The wireless middleware market is set to explode, but to take advantage will require heavy investment from the players, in acquisitions and in strong Wi-Fi enablement of older product sets.
Most contenders have come from a heritage of providing synchronized links between mobile users on laptops or PDAs to corporate email servers. Now full wireless access is the key, and enterprises are starting to build a broader set of applications around their mobile information servers, with field workers accessing all kinds of corporate information via the Wi-Fi or cellular connection. This trend will create a 36.5% compound annual growth rate in the mobile middleware sector, according to IDC predictions, and revenues of $1.6bn by 2007. Average seat deployment is rising with the average deal now in the 100-500 range, IDC says.
Pumatech is one of the specialists hoping to take a strong position, and its recent moves have been a blueprint for how start-ups can hope to succeed in a market where Microsoft Mobile Information Server and Lotus Notes/Domino are always lurking. It has significantly upgraded its software to improve wireless capabilities; and it has made a string of acquisitions to raise its fighting weight and to broaden the markets that it targets ‘ it now spans both enterprise and operator bases through the acquisition of Starfish Software, for instance.
Such moves have brought it four consecutive quarters of revenue growth and in its fourth quarter, announced last week, it saw revenue up 66% year-on-year to $7.3m. However, it is still lossmaking (with a 2003 fiscal net loss fo $1.8m, reduced from $3.8m the year before) and its recent acquisition spree has been costly for a company of this size. As well as Starfish, which targets mobile carriers, it acquired two other organizations during its fourth quarter alone ‘ Loudfire, which provides access to email from a web browser; and Spontaneous Technology, a provider of carrier-grade virtual private networks.
Like most of the specialists, timing will be all for Pumatech. On the one hand, the company and its rivals have to invest to increase their product functionality and their market weight in order to survive at all in this crowded space. On the other, with enterprises adopting wireless applications steadily rather than rapidly, it will be another year before they can expect to reap serious rewards. Many will not survive ‘ there are over 40 enterprise-focused wireless middleware suppliers, 27 of these niche players, the rest big names such as Oracle or Software AG that have acquired or developed their own mobile platform.. By the end of 2004, we can expect a few more general purpose software houses to have followed this trend, but to see only about five of the specialists remaining independent.
Those that do, therefore, will be ones with the financial reserves to survive the transition period, with a fully wireless-enabled and richly functional product suite, and with strong relationships with larger companies. In our view, the strongest player in this respect is Synchrologic, picked out by Gartner Group last October as the most visionary company in the sector. The company has consistently delivered advanced products ahead of the competition and recently upgraded its Push Mobile technology, which pushes urgent communications and files to mobile devices, to support Wi-Fi. It also has a good installed base and has been skilful in taking advantage of the uncertainty about which mobile enterprise and web services platforms will win through, because it has strong interoperability and is neutral towards .Net or WebSphere. However, its strongest vendor ties are with Microsoft, with which it is likely to be a major partner for developing heterogeneous applications based on Mobile Information Server.
The grandfather of wireless middleware was, of course, RIM, which pioneered mobile enterprise email. But even aside from its ongoing legal battles, the company failed to maintain its lead over other players and has become one among many, with no significant base outside the US. It has at least, finally, divorced the email server software from its own BlackBerry handhelds, and has a viable chance ‘ if it settles its lawsuit with NTP ‘ of creating a wireless software business. However, like its rivals, it needs a strong industry alliance to survive and acquisition is likely to be the best course for its long suffering shareholders. It did have a significant software partnership with Nokia, but this was overshadowed when the Finnish company bought Eizel to be the heart of its own wireless middleware offering for corporate users. Now, the most likely outcome is acquisition by Hewlett Packard, which is lagging behind IBM and Microsoft in making a mobile enterprise push.
HP also markets a messaging server from another of the strongest wireless middleware players, Extended Systems, which makes OneBridge Mobile Groupware for cellular or Wi-Fi devices. Like Synchrologic, Extended now offers push email, once the defining characteristic of the RIM system, and illustrating once more how BlackBerry has lost most of its differentiation.
Differentation is now more apparent at Extended, Pumatech and Synchrologic than at RIM. In technology and functionality terms, these are now the strongest players, providing superior capabilities to those of the big name but highly general products from Microsoft and IBM. Synchrologic is private and does not report financial results, while Extended and Pumatech are of a very similar size. There was just $100,000 difference in their fourth quarter revenues (Extended reported $7.4m, although its year-on-year growth was slower at 44%. Extended has just broken into profit though, with Q4 net income of $118,000, reversing last year’s $2.2m loss).
All three are growing on the back of an expansion of usage of their server software. Whereas it was previously used purely for enterprise email and PIM applications, the wireless middleware is increasingly being incorporated into apps such as customer relationship management and salesforce automation, as enterprises built on their email infrastructure and business applications houses integrate third party wireless technology into their packages.
The importance of intellectual property and licensing revenues, and of staying a step ahead in technology terms, is illustrated by the litigiousness of this sector, something that threatens to create confusion and irritation and leave the door open for the less functional but more predictable big names. RIM’s legal battles with NTP, Good and Xerox are well publicized and have surely dampened enterprise enthusiasm for basing investments on BlackBerry. Pumatech has been embroiled in lawsuits against both Synchrologic and Extended, alleging patent infringement, and is seeking an injunction to stop Extended selling its software at all, just as NTP is against RIM. Such legal actions may be inevitable in a sector where software houses are as dependent on licensing deals as on direct sales (56% of Pumatech’s revenue is from licensing, for instance, which makes it highly protective of its patents), but they do create uncertainty and drive customers into safer hands.
This gives the real power to the large players that acquire strong technology to flesh out their own software. So, as well as a wave of mergers of start-ups in the past year, we have also seen a series of acquisitions by giants ‘ one that is certainly not over. Most significant were Nokia’s takeover of Eizel, signalling the handset maker’s deadly seriousness about becoming a supplier of enterprise business platforms; and the purchase of AvantGo, an early pioneer of wireless middleware, by Sybase unit iAnywhere.
Of the non-independents, iAnywhere is currently the best placed. It overtook RIM in the number one spot for email servers two quarters after buying AvantGo and has enormously strong and well respected technologies to place around the middleware, including its ultra-small database and mobile development tools.
Microsoft and IBM cannot, of course, be ignored because of their dominant positions in the enterprise base but both need to improve the functionality of their products in terms of ease of use and integration, probably by acquiring a start-up or two. Nokia, which is naturally mainly focused on the cellular rather than the WLan client, had the same problem until it made the shrewd move of picking up Eizel, one of the most innovative of the start-ups and also the most clearly corporate-focused.
The market is wide open. When Gartner Group published one of its magic quadrants for this sector last autumn, it placed no company in the ‘leaders’ category, combining complete vision with ability to execute. Only RIM, IBM and Microsoft were, at that time, considered to have strong ability to execute, because of their installed bases and resources, though clearly the players we have outlined would now move into their orbit. Synchrologic was the only visionary and all the others were categorized as niche players. The battle now commences, to see which of those niche operators can establish itself sufficiently strongly to be one of the small handful that lives to see 2005.
Mobile wireless players:
Independents:
RIM
Aether Systems
Synchrologic
Extended Systems
Pumatech (acquired Starfish and LoudPC)
WaveLink
Thinque Systems
Air2Web
MDSI
Broadbeam
Everypath
Aligo
Seven
ViAir
Visto
Infowave
Jarna
Mobile Airwaves
Smartner (acquired Commtag May 2003)
Good
InfoClarus
JP Mobile
Palm
Covigo
FusionOne
Psion Software
Sofor
Mobeon
Orsus
Xora
Some of these, such as Mobeon, Seven, Mobile Airwaves, Wireless Knowledge, ViAir and Smartner, mainly sell through licensing to mobile carriers and are therefore focused on the cellular link only at this stage. Others mainly support a mixture of Wi-Fi, cellular and synchronization and will need to provide all options to be mainstream in the enterprise.
Big names:
iAnywhere (bought AvantGo January 2003)
IBM/Lotus
Microsoft Mobile Information Server
Oracle
SAP
Sun
Nokia (acquired Eizel April 2003)
Peoplesoft
Hewlett-Packard
Siebel
BEA Systems
Software AG
Dell (through alliance with Good)
Qualcomm (through Wireless Knowledge subsidiary)
Palm ThinAir
Several of these players will make acquisitions in the coming few months. Logical tips would include Dell to take over its technology partner Good, for both its devices and its back end software; HP to buy RIM or Extended (if not, both these companies would be attractive to other predators, including SAP, Sun or even Microsoft). Synchrologic would be a more natural choice for Microsoft and also a possible for Sony Ericsson, which needs an enterprise software platform (Synchrologic recently ported its Email Accelerator to Symbian, the mobile phone OS of choice for Sony Ericsson).