We know from endless US courtroom dramas how dangerous it is for a lawyer to open up a new line of questioning without being aware of all the potential answers. It seems Qualcomm may have made that mistake in its own legal dealings, extending its licensing disputes with Nokia, Broadcom and others aggressively beyond pure CDMA patents where its position is pretty safe, to lay claims in H.264 video, GSM and other technologies where its role is less clear. The focus on H.264 was one of the factors that led to the CDMA giant’s mainly negative experience with the US International Trade Commission last week, which led to a ban on import of new cellphones. And having taken its ongoing dispute with Nokia far beyond CDMA, with lawsuits over GSM and other platforms the Finnish giant regards as its own, Nokia has bitten back, extending its own countersuits to cover two of Qualcomm’s key growth technologies, MediaFLO and Brew, in an action that carries far greater medium term threat than the ITC decision. Specifically, it said that Qualcomm has illegally used six of Nokia’s technology patents in its Brew and MediaFlo products.
The ITC ruling, though a blow to Qualcomm, was not unexpected and could actually have been harder on the chipmaker. It will also be subject to numerous appeals, in which Qualcomm will have powerful support from its mobile allies, and could well end up having little real impact beyond the psychological one – another signal that the CDMA leader needs to rethink its licensing models in the near future if it is not to waste vast amounts of energy and money on constant legal wrangling. By contrast, the Nokia actions, if they achieve any measure of success, strike at activities that represent Qualcomm’s future, not its past – its chance to grow into new markets and applications, based around software and multimedia, and one of the factors that keep its stock value consistently high despite its legal tribulations.
The ITC judgement in the case brought last year by Broadcom was certainly the most serious setback so far in the two companies’ ongoing battle. Most of their disputes have now been settled out of court, though Broadcom has also scored several recent victories (see Wireless Watch June 4 2007). But the ITC decided to ban the import of future models of 3G handsets using chipsets and software that infringe a Broadcom patent. Though it did not seek to prevent sales of current models, and Qualcomm claims already to have a workaround for the patent in question, the ruling sets a dangerous precedent and the chip giant is preparing to take the matter all the way to seek a White House veto, if necessary. It immediately said it would seek both an emergency stay of the order from the US Circuit Court of Appeals and a presidential veto. Relief from the court of appeals could come within days or weeks, according to Qualcomm’s general counsel, Lou Lupin. The US Trade Representative, invested by the president to intervene in such cases, has 60 days from June 7 to issue such a veto.
The ruling means all new devices launched after June 7 2007 that use Qualcomm’s chipsets will be banned from being imported into the US. If the promised workaround is delayed and Qualcomm fails to gain a stay of execution from President Bush or other sources, this would create a major issue for handset suppliers using the company’s silicon, in particular Samsung and LG. Since there is no credible alternative source of CDMA2000 chips, this would also impact heavily on the CDMA carriers in the US, Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel and Alltel – and would be a welcome boost for UMTS-based AT&T Mobility as it prepares to redouble its market share efforts on the back of its much touted iPhone launch. Sprint Nextel, Verizon Wireless and LG all rallied behind Qualcomm at once, claiming that the ban would severely disrupt the flow of 3G phones in the US, crippling their newly launched data services.
The handset makers and carriers will bring their immense lobbying power to bear rapidly, and this may prove hard for the president to resist, with Qualcomm skilfully playing up the potential damage to the US national wireless industry and, even more sensitive for this president, to public safety systems based around CDMA.
Even with a presidential veto, Qualcomm is under increasing pressure to compromise and license patents from key rivals like Broadcom. It might ride out the Broadcom/ITC dispute, on the basis that it has far greater influence over powerful groups like the carriers, and far more money to buy justice, than its challenger, which is a newcomer in cellular systems. But Nokia is another matter, and as it expands its actions to cover most of Qualcomm’s key technologies, even the world’s most cocksure chipmaker must start to believe it would be easier and more profitable to make common cause with a compromise deal. Nokia, after all, has even more influence on the wireless industry and its various lobbying groups than Qualcomm and can command far more powerful support for its case than Broadcom can. Adding MediaFLO and Brew to the mix may prove Nokia’s master stroke.
The danger for Qualcomm lies in the combination of the two actions. Like Napoleon, it is being forced, partly as a result of its own audacity, to fight on two major fronts. Those fronts may or may not be deliberately coordinating their actions on either side of the Atlantic, but their actions are certainly more threatening together than alone. The ITC decision and Nokia’s expanded countersuits are both dangerous, but will involve long periods of legal wrangling before they have a real impact on Qualcomm – and while that goes on, there is still plenty of upside. One impact of Nokia’s actions on MediaFLO and Brew is, at a stroke, to cast doubt over that upside. When the ITC announced its decision, Qualcomm shares actually rose slightly – because the judgement could have been even harsher, and because it is increasingly clear that, whatever the future of its CDMA royalties revenues, the chipmaker has important growth opportunities through its new technologies, which are geared to significant boom sectors and are not CDMA-dependent. Chief among these are MediaFLO for mobile television and the Brew software platform, on which key products like UIone for mobile internet interfaces are based. By striking at the heart of high potential technologies that many see as Qualcomm’s crown jewels in the move to a multimedia world, Nokia is doing as much damage to confidence in its rival as with its more conventional attacks on its licensing structures and royalty rates.
While many companies are dependent on Qualcomm in CDMA chips, in its software businesses it has few powerful friends. Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility are both set to use MediaFLO for their mobile television services, but are more likely to pressurize Qualcomm to sort the issue out quickly so as not to delay their launches, than to lobby on its behalf.
As always, Nokia is playing a two-tiered game with Qualcomm. The first objective of its legal actions is the short term, and financially critical, one of reducing its own royalty payments in order to improve its cost base, especially in emerging markets. To do this, normal negotiation having failed, it clearly aims to step up the legal pressure on its antagonist until the CDMA giant breaks. In itself, any compromise that appears to favor Nokia will have huge significance, as it will set the precedent for the whole handset industry.
But the Finnish giant always has an eye on the longer term too, and particularly on the position it wants to carve out for itself in the mobile internet future, one that will revolve more around multimedia, user interfaces and applications architectures than around hardware. This is a strategic area where it is already facing a challenge from Qualcomm, especially as the chipmaker brings its various technologies out from the CDMA corral and into the broader world of UMTS/HSPA and OFDMA. Qualcomm’s Brew and UIone software platforms have the potential to compete head-on with Nokia’s would-be de facto standards such as Series 60 and Widsets, the cornerstones of its bid to become a mobile internet company as well as a handset maker, and to sideline Microsoft into the bargain. And in mobile television, which both companies also see as critical to growth, the heavily Nokia-backed DVB-H standard has lost some key battles to MediaFLO, notably in the US, where DVB-H may well be shut out of major operators altogether.
So anything Nokia can do now to improve its own position in mobile internet and weaken Qualcomm’s will be, for its investors, a welcome side-effect of the legal battle with Qualcomm, and one reason why it must have chosen to add these two technologies to the battle. This is especially true of Brew. Nokia will almost certainly have to incorporate MediaFLO into future handsets to address the US market, and so will be keen to ensure royalty rates are low – although Qualcomm includes most technologies into a single license, we can be sure the companies are haggling over each element individually too. But Nokia has no need to use Brew itself. It will clearly rely on its own software technologies, especially since it quit the CDMA phone sector. So the Brew debate goes far beyond simple royalty haggling.
Nokia launched its first countersuit against Qualcomm a week earlier, going on the offensive after tough negotiations stalemated and the companies’ existing licensing deal expired on April 9. The Finnish company filed a counterclaim against an April suit by Qualcomm in the Western District of Wisconsin, asserting that Qualcomm has been using Nokia IPR in its chipsets and making those chipsets available to other handset customers. Specifically, Nokia says that Qualcomm is infringing on six implementation patents that are being used in Qualcomm GSM/W-CDMA and CDMA2000 chipsets. The phonemaker is seeking damages and an injunction. The implementation patents relate primarily to multiband/multimode technologies, and direct conversion technologies that reduce handset and chipset size, cost and power consumption (see Wireless Watch June 4 2007).
Now six further patents, related to Brew and MediaFLO, have been added, in response to an earlier lawsuit filed by Qualcomm in the Eastern District of Texas on April 2. This accused Nokia of infringing three Qualcomm patents, which Nokia claims are invalid. “This is another example where Qualcomm has effectively copied Nokia’s innovations. We believe that, for MediaFlo to evolve and for Brew to remain viable, Qualcomm needs access to these and many other patented Nokia inventions,” said Nokia’s CTO Tero Ojanpera, in a statement.
Qualcomm’s European president, Andrew Gilbert, retorted: “Nokia might try and paint a picture that it’s about the evolution of the industry, but it’s more to do with them trying to maintain their 40% to 50% margins on handsets and stifle competition in the industry. We will continue to fight for a model that we believe gives greater competition in the market.”
Whatever the rights and wrongs of that model, it seems its days must be numbered. Even a company with Qualcomm’s powerful friends, engineering excellence and sheer aggression must eventually bow to the weight of opposition that it being heaped upon it. At this stage, we have hardly seen any movement from Ericsson, but that surely cannot be far away if the Nokia and Broadcom efforts appear to be stalling, especially since Ericsson was a prime mover in the bid to launch a European Commission investigation into Qualcomm’s business practises. Time will be important to the chipmaker, to sort out workarounds and bring new products and revenue streams to market that could offset reductions in royalties and even a possible spin-off of the IPR business. But while it cannot suffer sudden IPR death in CDMA-related systems – its patents are too well proven and too essential, and the companies that depend on its chips too strong – it is far more exposed in the newer technologies. Here, it has not established clear market share and so is still at risk of being pushed aside by other contenders such as DVB-H in the mobile TV space. Therefore, it does not have the ecosystem in place that will rise to its defense in a tight spot. Yet such platforms are essential to Qualcomm if it is to continue its growth in revenues and value even after its CDMA technologies start to become less significant in the total wireless picture. Now that Nokia and Qualcomm itself have opened up the questioning to these new technologies, it really is time for the chip giant to find a settlement, and quickly.
Sagem:
Qualcomm’s latest licensing agreement is with French handset maker Sagem Communications, which signed a royalty-bearing agreement to make and sell W-CDMA handsets worldwide at the chipmaker’s ‘standard rate”.
Sagem, the mobile phone arm of French Safran Group, has revived its fortunes this year after speculation that Motorola might acquire it. In March, Sony Ericsson said it would employ Sagem as an original device manufacturer for GSM, GPRS and EDGE-based phones for emerging markets. In April, Sagem and Vodafone signed a deal for an ‘extra slim’ Vodafone-brandedGSM handset for worldwide markets, due on the market this month.