Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 November 2005

Only decisive spectrum policies will save US from a return to Ma Bell

The concept of the competitive carrier is almost a dead one in the US now. While the wireline CLEC (competitive local exchange carrier) has struggled for years, and been dealt a body blow by recent FCC decisions, it seems on the surface that the wireless version is in a far stronger position. The FCC has been far kinder to independent wireless service providers than to wireline challengers, and two key developments have put new weapons into their hands ‘ the rise of the MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) approach and the emergence of WiMAX-style technologies that allow operators to bypass the incumbents’ copper in the last mile. But the FCC’s kindness has been mainly aimed at the rural market, which remains problematic in terms of profitable business models, while in the most attractive sectors, challengers will need spectrum rights to offer services that support a serious growth model. And while the legendary shortage of telecoms spectrum in the US is something of a myth, it is true that the vast bulk of the useful bands are held by a few large companies ‘ companies that will increasingly consolidate among themselves, and wipe out smaller players in their path, in their quest to control the balance of power.

As SBC completed its acquisition of AT&T, and took the venerable, if tarnished, name for itself, an extreme scenario was no longer looking far-fetched ‘ that the battle for the US market, now defined in terms of the ‘screen’ rather than the ‘line’, would be fought between just two Bell operators, AT&T and Verizon, plus the cabal of major cablecos, with Sprint Nextel the arbitrator. With the exception of Clearwire, the major potential disruptive force because of its huge spectrum ownership, the only genuinely independent forces would be have to be in unlicensed frequencies which, while they can support localized businesses and creative approaches to the market, come with all kinds of downsides, notably interference. Even the much discussed challenge from the Google business model will be severely limited by the restrictions that unlicensed spectrum will put on the real usefulness of the services it can deliver. There will be far more brands for consumers to choose from, that is true, at least in the short term, because of the MVNOs, but these are totally reliant on the spectrum holders, notably Sprint Nextel, in the same way that the CLECs were on Bellco copper. And the MVNOs are facing their own consolidation too.

The power to change this depressing scenario lies primarily with the FCC, which gains a new commissioner this month. There needs to be new spectrum allocated that supports competitive services and comes in large enough chunks, and with low enough prices, to support a major competitive challenge ‘ but which also carries safeguards against interference. Whether this means adapting the rules proposed for the 3.65GHz band, making some brave decisions on the 700MHz analog TV frequencies and the 2GHz satellite communications territory, or accelerating the introduction of effective anti-interference laws into unlicensed bands, clear statements of direction will be needed before next year is out. While the regulatory policies, state and federal legislation and lobbyists’ arguments will be slow to agree, the Regional Bell operators and Sprint Nextel have shown remarkable swiftness of action recently and will seek to shift the goal posts as far as possible to their own advantage before another, and more pro-competitive, sea change can occur within the FCC.

Consolidation:

While all the politicians’ talk regarding telecoms is about promoting increased competition, in reality this has not led to significant additional consumer choice of suppliers, although it is having some impact on expanding broadband and triple play (voice, video and high speed data) services to rural and other underserved communities. But in the attractive markets ‘ the densely packed urban and affluent suburban communities plus the enterprise ‘ the story has all been about consolidation on a massive scale. At the top end of the market, in little more than a year we have seen the six major cellular operators reduced to four; and two of the long lines operators, AT&T and (soon) MCI snapped up by Bellcos. This has had a trickle-down effect, with an ongoing wave of mergers between tier two and three wireless and wireline operators, the latest example being Alltel’s purchase of Midwest Wireless. The same trend is affecting the larger wireless ISPs, as all companies recognize that survival is largely about scale ‘ in terms of negotiating power with equipment makers and spectrum or wireline owners, and brand recognition among customers. Brand is the main advantage that the MVNOs have, but even before most of them are officially launched, there are signs of shake-out in that sector too, and fresh doubts over which companies, apart from Sprint Nextel, the main leasor of spectrum, will really cash in.

Even among the largest players, the mergers and acquisitions may not have ended yet. In particular, there has been intense speculation for months that SBC, now that its purchase of AT&T has finalized, will put in a bid for BellSouth ‘ one that might well be countered by the other major Bellco, Verizon. Given that the current regulatory climate might actually allow such a deal to go through, this must be an option SBC is considering. It certainly has to do something about Cingular, its cellular joint venture with its fellow Bell. This was fine when cellular operations were entirely separate from wireline ones, and when the Bell operators were confined to their own territories. Now, both SBC and BellSouth will want to integrate mobility increasingly tightly into their converged offerings, making it more attractive to have full control over the cellular arm. And they will be competing with each other, with AT&T’s national activities and enterprise business coming up against BellSouth in its home regions, and BellSouth potentially using its broadband wireless projects, and its close partnership with Sprint on long lines, to move into new geographies without needing to own or lease wires.

So the new AT&T needs full control of Cingular, which is its key growth driver, and it may find it more advantageous to buy the whole of BellSouth rather than seeking to buy it out of the joint venture. Outright acquisition might be preferable for BellSouth too. Although WiMAX gives it a longer term option to broaden its territorial reach and compensate for the loss of Cingular, for the first few years, being wireline-only again would make it a larger version of Qwest, confined to its increasingly stagnant home territories and wireline markets because of the lack of national coverage in any technology with which to take on AT&T/SBC and Verizon.

Another option for BellSouth could be to charge a premium to sell its share of Cingular ‘ Vodafone might help push up the price by indicating interest, as it did when Cingular bought AT&T Wireless last year ‘ and tighten its already closening relationship with Sprint Nextel. It currently uses Sprint’s long distance lines for enterprise and backhaul services, where it does not have its own, as an alternative to buying its own long lines company as SBC and Verizon did. If it were no longer competing with Sprint Nextel in cellular, it could take this concept further and lease its CDMA and broadband wireless spectrum as Qwest already does. A merger between the two might not even be inconceivable, though it would rob Sprint Nextel of its greatest advantage, its lack of significant local lines business, which gives it the ability to be the spectrum provider, and power broker, between the various competing last mile operators, as highlighted in its far reaching alliance with the major cablecos.

Cellcos:

The cellular market is also shifting rapidly, with the mega-mergers among the big six being echoed among the regional carriers, even as the brand choices available to consumers expand because of the MVNOs. T-Mobile USA – now the fourth largest cellco but a minnow compared to the big three, and one with a shortage of coverage and spectrum ‘ has some big choices to make. Its parent Deutsche Telekom recently ruled out a sale of its greatest growth engine in the near future, and recently hinted that T-Mobile, as well as putting aside large sums to buy new spectrum and belatedly build out 3G, would look to expand by buying up regional carriers, an activity that in some markets could be more cost effective than bidding for licenses.

Valuations for companies like Midwest Wireless, which the largest regional cellco, Alltel, has agreed to acquire, have trebled since 2003 as the major players start to take an interest in rural markets, with their core markets saturating. Alltel will pay $1.08bn, more than 10 times the smaller carrier’s EBITDA earnings, expected to be about $100m this year on revenues of $250m.

Midwest, in which Verizon had also taken an interest, may have gone, but T-Mobile could look to other fairly large tier two players such as Centennial Communications of New Jersey, the US’ third largest independent cellco, which is up for sale and expected to go for over $1.5bn. Other options include Rural Cellular and US Cellular.

Earlier this year, Alltel acquired Western Wireless for $6bn, and looks set to piece together a near-national network that could approach T-Mobile in size and even prove attractive to its most important roaming partner, Verizon Wireless ‘ although that company, while it has invested extensively in new spectrum this year, seems more inclined to accumulate new markets gradually than go for a big acquisition.

There has also been considerable consolidation of spectrum holdings among the regional carriers as they look to bulk up to preserve their independence or increase their attractiveness to predators. For instance, Alltel agreed with US Cellular last fall to swap 15 rural markets in Nebraska and Kansas that it acquired with Western Wireless, in exchange for two Rural Service Area markets in Idaho currently operated by US Cellular plus $50m in cash.

It is increasingly hard for local carriers to invest in the technology required to deliver the advanced 3G and converged services that will become necessary to drive ARPU growth in all but the most remote and underserved territories. This was made very clear by the outcry from the Sprint and Nextel affiliate operators on news of the merger. The Sprint partners argued that they could only remain competitive in their regions because of the non-compete clauses they had with Sprint itself, which would be compromised by the fact that Nextel operated in most of their territories. The upshot, after various legal battles, has been for Sprint to acquire nearly all its former affiliates, including, last week, Alamosa Holdings, the largest of the group (apart from Nextel’s only one, Nextel Partners, which is in acquisition negotiations). The acquisition of Alamosa is worth a total of $4.3bn, including $900m in net debt. Alamosa’s 1.48m subscribers mean that Sprint’s series of affiliate deals has netted it about 2.3m additional customers. Though the main motivation was to end destructive legal wrangling, the series of deals also shows the trend for large carriers to start to buy up, rather than partner with, localized players.

However, such trends are not universal. The tier one players may be casting their territorial nets more widely, but there remain many markets in which they have little interest. If these are neglected purely because of sparse populations or low income levels, the situation will remain unchanged, with these areas being served by small companies with modest growth ambitions. But increasingly, alternative operators are identifying customer groups that have good growth and ARPU potential but are too small or fragmented to appeal to the majors ‘ which in any case, have never been good at targeted, segmented marketing. This is where the MVNOs have shone, often using an existing brand and customer base, as Virgin Mobile has done, to go after a well defined group with highly targeted offerings. There are even some ‘non-virtual’ operators looking to do the same, and this year has seen two new regional carriers in the US that have decided to own rather than lease their spectrum. Nex-Tech Wireless has a highly specific focus, on the agricultural market of Kansas, which it says is underserved but affluent, while another new entrant, Revol, is targeting under-25s in Ohio. The key to success is not to try to go head-to-head with a major player and its marketing budget but to fill gaps and target consumers who feel sidelined by the tier one offerings and branding messages. Revol said that, while it is taking an MVNO-like approach to branding, it rejected the spectrum leasing route because its business model and pricing would be at the mercy of the carrier that owns the spectrum.

However, most companies, particularly if they want to operate across broader territories, do not have access to spectrum and so need to take the MVNO path. And with so many of these virtual operators set to launch in the US, we can expect consolidation and shake-out quickly to follow. In theory, a three-layered cellular market is developing in the US. Most prominent are the major national players that are including mobile services in a converged triple play. So the Bellcos are adding television to their existing strengths in mobile, voice and data, while the cablecos are filling in the mobile and voice gaps, with Sprint Nextel the enabler of the latter. Then there is the market that is not ready for the full blown mobile triple play but merely wants to buy cellular voice and some basic data such as SMS. This remains the bread and butter of the tier one cellcos in urban markets, and will drive the ROI on 3G networks for some time to come, but in the rural areas is often catered for by the regional players and, increasingly, the rising breed of flat rate providers. Thirdly, there is the idea of mobile as part of a broader set of services that are lifestyle related and also include finance, shopping and travel, and this is the territory of the targeted MVNO. The problem is, too many of the brands that have taken an interest in MVNOs are after the same audience ‘ youngish, fashionable, with high disposable income and interest in media. With some variations, Virgin, Helio (the SKT-Earthlink venture), ESPN and Amp’d are all after this base, as are many other mooted projects. Most of these are dependent on Sprint Nextel for spectrum and since there are no rules equivalent to the pricing caps that some regulators put on charging for access to wired lines, Sprint will be able to name its price in many situations, taking advantage of the competition between its own partners to divide and rule. The existence of a large number of MVNOs with similar targets will put the power back with the spectrum owner. While Sprint ‘ and to a lesser extent Verizon ‘ originally needed MVNOs as a way to reach groups its own branded service would not touch, and to use excess capacity, in a competitive market Sprint’s reliance on its partners is considerably lessened. The most successful MVNOs, and the ones that get the best deals from the frequency owners, will be those that have a brand with a unique customer profile, or which get to a certain market segment early. And, of course, those that avoid treading on their cellco master’s toes. iGillott Research has called MVNOs the ‘CLECs of the new millennium’ on the basis that, once they start eating into cellco revenue and margin rather than supplementing it, the big guns will have the power to crush them, since they own no real assets beyond their brands ‘ and brands still need a delivery vehicle.

We would expect to see the more opportunistic MVNOs disappear quickly; the well established ones like Virgin and Boost becoming part of the landscape; but the real success lying with those that use an MVNO as a toehold in the market, but have the weight and resources to move towards owning their own assets. Thus the cablecos may lease spectrum off Sprint Nextel, but they have a complex relationship in which their ownership of last mile networks gives them equal power; and some MVNOs like Helio will also invest in building their own systems, in SK-Earthlink’s case through WiMAX and municipal metrozones, potentially bypassing even the Bells’ long lines by using wireless backhaul.

But the example of Helio brings us back to the initial point ‘ that while a large scale ISP, skirting round Bellco lines and fees by delivering services through various forms of wireless, looks disruptive to the Bell control of the customer, it still has the potentially fatal risk factor of not owning spectrum. This means that in licensed spectrum it is at the mercy of its leasing partner; and in WiMAX or Wi-Fi it is confined to license-exempt bands that are riddled with interference and, in the case of 5GHz, do not support mobile usage. These bands are fine for delivering best effort internet services to underserved areas or casual users; they are not fine for creating a triple play, or a business offering, with the quality of service that would justify charging more than a basic flat rate ‘ or, in Google’s case, nothing at all.

A few operators, notably Clearwire, will succeed in purchasing enough useful spectrum ‘ which for triple play really means under 3GHz ‘ to create a national or regional service. But the prices are rising and the supply running out, and new allocations of 3G bands ‘ and potentially, the opening of the 2GHz satellite band to broadband wireless ‘ will be at prices affordable only by the largest players. This leaves all the hopes focused on two bands that are subject to upcoming FCC decision on rules and licensing ‘ analog TV around 700MHz and 3.65GHz. The former is beset by complex debates over how soon the television broadcasters should vacate, whether wireless technologies could move in before that date without causing interference, and how much of the spectrum should be retained for public safety amid the current and vexed rebanding process below 900MHz. There are also many arguments over whether any, or even all, of the 700MHz band that has not been already allocated (mainly to Qualcomm and Aloha) should be license-exempt. While 700MHz has many advantages in terms of propagation, nobody can base a business plan on it until these decisions are made.

In 3.65GHz, there are fewer issues and most controversy has centered on whether the FCC will continue to mandate a contention-based protocol to guard against interference, a specification that would exclude WiMAX (though support Wi-Fi). Beyond that key technical debate, however, the overall approach to 3.65GHz could be a model for opening up new spectrum to competitive carriers, since it introduces a light licensing system that costs very little to the operator, but insists on a ‘good neighbor’ code that includes the use of certain technologies to avoid interference with other providers nearby. Should 700MHz be opened up under similar terms, the technology specified would be likely to be a cognitive radio standard currently under development by the IEEE 802.22 committee, which would enable equipment to detect and avoid potentially conflicting signals.

The thinking on both these bands has focused on helping rural areas get better access to broadband. The downside of that focus is that the FCC is likely to devise rules that favour small rural carriers, which does little to provide a counterbalance to the Bells and Sprint Nextel, because it does not provide a real additional choice for consumers across the whole country. Instead, it preserves the status quo ‘ allowing the rural carriers, as they run out of resources to invest in 3G or fiber, an alternative way to stay in business, but not opening significant new options. As recent consolidation among tier two operators shows, the rural players actually strengthen the majors by partnering with them through roaming deals, while not forcing them to build out in marginally profitable communities. Also, one proposed approach of reserving some of the 700MHz band for small parcels of rural spectrum also has its problems, as does excluding major bidders altogether, another common demand by the public broadband lobbyists. These problems revolve around the risks that small players, whether rural cellcos or start-ups, will acquire licenses but lack the resources to build out networks or to run them at a profit. This could lead to patchy coverage and a long line of failed ventures and wasted spectrum.

The effect of 3.65GHz and 700MHz availability will only be disruptive if this spectrum can be placed in the hands of a powerful, national operator ‘ not necessarily a current telco, but a company with the resources to build a network over wide territories, launch innovative services and preferably own its own backhaul too. This would create a true independent with no obligations to AT&T, Verizon or Sprint, and so with true freedom of action. Clearwire is the closest candidate right now, though in its early stages and with many risk factors surrounding its model. Other potential contenders, from Intel or Qualcomm to Helio to a major consumer brand, would all need to get their hands on spectrum and infrastructure to achieve that freedom of action ‘ at least in a second stage, after establishing a brand in unlicensed frequencies and/or an MVNO. The well intentioned proposals to parcel new spectrum up in small chunks affordable by rural operators (see inset) could jettison such a development by robbing a major non-telco player of the chance to buy a national license for some time to come (unless it got really brave and went up against the telcos for a 3G license). And that breathing space would be enough to allow the triumvirate of Verizon, AT&T and Sprint Nextel to consolidate their power for a whole generation.

BOX

The hundreds of US rural wireless carriers are fighting to survive with stronger alliances, particularly to increase their negotiating power when purchasing handsets; with programs to talk up the local market knowledge and high customer service levels they claim; and with a campaign to gain more spectrum, in particular in the 700MHz band.

Some of the 700MHz band is already allocated ‘ Qualcomm has a national license for its MediaFLO mobile broadcasting system, while Aloha Partners is another major holder, and is trialling Flash-OFDM technology. Other available licenses are being bought up by speculators such as Paul Allen’s Vulcan Ventures, in anticipation of their increased value in the coming years.

It is not finally decided yet how much of the remainder of the available band will be licensed or unlicensed, or what the terms of use will be, but the broadband wireless community is eager to gain access to these frequencies. One body of operators that could take advantage would be the rural cellcos. These could run a broadband wireless network in parallel with their existing GSM or CDMA systems to deliver 3G-style services and beyond, for a far lower cost than an upgrade to 3G, which even large carriers are finding cost prohibitive in sparsely populated rural areas because of the density of base stations required (the same pressures are leading to the adoption of 450MHz solutions by European operators in rural regions).

Aware that broadband wireless could be its members’ lifeline, the Rural Cellular Association (RCA) has asked the FCC to change the band plan for 700MHz to favor rural services.

“RCA asks that the FCC make portions of the spectrum that is yet to be auctioned available according to smaller service areas than are presently planned. Such action will facilitate and accelerate the availability of competitive broadband services in rural areas of the country. It will also yield, by all reasonable expectations, increased participation in the auctions and increased revenues for the US Treasury,” said David Nace, the RCA’s outside counsel, in a filing in August. “The most effective means by which the FCC can foster the prompt availability of competitive wireless broadband services to rural markets is to make available more licenses in the upper and lower 700MHz bands with service areas no larger than rural service areas and metropolitan service areas.”

Current expectation is that licenses will be auctioned by economic areas, which allows for only six licenses per block in the nation. This would only be in reach of rural cellcos if several banded together on a national basis.

Of the 700MHz spectrum to be freed up by the transition to digital television, 36MHz will be allocated for public safety (or possibly more) and 48MHz will be auctioned, in addition to the frequencies already owned. While the rural carriers lobby for small parcels that they could realistically acquire, other potential bidders will be eager for the chance of a national license. These could include major vendors such as Intel and Cisco, which want to ensure the spectrum is controlled by forces friendly to their all-IP plans; large telcos and cellcos seeking to supplement their existing networks; well funded start-ups such as Clearwire; or even public sector bodies.

A Congressional Caucus has been formed to lobby for 20MHz of unlicensed spectrum to be taken out of the available 48MHz in the band. This Wireless Caucus contends that unregulated broadband wireless is the only way to extend broadband access into rural America, especially if local cellcos cannot afford to build out 3G and large players do not bother to do so. Jim Snider, a fellow with the New America Foundation, was quoted in several articles as saying, said: “This transition is about broadcasting to broadband. Using wires to deliver broadband to rural America is insane. It is like using a golden hammer when a wooden hammer would do.”

BOX

The FCC may have a disappointing track record in terms of wireline competition, but a recent ISP conference concluded that it had been, on balance, a benefactor to wireless ISPs. The main areas where service providers praised the regulator for its recent record on promoting competition were:

‘ Fostering of cognitive radios
‘ Simpler Part 15 rules on interference
‘ Opening the 3.65GHz band
‘ Licensed spectrum leasing
‘ Increasing the unlicensed UNII band to 255MHz in size
‘ The possibility of allowing WISPs into 700MHz alongside broadcasters

All these options add to the store of usable spectrum, in real terms, by allowing multiple operators to coexist in the same bands without wrecking each others’ services, a development that is helping to cure the US’ spectrum famine