Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2008

Nokia wins Orange for web services, but not for the full Ovi offering

When Nokia first announced its intention to turn itself into an internet services company last year, and launched its Ovi portal and multimedia applications to support this, the main fly in the ointment seemed to be carrier hostility to a brand that competed with their own web efforts. The handset giant is hard for even the largest operator to ignore, however, and one by one the major European cellcos that are its heartland base are coming round to supporting Nokia branded applications ‘ but generally in a less wholehearted way than the Finn would have liked.

Orange, which was initially very hostile to Ovi and seemed set to blacklist Nokia phones associated with its music service, has now expanded its content deal with the phonemaker, but has stopped well short of embracing Ovi. Vodafone has adopted a two-tier strategy for key services like music, targeting Nokia branded mediaphones at the high end and its own Live! services at the midrange ‘ with the option to access both from the front screen. Telefonica has a similar deal, but T-Mobile and Orange are picking off certain services where Nokia has strong differentiation over their own offerings or those of internet players like Google or MySpace. This enables them to keep the phonemaker onside, without having to adopt the whole Ovi portal.

While T-Mobile focused on social networking, to enhance what has proved a strong element of its Web ‘n’ Walk mobile internet platform, Orange’s main interests are in mapping and games. Both of these are important elements of the Ovi suite, along with music and social networking, but Orange has excluded those two, sticking to its hostile stance against Nokia MusicStore. The maps and gaming will be available to Orange customers, on special Nokia handsets, in nine European countries from later this year. The target is to get 10m Orange customers using Nokia mobile maps by 2010. Orange will share revenue with Nokia and the agreement will see the maps co-branded with the operator’s name.

THIs seems a fair compromise, but from the point of view of Ovi, the Nokia brand is underplayed. On games, the two companies will offer their own games under their own brands, not under the Ngage games brand umbrella used for Ovi. And the 10 new Nokia handsets that will be offered in the second half of the year to support the new offerings will provide on-click access to Orange’s music store, not Nokia’s. While many operators do not restrict the sites and services to which users can go via the browser, the key to uptake of certain content, especially on small screens and among non-technical bases, is the one-click route from the front screen, so the omission of Nokia MusicStore is significant, and shows the level of compromise that the phonemaker is having to make to ensure a premium position for its important and high margin mediaphones in the tier one carrier’s portfolios.

Nokia said last week that it had invested ‘hundreds of millions of euros’ in its internet services strategy, and expected to see a return on that from 2010. But while a lot of compromise is necessary in the first phase, in order not to alienate operators, if it achieves the level of success necessary to report that ROI within two years, at that point it will be able to take a harder line. This is what the cellcos, trying to establish their own internet services businesses and brands ‘ and gain strong negotiation positions when sorting out the revenue share with device and content vendors ‘ fear. Even though T-Mobile has signed a fairly wide ranging deal with Nokia for Europe, CEO Hamid Akhavan told Reuters last week, echoing previous comments: “My life would be simpler if they would have not come to my space. It is still not the happiest thing to have someone try and take your cheese away.”