While the headlines may like to focus on the potential conflict between 3G and 802.16e, much of the real world operator and vendor effort is focused on enabling them to complement each other to support a variety of next generation business models more effectively. This means that whether the two technologies end up competing or combining will be influenced more by the commitments of individual operators in a market, than by technical or performance factors per se. In a location with one or more strong start-ups ‘ or a major wireline-only telco such as BT – there may be a realistic WiMAX challenge to the incumbent 3G carrier, as we are seeing in Australasia. Other 3G players may seek to sew up control of the market by co-opting WiMAX for themselves, to enhance their own offerings or move more quickly into new markets. In many cases this will be the policy of a converged operator looking to deliver advanced enterprise and consumer triple play bundles over multiple networks unified by IP ‘ Japan’s KDDI is a good example. Some cellular-only operators, even now including one of the largest 3G backers, Vodafone, may also look to 802.16e to enhance their reach and to take them into the indoor sector. In this patchwork, then, W-CDMA and 802.16e can either compete or work together ‘ and in some markets will do both, where there are multiple operators adopting WiMAX in different ways. Undoubtedly, however, the most complex choices face the broadband telcos with powerful cellular arms ‘ adopting WiMAX must be done very skilfully and applications targeted very precisely, to prevent a plan that could, for instance, add wireless capabilities to the core DSL base, also cannibalizing valuable 3G wireless revenue. This dilemma has already been seen in Korea, with SKT far less enthusiastic about using its 2.3GHz Wi-Bro license for mobile broadband services because of the strength its position in 3G ‘ but being forced to do so to prevent Korea Telecom having the Wi-Bro market to itself. And the issue is even more challenging for Japanese incumbent NTT, whose cellular arm DoCoMo has been the loudest cheerleader for W-CDMA and its future evolutions, but which is now experiencing tougher financial times, forcing its parent to look to a multi-network future that will include WiMAX.
It is hard to believe that the names NTT and WiMAX are being said in the same breath, but the parent telco will start to trial the emerging technology next month. There will be a skilful balancing act required to marry these trials, if successful, with DoCoMo’s leading edge work on enhancing the performance and indoor penetration of W-CDMA, with the aim of making it a true broadband platform capable of supporting fixed/mobile convergence. The W-CDMA LTE or Super3G initiative, spearheaded by DoCoMo with Vodafone and various vendors, looks to create a ‘3.9G’ standard, or a step to 4G, that could deliver 100Mbps by 2008.
DoCoMo has been very independent of its parent but recently, its financial performance has been suffering and it has been criticized for haphazard international expansion strategies. Last month DoCoMo announced a poor set of figures for the nine months to December 31, with pre-tax profits down 35.1% year-on-year to ‘811.2 bn ($6.9 bn), and net income down by 31.7% to ‘516.4 bn ($4.4 bn). The giant cellco also suffered a 1.7% year-on-year decrease in operating revenue to ‘3,582.2 bn ($30.5 bn) for the nine months, though it had slowed its ARPU decline.
All this means there may be moves to bring it more closely into the NTT fold, especially with the trend towards fixed/mobile convergence across wireline and wireless infrastructure. Any such initiative at NTT would almost certainly create massive internal conflict over how R&D resources should be spread over the various networks, including possibly WiMAX.
DoCoMo will take part in the WiMAX trial, and its parent is likely to be pressurizing it to emulate Vodafone and take a more flexible view of future infrastructure choices, looking beyond just W-CDMA. NTT is currently reorganising its internet services, including ADSL and Wi-Fi, under a single company called NTT Broadband Platform, and will take some infrastructure currently operated by DoCoMo, by the long distance and internet operator NTT Communications and by the NTT East and NTT West local carriers, creating a single platform from which all units can offer services. This will be the physical underpinning for a converged all-IP network and should support next generation multimedia fixed/mobile services as well as reducing operating costs.
Somewhat reflecting rival KDDI’s ‘Ultra3G’ strategy for its next wave network, which will deliver high bandwidth broadband services over WiMAX or DSL while retaining CDMA2000 for most voice and mobile applications, NTT Group announced its ‘Medium Term Management Strategy’ roadmap in November 2004, with ubiquitous broadband being the key goal.
In this roadmap document, NTT says: ‘Our intention is to build an open next generation network that a variety of players outside NTT Group can use to pioneer and develop a variety of services and business models. At the same time, we plan to actively move ahead with alliances with these players in a wide range of forms.’ It will open up its network interfaces to third parties to enhance the range of services that can be offered, and will migrate its backbone from ATM to IP. The group says in its roadmap that it will use optical access and broadband wireless access in its next generation network for communication between fixed and mobile handsets, for metrozone and rural services and for communication between eastern and western Japan. Key services, which are currently being trialled, will be ‘broadband internet access, IP telephony, multicast communication for video distribution, bidirectional video communications and ethernet services (largely replacing dedicated line services)’. The aim is to switch entirely to the new all-IP network by 2010 and to achieve seamless linkage with the mobile network through the deployment of mobile network edge nodes at the time of DoCoMo’s introduction of Super 3G.
The question for DoCoMo, of course, is how far key applications that it currently sees as the preserve of the Super3G portion of this picture ‘ such as mobile commerce ‘ will be better or more cheaply delivered using WiMAX access, and how far the group will start to see 802.16e, because of its IP nature, as an easier and cheaper mobile front end for the all-IP network than Super3G, at least for new applications. (KDDI has a less urgent problem here as it will implement CDMA2000 EV-DO Rev A and Rev B, which will support full IP, so its flexibility to mix and match its wireless platforms will be greater.) If 802.16e ‘ and it is early days to assume this of course ‘ takes a major role in NTT’s roadmap and its delivery of portable and broadband services, there could be a bitter battle for which unit within the group gains control of that portion of the network ‘ or whether a full restructuring of the giant company, to converge the various divisions, would be preferable.
NTT has the advantages but also the problems that being the market leader bring. For a second national player, especially one with a significant market gap or newly set up, WiMAX may prove a relatively quick way to gain ground. In South Africa, a second national operator will soon be licensed and will likely come to market late this year. Using WiMAX, with its good indoor penetration and high speeds, could enable the company to make up ground on the incumbent Telkom ‘ although Telkom itself has started to trial WiMAX as a possible way to extend its fixed broadband coverage and add mobile capabilities in future.
Australia and New Zealand are also seeing very advanced use of WiMAX-class technologies to challenge the incumbent telcos. Unwired Australia has been vociferous in its belief that it can present its pre-WiMAX based network, which uses Navini equipment in Sydney and will soon go live in Melbourne, to make significant inroads into the broadband and mobile business of Telstra. Telstra itself is steering clear of WiMAX, instead creating a roadmap that involves moving its varied mobile networks to W-CDMA only, and combining DSL with some Wi-Fi facilities.
Over in New Zealand, a similar pattern is seen, with a group of wireless ISPs looking to collaborate to create a combined WiMAX network to challenge New Zealand Telecom. The first members of this loose roaming and investment alliance are Nzwireless of Auckland, which has just started WiMAX trials; and Hawkes Bay company Airnet, which began deploying pre-WiMAX technology on its existing wireless network recently; and these may be joined by National Communications, which is also about to begin trialling WiMAX in Auckland; and CallPlus, now testing the technology in Northland. These operators hold regional 3.5GHz licenses and look to compete with NZ Telecom’s Jetstream DSL services on the basis of price, flexibility and speed.
Nzwireless aims to partner with enough 3.5GHz license holders around the country to create national coverage. “Telecom’s huge benefit is their nationwide coverage. We’ve got clients in Wellington and Auckland, but as soon as we get outside of that they don’t really have another option,’ said the WISP. ‘Obviously partnering with local wireless companies is the most effective way of broadening everyone’s reach’, and a national system would be possible within a year, aided by the adoption of consistent technology across all areas.
Wi-Lan exits equipment business, highlighting patents issue for WiMAX players
In a standards-based equipment market, volume is key to competitiveness, and smaller suppliers will only survive if they have significant intellectual property over and above the standard. The Wi-Fi market is in the process of consolidating and it will soon be WiMAX’ turn. We have already seen Proxim and Terabeam merging, and now Wi-Lan is staking its future entirely on its patents portfolio, and seeking an acquirer for its equipment business. With the certification process for 802.16-2004 fixed WiMAX kit speeding up, and mobile 802.16e on the horizon, this will certainly be the first of many upheavals in the once cosy world of broadband wireless vendors.
Canadian Wi-Lan has had one of the most tumultuous histories since the broadband wireless market started to converge on WiMAX. It has been in financial difficulties, and undergone a series of reorganizations, over the past two years, but has clung to its claims of significant intellectual property holdings in WiMAX and other OFDM technologies such as 5GHz Wi-Fi. Wi-Lan believes its portfolio of patents, including its core W-OFDM patents and 17 patents and patent applications acquired from now defunct WiMAX pioneer Ensemble Communications in May 2004, are necessary for the implementation of devices using the IEEE 802.16 and ETSI HiperMANas well as Wi-Fi variants 802.11a and 802.11g and ETSI HiperLAN/2.
These claims led it to take the bold move of suing Cisco, and it gained licensing agreements with its key technology partner, Fujitsu Microelectronics, with whom it codeveloped the Fujitsu WiMAX system on a chip.
However, despite some licensing wins, Wi-Lan did not succeed in gaining the Qualcomm-style universal recognition of its patents that it had hoped for. Indeed, it was widely rumored that Qualcomm was interested in acquiring Wi-Lan as part of its bid to assemble its own OFDM patent arsenal, but instead it opted for Flarion, a move that suggested to many that Wi-Lan’s IP was less attractive than the company had hoped.
Cisco did show some interest, and may still be Wi-Lan’s main salvation, as the networking giant seeks to flesh out its mobile IP and OFDM patents store in an intellectual property stand-off that looks increasingly likely with Qualcomm. In December Cisco came to a settlement with Wi-Lan, and licensed all the smaller company’s patents and, significantly, acquired some of them for itself, in the WiMAX and smart antenna areas. Like Qualcomm with the acquisition of Flarion, Cisco is building up its patent stores in key technology areas, and more of Wi-Lan’s intellectual property may also be snapped up.
Now the company plans to phase out its struggling equipment making arm and focus entirely on its patents ‘ a move that we can expect to see from other smaller vendors. Unless they can gain significant OEM partnerships ‘ as Alvarion has with Alcatel and others, and Airspan with Ericsson and Nortel ‘ these specialists may find it hard to compete with the giants. As it is, most of the current OEM deals are in the fixed WiMAX world, a relatively niche market for backhaul and traditional BWA, that is of limited interest to the giant vendors and so could continue to support growth for the niche players as the better economics of WiMAX kick in. Redline, for instance, has a strong track record in backhaul on which it will continue to build in the fixed WiMAX market.
In the 802.16e market, focused on consumer access, triple play and, eventually, mobility, the large suppliers that are most serious about WiMAX, such as Nortel, are set to develop their own products, loosening their ties with the specialists. This will create a degree of shake-out in the 2007-8 timeframe, but at least those companies with a strong partnership for 802.16-2004 have a breathing space to extend their business in other directions ‘ especially though licensing, as we have seen SR Telecom doing – or secure an attractive acquisition. For Wi-Lan there was no such luxury, as its cashflow was weak, and it had failed to gain a big name licensee. It will now phase out the equipment business by the end of April, saying this arm was not profitable and the company has been ‘unable to sustain the costs of development expense of its products while also growing the intellectual property business’.
In August, it had already split off the IP unit as part of a move to take a more focused approach. This had earlier led it to place most of its Mobilis high speed transport-oriented technology into the hands of a Korean partner.
It said it is now looking for potential buyers for the equipment business and is ‘working with several other companies to form new approaches to market its existing IP systems, patent portfolio and expertise, and to develop new IP products for the wireless fixed and mobile markets’. It is to be hoped that the new strategy does not merely turn Wi-Lan into a patent hoarder seeking to take aggressive action against product developers, an increasingly common situation in the wireless world and one that merely serves to confuse the market and delay systems roll-out.
The intellectual property issue remains one of the uncertainties surrounding the progress of WiMAX. As well as the lurking threat that Qualcomm may claim patent rights to some aspects of 802.16e systems, particularly in the mobile IP area, the policies of the IEEE and WiMAX Forum on licensing have always been vague and unenforceable, especially with the accelerating trend for standards bodies to take existing de facto standards on board in order to speed time to market, rather than starting from scratch. Many players ‘ including a group of large cellcos led by Vodafone, which recently achieved a significant shift in EU rules on patent claims ‘ are calling for all intellectual property claims to be declared up-front during standards development, or relinquished, to avoid the rising risk of ‘patent ambushes’ when claims emerge only when a standard has been approved and is gaining market momentum.
Jeff Orr, executive at the WiMAX Forum and head of marketing, agreed the process is complex: ‘We need ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory (RAND) policies on intellectual property but if a standards body has the intention to use a de facto technology, RAND is hard to implement’. This could clearly apply to Qualcomm and its likely attempt to push its newly acquired Flarion Flash-OFDM technology as the basis for the 802.20 standard for mobile broadband, a potential alternative to 802.16e.
Patents are not the only complex issue facing the Forum, of course, as it races to meet the market’s expectations for certification of 802.16e equipment. Despite the long and often badly communicated process of getting the first 802.16-2004 gear out of the certification labs, run by Cetecom in Spain, the process does now seem to have gained momentum for the fixed wireless products, and confidence is growing. It is very important that this is maintained for the more critical 802.16e standard, and the Forum is showing signs of rising to that challenge.
Part of the problem for the initial testing effort was the expansion of WiMAX’ remit and market profile during the run-up to its standardization. From being a somewhat obscure technology for traditional fixed wireless and backhaul, it had taken on the mantle of being a mainstream consumer access and mobile network capable of delivering a triple play service for a major operator, and so had gained huge new political significance and the interest of many large players. This meant that the scope of the WiMAX Forum’s work had to stretch almost beyond its resources. For instance, Orr says far more products joined the queue for first stage certification than had been expected, and Cetecom has had to adjust its resources to meet the demand and ensure that companies can get into line within a few weeks. So far, a handful of 802.16-2004 products for the 3.5GHz FDD (frequency division duplex) profile have been certified of a total of over 30 in line, and the first 3.5GHz TDD systems will soon emerge too. The certification of 5.8Ghz fixed WiMAX gear will take place in parallel and will start as soon as a testbed of at least three products is checked into the lab to form the basis for the testing. Defining the 5.8GHz process should start within a few months and the actual certification will be quicker than for 3.5GHz, as areas like protocol conformance are common across different bands.
The Forum is now looking for ways to expand its laboratory facilities, either by using other Cetecom locations and/or signing new partners. This will be essential to cope with the addition of 802.16e to the process ‘ validation of test processes for the initial 802.16e profiles, which are currently under review, is expected to start around August, with the first certified products emerging at the turn of the year, though some vendors like Motorola will launch pre-certified gear that is built to the ‘e’ specifications but only tested unofficially.
Additional lab capacity will also be needed as WiMAX continues to expand its remit ‘ new profiles are being considered, particularly to meet the frequency allocations in special case markets like Japan and Russia. The aim, according to Orr, is to have mainstream testing centers for 802.16e in the three key geographies ‘ Europe, Americas and Asia-Pacific ‘ and some localized labs for countries with specialized profile requirements, notably Japan, China and Korea. The Forum is facing the classic dilemma of a would-be global wireless network ‘ reducing the standard to just a few profiles encourages uniformity, volume and attractive pricing, as well as appealing to operators with support for global roaming; but some important markets will not harmonize their spectrum policies for years to come and must not be excluded. This dilemma afflicted 5GHz Wi-Fi but was relatively easily solved since there was only one major profile affected and many countries are moving into line with ITU guidelines on license-exempt 5GHz rules. For WiMAX, with profiles in licensed bands that are different allocated and governed in different regions, the challenge is far more complex.
To try to keep important economies, despite their peculiar spectrum maps, in the WiMAX fold, the Forum is recruiting ‘champions’ in key growth markets to promote the technology with operators and regulators. Initially these will be in China, India, Brazil and Russia.
This international activity, and the broadening scope and acceleration of certification, both reflect the high ambitions of WiMAX. Intellectual property issues are one risk area that need to be addressed in a coherent manner, and this may be complicated by the increasing reliance of small vendors on their patents store as they become less able to compete on the sales front. It is important that specialists with important technology to add value to WiMAX gain their success through positive means ‘ by attracting partners to license their platforms through the strength of those products’ performance (Aperto is a good example), not purely by patent hoarding. As 802.16e appears and certified products start to flood the market on the fixed side too, the specialists will need to build quickly on their unique strengths in OFDM expertise and broadband wireless intellectual property, if they are not to be swamped by the majors.