Nokia will is becoming a familiar face at the US International Trade Commission (ITC), where it faces challenges from Qualcomm and long time patents bugbear InterDigital, newly flush from a licensing deal with Apple. Hearings in the former case have already started, while the latter is only at the investigation stage, but both reflect Nokia’s determination to set new rules for the handset IPR industry by playing tough in the renegotiation of its technology licenses, as these come up for renewal. Meanwhile, as the current wave of IPR-related legal activity in the handset sector gathers pace, Qualcomm has gained some relief from the import ban that resulted from its last ITC case, brought by Broadcom, and has also gained some breathing space in Europe-based disputes with Nokia.
Just days after it announced that it was suing Nokia for allegedly infringing two of its patents in the N75 handset, wireless IPR company InterDigital saw its shares surge nearly 14% on news of a licensing deal with Apple for current and future iPhone models. This is apparently worth about $20m plus ongoing royalties over seven years, backdated to the iPhone launch, and intensified speculation that Apple would bring out a 3G version of the handset before Christmas – almost essential if it is to have the same impact with its European launches as it has had in the US (see separate item). InterDigital also revised its guidance for the coming quarter’s licensing revenues up by $2m, to a range of $55.5m to $56.5m.
InterDigital will, of course, have to wait a lot longer for any developments in its latest battle with Nokia, but last week the ITC did say it had initiated a 45-day investigation into whether certain Nokia handsets should be banned from import to the US because they violate InterDigital patents.
Despite the Apple boost, the risk of taking on Nokia, plus other factors including its latest chip launch, make InterDigital’s short term prospects uncertain. In its second quarter, InterDigital upset investors by announcing a dip in its recurring licensing revenue, so the Apple deal will be particularly welcome. In quarterly revenue of $55m in the most recent quarter, $52.6m came from royalties connected to the company’s large portfolio of 2G and 3G wireless patents. This had fallen year-on-year from $54.9m, largely because there were no payments from Ericsson or Sony Ericsson this time around (their previous deal expired at the end of 2006). Higher expenses contributed to a net loss of $4.4m and a negative free cashflow of $2.5m, raising more doubts over InterDigital’s high risk plan to move into the HSxPA chip market in its own right with the planned launch of its ASIC platform this fall. This launch will boost expenses in the current quarter by 5-10%, said ADI, while it also expects litigation costs to rise from the $9.9m level of Q2. However, InterDigital will feel justified in taking on Nokia again ‘ last time it won a suit over 2G patents and gained a payment of $253m in April 2006. However, its 3G deal with Nokia expired at the end of that year and is now the subject of the latest legal battles.
This shows Nokia pursuing the same line as it has with Qualcomm, with which it has also failed to come to terms on renewal of a licensing deal, which expired in April. The Finnish giant, seeking to reduce its costs and increase its own control over wireless standards, is arguing that the value of its own patent portfolio has increased dramatically since most of its licensing agreements were negotiated last time around ‘ and so it should gain far better cross-licensing terms in 2007. So vital is this claim to Nokia’s strategy to tighten its stranglehold on the handset sector that it is clearly prepared to take expensive court action and, especially in the Qualcomm case, to push brinkmanship to its limit.
Hearings related to that battle, which will set important precedents for the whole handset sector, are now underway or imminent in various locations. Last Monday, the ITC started to hear testimony in a case brought by Qualcomm against Nokia ‘ one of a series of tit-for-tat actions – and will continue until September 24. Iin Germany, a court stayed a similar infringement case brought by Nokia. The District Court of D’sseldorf ordered a stay of proceedings until further notice based on a request by Qualcomm, Nokia said.
At issue in the ITC hearing are three patents related to power control in EDGE and GPRS (initially, Qualcomm’s ITC complaint included six patents, with one declared as essential to the standards, but the chip giant subsequently withdrew the essentiality claim and reduced the number of patents to three). Qualcomm has presented its case and Nokia will respond this week, arguing that it has not infringed the patents and that they are invalid anyway. A ruling is expected by next March. In August, Nokia also asked the ITC to launch a separate probe into alleged violations of its IPR by Qualcomm, concerning five 3G patents, and demanded an import ban similar to that imposed by the body after Qualcomm lost a patent dispute with Broadcom.
However, in this case – which has led Verizon Wireless, the largest CDMA carrier, to negotiate directly with Broadcom in order to safeguard handset supplies ‘ Qualcomm won some rare respite last week. A federal judge granted a stay on the import ban, pending appeal, that will allow third parties to import handsets into the US. These third parties – Kyocera Wireless, Motorola, Samsung, Sanyo, T-Mobile, LG Electronics and AT&T Mobility ‘argued successfully that, since Broadcom only filed its complaint against Qualcomm, the ITC did not have the power to block the imports by companies beside Qualcomm. This was upheld by Judge Haldane Mayer of the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, a decision that, if not overturned, dramatically takes the sting out of the anti-Qualcomm judgement, even though it will place the chipmaker in a weaker negotiating position with its handset customers than it is accustomed to. The stay applies only to those third parties that filed motions, a list that does not, interestingly enough, include Sprint Nextel, the second largest CDMA carrier. In contrast to Verizon Wireless, Sprint has been trying to free itself of the Broadcom issue altogether by developing a workaround for the patents at issue (see Wireless Watch August 13 2007).
The Federal Circuit will now turn to reviewing the merits of the ITC infringement finding and the ban, which Qualcomm has appealed. Analysts welcomed the latest decision, with Mark McKechnie at American Technology Research echoing the views of many in a research note, in which he wrote that the federal court’s ruling increased confidence in his earnings projections for Qualcomm’s next quarter, which had assumed no material impact to earnings from the ban.
The ruling complicates further the issue of how carriers and handset makers split licensing costs, whether directly or indirectly ‘ as does the direct patent deal struck between Verizon Wireless and Broadcom many sources assume AT&T has something similar, though not made public). This contentious issue, and the accusations that Qualcomm indulges in ‘double-dipping’, or charging both parties for the same IPR, lie at the heart of another Nokia case, this one in the Netherlands. Last Friday the handset giant told a Dutch court that it is not infringing Qualcomm patents because its chip supplier, Texas Instruments, has already paid to license the technologies. Nokia’s lawyer Wouter Pors told a court in The Hague that the US company was “fighting a war against Nokia’ and that “Nokia does not need an agreement with Qualcomm because those rights have been exhausted in [Qualcomm’s] agreement with Texas Instruments.’ He argued that Qualcomm was abusing its market position by demanding payments both from chipmakers and their clients. Qualcomm lawyer Bart van den Broek said the US company had the right to seek payments from TI’s clients and that there was no “exhaustion” of patent rights when Nokia used TI chips.
McKechnie said in his investor note that he remains confident of Qualcomm’s long term patent position, but believes three upcoming events, in particular, will help to clarify the situation and reduce shareholder uncertainty. These are: the remedy phase of a district court trial in Santa Ana, California, where Qualcomm lost a ruling to Broadcom over video compression technology; the outcome of Qualcomm’s appeal against the ban on import of 3G handsets using its chips; and news from the American Arbitration Association’s involvement in the cross-licensing dispute between Qualcomm and Nokia.