Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 August 2007

Nortel signs new university partners for 4G efforts

Nortel is seeking to turn around its fortunes by gaining a headstart in emerging fourth generation technologies, and has announced some major collaborations with universities to boost its chances.

The Canadian company has adopted the high risk strategy of dropping out of UMTS but trying to leapfrog the big three wireless equipment makers in all the next generation platforms ‘ WiMAX, LTE and UltraMobileBroadband (UMB). It has put considerable R&D effort into technologies that are common to all these, such as OFDMA and MIMO, and also into mesh networking and combining pre-4G systems with Wi-Fi. But this approach carries high R&D costs, and the risk of losing its visibility with clients and supply chain partners, because of its exit from UMTS. It also has the disadvantage of being strongest in CDMA, whose 4G path ‘ UMB ‘ is the least certain, of the three candidates, to become a commercial reality.

With all these risks, Nortel is, in the short term, very dependent for growth on its expanding unified communications and enterprise businesses, and its partnership in those areas with Microsoft. But with little strategic position in the current 3G upgrade cycles, the company also really needs its 4G plans to work out, or it could lose its place in the wireless infrastructure sector, or be forced to sell up to one of the big three (Ericsson, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens) or even one of the Asian challengers.

The risks mainly lie in confidence, in the wake of Nortel’s financial scandals and its exit from UMTS, and in whether the company has the scale to compete and lead, when its rivals are consolidating and throwing huge resources at WiMAX and LTE, in particular. On the technology side, Nortel has plenty of assets and genuine competitive advantage, and it is looking to reinforce that by building an extensive ecosystem (see Wireless Watch May 21 2007), and teaming up with advanced research teams round the world.

The latest is an international group of universities, with which Nortel will work to develop technologies for 4G mobile broadband. It is expanding existing research partnerships with the University of Waterloo in Canada, The University of Texas at Austin in the US, and National Taiwan University (NTU), and has formed a new alliance
with the Technische Universitaet Ilmenau in Germany.

“Nortel’s investigations with these universities are designed to improve spectral efficiency, and decrease time to market for Nortel’s 4G mobile broadband solutions,” the company said, and will focus on all three pre-4G systems.

In particular, Nortel is working with the Coding and Signal Transmission group of the University of Waterloo on advanced multiuser transmission techniques; and with the Austin facility on MIMO-OFDM, and on using multiuser MIMO technologies and relay links to extend the coverage of base stations. The goal is to blanket an area with small, relay access nodes.

Ina Taiwn, the main focus is on multimedia videoconferencing over WiMAX with voice, video, internet messaging and location-based applications.

Nortel is also working with Mera Networks, a Russian telecoms R&D services provider, and Technische Universitaet Ilmenau, to develop advanced combinations of spatial processing and MIMO, in order to increase capacity up to fourfold, by reusing spectrum resources.

More executives leave:

Another senior executive has left Nortel, bringing the total since late 2006 to six. Nikos Theodosopoulos, an analyst at UBS, used the departure of John Haydon, head of network partner solutions, to reiterate a ‘neutral’ rating on the stock, despite some improvements such as better gross margins. The analyst said in a research note that he is also concerned by Nortel’s ‘disappointing EBIT performance, a tough competitive environment, and lack of clarity on a normalized business model. The need and/or desire on Nortel’s part for M&A to accelerate growth/gain scale in a tightening credit environment pose further challenges,’ he wrote.

He sees the loss of Haydon as ‘marginally negative for Nortel, particularly from a sentiment perspective’ and ‘not an encouraging sign for a company in the midst of a critical transformation.’

The other five executives who have left in the past 10 months are chief ethics officer Susan Shepard, chief financial officer Peter Currie, North America president Dion Joannou, VP of investor relations Terry Glofcheskie and Martha Bejar, the company’s president for the CALA region. However, the company maintains that the departures will not slow its recovery plan and points to the hiring of new ‘world class executives from companies such as GE, IBM, Juniper, Bell, Lenovo’.