related to GSM, expire.

When it made the momentous decision to exit the cellphone business that it once ruled, it clearly indicated that it would continue to develop mobile device technologies in order to expand its IPR and technology licensing businesses.

Despite recent staff reductions in the Advanced Technologies unit (which houses IPR, licensing and R&D), it has made decisive moves to boost revenues from its many inventions, past and current. It licensed its brand and a reference design to Foxconn to power the N1 tablet (and could re-enter the smartphone space, by the back door, in the same way, once non-compete clauses with Microsoft expire). The division recently hired former Dolby Labs executive Ramzi Haidamus as its president and Cisco executive Guido Jouret as CTO, with the clear aim of redoubling its efforts to capitalise on its broad and deep portfolio. In the wake of the agreement to acquire Alcatel-Lucent – also a patent powerhouse thanks to its Bell Labs subsidiary – Nokia said that the licensing unit “will stay as a separate entity with a clear focus on incubating new technologies and sharing those technologies through an active licensing program.”

The Finnish firm’s new freedom to exploit its innovations independently of any actual products has raised fears that it will cross the line into being a ‘troll’ – a company which extracts fees for patented inventions without ever applying them to commercial offerings. The former European competition commissioner, Joaquin Almunia, after the Microsoft deal, warned Nokia not to “behave like a patent troll, or to use a more polite phrase, a patent assertion entity”. He added: “If Nokia were to take illegal advantage of its patents in the future, we will open an antitrust case … but I sincerely hope we will not have to.”

However, although Nokia has embarked on a few patent lawsuits, notably against HTC and BlackBerry, it has mainly stuck to its old non-litigious ways. In response to Almunia’s comments last year, Nokia’s then-CTO Henry Tirri said in an interview that just milking the existing portfolio was “not a very sustainable, or a very wise, business. Yes, we have a young patent portfolio, so for next 10 years, we can utilize two-thirds of patents, but still, it’s not a sustainable business. I don’t envision us buying patents and then selling them.”

The CTO Office is at the heart of the Advanced Technologies unit, and traditionally contributes about two-thirds of the intellectual property that Nokia generates each year. Much of its R&D focus will still be on traditional Nokia strengths, notably radio technologies, and some of the projects will feed into Nokia Networks.

Executives talk of turning Advanced Technologies from the rather academic research unit of the current structure into an innovation and IPR powerhouse more like Bell Labs. ALU itself has recently been reorganizing its R&D to harness Bell Labs’ research more directly and to relate R&D to product roadmaps.

But Advanced Technologies will not be all about NSN and mobile networks, but will also look to projects that could create new areas of business for the handset-less Finnish firm. According to Nokia, sensor technologies, imaging, audio and cloud are all on the agenda as the firm looks for a role in the internet of things and contextual computing.